“Security is mostly a superstition. Life is either a daring adventure or nothing.”
Helen Keller
In 1991, the Administration for Children and Families was created within the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. ACF encompassed the original Children’s Bureau and took over child support enforcement and child welfare.
In the trenches, the battle heated up.
In 1991, protective mothers and their supporters in Houston, Texas began protesting a decision by Judge Allen Daggett to give custody of a 3-year-old to her father, a convicted rapist who was accused of molesting the little girl. The picketing led to the HBO docudrama America Undercover: Women on Trial by Lee Grant about four mothers’ stories. There was a lawsuit. The docudrama never aired, but the women persisted.
Carole Bell Ford later wrote The Women of CourtWatch: Reforming a Corrupt Family Court System about Donna Ringoringo who chained herself to columns at the courthouse and went on a hunger strike, Phrogge Simon who camped out on the courthouse steps day and night for over a year and attorney Florence Kusnetz who led a Political Action Committee (PAC) that eventually got rid of five bad judges.
Judges justifiably feared court watch and PACs by such fierce activists.

The same year, 1992, teenager Kelly Wilson mysteriously disappeared in Gilmer, Texas. The story was brought forth by Dateline in A Touch of Evil.
Texas is the only state with jury trials for divorce cases. Jury trials for family courts might not to be the entire answer, although they would be a step up from a single biased judge. Few protective mothers could afford an attorney, much less a full trial. Judges also still have the power to exclude evidence.
The opposition responded with a telling “how-to” book on divorce published in 1991. It was bluntly titled Screw the Bitch: Divorce Tactics for Men by Dave Hart. The picture on the front cover is worth a thousand words.

That year, a program called Family Bridges began in Mill Valley CA and quietly began its work. The website states it is a “Workshop for Troubled and Alienated Parent Child Relationships.” The focus is to re-bond children who are “alienated” from a parent, with little or no regard for the underlying reason for the children’s dislike or fear of that parent.
Texas-based Richard Warshak helped develop the forced reunification program run by Randy Rand, an unlicensed psychologist, and his wife Diedre with the help of Marin County psychologist Ed Oklan. The 4-day workshops could happen anywhere, often in motel rooms and cost tens of thousands of dollars. But not many knew about this new approach at the time, as it operated under the radar screen.
The results of addressing the problem of domestic violence on federal and state levels were beneficial for many, yet the problems listed in H. Con. Res. 172 kept getting worse.
- State courts continued to fail to consistently hear, weigh evidence or recognize the detrimental effects on children when a parent physically abused a spouse. In fact, they frequently ignored or minimized all evidence of abuse.
- The “alarming bias” against battered parents continued to escalate, and more batterers were guaranteed access and control over their spouse’s life through their children.
- Joint custody and mandatory mediation became increasingly popular, forcing victims to have ongoing interaction with their violators. As one mother succinctly put it, “He dates me through court.”
When Karen Anderson and I first started trying to get a grip on family court, we didn’t know about most of these past efforts to keep domestic violence and their children safe.
How utterly naive we were when we first started trying to save the traumatized children who continued to be hurt by witnessing and/or becoming targets of abuse by a parent. The sense that marital conflict was acceptable was passed on to the next generation.
It came as a surprise how often intimate partner violence and child abuse occurred and how interconnected the two forms of violence are. Knowledge was growing as the wider culture began to understand its subtly and destructiveness, the difficulties of leaving a batterer, and the potential for generational violence, but it certainly was not a mainstream topic. Fortunately, that was changing.
Judith Herman articulated the problem of domestic trauma well in her 1992 landmark book Trauma and Recovery: The Aftermath of Violence – from Domestic Abuse to Political Terror.
In 1992, the California Judicial Council posted the Administrative Office of the Courts, Family Court Services Snapshot Study Report, and Overview of California Family Court Services Mediation 1991: Families, Cases and Client Feedback on their website.
In part, the study states, “In California, mediation is mandatory for all contested custody cases. In this statewide study of most custody mediation sessions conducted by court personnel on a single day, serious issues of child abuse, family violence and substance abuse were raised by the parties in 42% of all mediating families, with an additional 24% raising one of these issues alone.”
Mediators were grappling with crimes and addictions, trying to convince the victims and abusers to get along. What an overwhelming task that must have been.
“In this statewide study of most custody mediation sessions conducted by court personnel on a single day, serious issues of child abuse, family violence and substance abuse were raised by the parties in 42% of all mediating families, with an additional 24% raising one of these issues alone.”
The researchers also reported that in a review of five federally funded demonstration projects to resolve child access and visitation problems, ‘‘Nearly half of the access denial cases at every site involve allegations of the child’s imperiled safety.
Most allegations are made by the residential parent, regardless of sex, against the nonresidential parent and the other people in his/her household. Violent behavior is the only allegation that is consistently leveled with greater frequency against men.’’
Although 90% of the litigants in the study reported that they thought mediation was a helpful way to come up with a parenting plan, 86% said that they felt pressured to go along with things they did not want.
The major issue was and is that most contested custody cases were for situations far, far beyond simple mediation. Mental health professionals hired by the courts were trying to mediate violent crimes. Children’s safety was imperiled. Where were the headlines? Alarm bells? Radical changes? Nobody but a few researchers even noticed that the sky was falling on the children.
However, parents accused of incest by their adult children believed the sky was falling on them. They did not want exposure or lawsuits. Accused parents likewise banded together and found willing professionals to support them. They founded the False Memory Syndrome Foundation (FSMF) in 1992.
“False memory syndrome” was a created term designed to discount adult children’s testimony about crimes committed against them by parents in criminal court, exactly as “parental alienation syndrome” was created and designed to discount parent’s testimony about crimes committed against their children by the other parent in civil family court.
Co-founded by Peter and Pamela Freyd after their daughter remembered being viciously sexually abused by her father, the FMSF was finally dissolved on December 31, 2019. In between those years, many good trauma therapists found themselves traumatized by a flurry of lawsuits by their patients’ accused parents, blaming them for implanting false memories into their patients’ minds.
A professor at the University of Oregon, Peter and Pamela’s daughter Jennifer Freyd PhD was uniquely positioned as a respected psychologist when her parents attacked her. She developed the terms “institutional betrayal,” “institutional courage” and “DARVO,” an acronym for abusers’ tendency to “Deny, Attack, and Reverse Victim Offender” roles.

The government ratcheted up their efforts for child support, again not recognizing the unintended negative consequences. The Child Support Recovery Act of 1992 allowed states to prosecute parents who did not pay child support.
States were mandated to standardize child support, which was linked to earnings and the amount of parenting time. The downside was that this gave an even stronger incentive for parents to seek custody if did not want to pay support.