“Violence against women and children resembles an epidemic. It has spread through society, sparing no social group or class.”
Cyril Ramaphosa
Former domestic violence victim and attorney Joan Pennington founded the National Center for Protective Parents in Civil Child Sexual Abuse Cases in Trenton, New Jersey in 1992. Five years later, she founded the Women’s Law Project with a grant from the Department of Justice to fund sliding scale or pro bono legal services for victims. She wrote a superb paper titled Incest: The Hardest Case.
Myopic, we had not understood at that time that this virulent scourge was also happening in other states across the country. We also knew nothing about the first Mother’s Day demonstration in Washington DC, which was held on May 10, 1992. Protective mother and activist Maralee Mclean completely understood, and helped organize the event with attorney Joan Pennington and other early leaders on the East Coast to speak out against placing children at grave risk with their abusers.
It was an amazing networking feat to bring together a coalition of protective mothers, professionals, child sexual abuse survivors and others interested in protecting children.
On August 6, 1992, attorney Pennington gave testimony to the U. S. House of Representatives Judiciary Committee regarding the Judicial Training Act. Maralee and 10 other mothers testified. Attorney Pennington wanted to use Maralee’s case to bring attention to this social injustice since she had already garnered media attention around her case.
Maralee’s case mirrored those in California. After a marriage marred by domestic violence, she filed for divorce in 1987 and received sole custody of her infant daughter Julie. At age 2, the child described sexual abuse by her father.
Despite multiple police, medical, therapist, daycare provider and teacher reports of the child’s disclosures, including a Children’s Hospital Sexual Abuse report of physical evidence of sexual abuse, by 1992, Judge Michael Bieda had ordered the little girl into the full custody of her identified sex abuser.

Therapists Leona Kopetski and Dr. Claire Purcell reported falsely to the court when Maralee was not there that Maralee would run away with her child and had “Parental Alienation Syndrome.”
World renowned Colorado Kempe Center, founded in 1972 by Henry Kempe and his wife, were threatened with a lawsuit. The District Attorney had told Maralee that if she lost her child in family court, they would step in. They did not. Maralee and her daughter were relegated to supervised visits in a small room for one hour a week for the next 8 years.
The child deteriorated visibly and dissociated frequently, at times saying she just wanted to die. Finally at age 12, she was able to come home to her mother for a few hours and eventually was allowed to stay overnight. Twelve years of litigation, eight attorneys, and seven judges later, Maralee was broke, but not broken. Her book Prosecuted but not Silenced says it all.
She was the prime mover of the 1993 grassroots National Rally at the Denver Colorado State Capitol, with mothers who came from all fifty states. The preparation was tremendous. There were loudspeakers in the trees, port-a-potties, police notification, arrangements for a podium and microphone, a food tent, and a table for author’s books. Gold hearts on thick purple ribbon were placed around the mother’s necks as they went up to speak. Purple helium balloons with gold sparkle lettering floated above for each child forced to live with their abusers.
Joan Pennington compared the mothers’ movement to the civil rights movement of the 1960’s. She called it the movement of the 1990’s. She reminded the audience that It took 20 years for domestic violence survivors to be heard, and we did not have another 20 years to wait for this issue. Little did she know that a quarter of a century later, the problem would remain unresolved.
Her National Center had collected a list of mothers, and they decided to also collect a list of judges who sentenced children to a lifetime of abuse. At the end of her talk, she raised her fist and called out, “This is for you Julie!”
Joan Pennington compared the mothers’ movement to the civil rights movement of the 1960’s. She called it the movement of the 1990’s.
Other speakers included Congresswoman Pat Schroeder, author Louise Armstrong, NCADV president, and Glennie Rohelier from the Alliance for the Rights of Children who worked with Elizabeth Morgan.
The top attorneys in the field spoke, including Alan Rosenfeld, Garnett Harrison and Meera Fox, a young new attorney who was catching the grassroots efforts in the very beginning. All the news stations in Colorado covered the rally, with a full-page article in the Rocky Mountain News on July 7.
Maralee began to educate tirelessly. As the Executive Director of Moms Fight Back and Ambassador for Child USA she worked on Colorado bills SB-73 to eliminate the statute of limitations, SB 21-88 to give a 3 year window for civil suits against the institutions that did not protect children, and HB 21-1228 “Julie’s Law” to improve training for court personnel.
Other states were working toward the same goal of protecting child sex abuse victims. In 1992, Louisiana Legislature created a presumption against custody to domestic violence or sexual abuse, drafted by attorney Richard Ducote, an equally tireless advocate for vulnerable sexually abused children.
The Harvard Law Review called it “model legislation.”
§364. Child custody; visitation
A. There is created a presumption that no parent who has a history of perpetrating family violence, as defined in R.S. 9:362, or domestic abuse, as defined in R.S. 46:2132, or has subjected any of his or her children, stepchildren, or any household member, as defined in R.S. 46:2132, to sexual abuse, as defined in R.S. 14:403, or has willingly permitted another to abuse any of his children or stepchildren, despite having the ability to prevent the abuse, shall be awarded sole or joint custody of children. The court may find a history of perpetrating family violence if the court finds that one incident of family violence has resulted in serious bodily injury or the court finds more than one incident of family violence.
B. The presumption shall be overcome only if the court finds all of the following by a preponderance of the evidence:
(1) The perpetrating parent has successfully completed a court-monitored domestic abuse intervention program as defined in R.S. 9:362, or a treatment program designed for sexual abusers, after the last instance of abuse.
(2) The perpetrating parent is not abusing alcohol or using illegal substances scheduled in R.S. 40:964.
(3) The best interest of the child or children, considering the factors listed in Civil Code Article 134, requires the perpetrating parent’s participation as a custodial parent because of the other parent’s absence, mental illness, substance abuse, or other circumstance negatively affecting the child or children.
C. The fact that the abused parent suffers from the effects of the abuse shall not be grounds for denying that parent custody.
D. If the court finds that both parents have a history of perpetrating family violence, custody shall be awarded solely to the parent who is less likely to continue to perpetrate family violence. In such a case, the court shall mandate completion of a court-monitored domestic abuse intervention program by the custodial parent. If necessary to protect the welfare of the child, custody may be awarded to a suitable third person pursuant to Civil Code Article 133, provided that the person would not allow access to a violent parent except as ordered by the court.
E. If the court finds that a parent has a history of perpetrating family violence, the court shall allow only supervised child visitation with that parent pursuant to R.S. 9:341. F. If any court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, that a parent has sexually abused his or her child or children, the court shall prohibit all visitation and contact between the abusive parent and the children pursuant to R.S. 9:341.”
Both a Louisiana trial court and the Louisiana Supreme Court in Folse v. Folse ruled in 1999 that clear and convincing proof in a custody case of sexual abuse, sufficient to terminate the abuser’s visitation, was established by the child’s specific complaints, demonstrations of sexual abuse to her mother and others, including her therapist, and the child’s age-inappropriate knowledge of adult sexual behavior.
Like fleeing slaves who crossed the Mason Dixon line, children in Louisiana had a way to protect themselves. They could tell the truth.
By 1999, both a Louisiana trial court and the Louisiana Supreme Court in Folse v. Folse ruled that clear and convincing proof in a custody case of sexual abuse, sufficient to terminate the abuser’s visitation, was established by the child’s specific complaints, demonstrations of sexual abuse to her mother and others, including her therapist, and the child’s age-inappropriate knowledge of adult sexual behavior.