Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 16:  Inching Forward

“I think that maybe if women and children were in charge we would get somewhere.”

James Thurber

In 1992 the California legislature approved a law for private attorneys for children who could be appointed to represent the child’s best interests in custody disputes. It sounded heartening but turned out to be a disaster. 

“Best interests,” as we have said, was vaguely defined. Some children’s attorneys took full advantage of the vagueness and, if they were paid by the perpetrators, often acted as a second attorney for the person who was paying the bill. It happened so often that advocates later called the appointment of a child’s attorney the “kiss of death.”

Other child welfare measures were developed in the early 1990’s. Research began showing positive outcomes in reducing child abuse by home visitation programs.

young girl smiling

The federal government did not create a national universal program, but a patchwork of local and state programs arose.

In 1992, the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Administration (SAMHSA) was formed within the US Department of Health and Human Services, designed to “reduce the impact of substance abuse and mental illness.” There was no acknowledgement at the time that both issues generally sprang from, and created, child abuse, creating a vicious cycle.

We were beginning to realize that not all judges were paragons of virtue. An example is Judge James Stevens of Yolo County, who was reprimanded by the Yolo County Grand Jury in 1992 for waving a loaded pistol in court. He asked rhetorically, “What’s a little wife-beating?” in a domestic violence case, and presented a rotten zucchini phallic symbol to a court employee. The local press covered his abuses and sexual harassment. The county was sued. The judge received two public hand slaps by the Commission on Judicial Performance in 1994 and 1998  for his Wild West behavior, and mercifully retired.

An example is Judge James Stevens of Yolo County, who was reprimanded by the Yolo County Grand Jury in 1992 for waving a loaded pistol in court. He commented “What’s a little wife-beating?” in a domestic violence case…

Liz Richards founded the National Alliance for Family Court Justice in Washington DC in 1993. She analyzed the Men’s Rights groups, with a particular focus on the Children’s Rights Council, and worked hard to create a national organization to counteract their work of having abusive men get custody.  She tried to educate us, but it was hard to absorb the extent of the problem.

In 1993, the Social Security Act was amended to establish the Family Preservation and Family Support Program (FPFSP). It also established the Court Improvement Program. 

By 1993, police could arrest for misdemeanor restraining order violations without a warrant which put some teeth in the protection of abused women. Children were not able to get their own protection orders.

However, more attention was being given to child sexual abuse.

Over three hundred national experts and speakers from 3 presidential administrations participated in the high level Washington DC National Conferences on Crimes Against Children: The Sexual Exploitation of Children: Creating an Investigative and Research Agenda for the 21st Century (1993) and The Physical and Sexual Exploitation of Children: Evolving Strategies and Challenges to Research, Investigation and Prosecution (1994). 

The main tactic of abusers was and is to flatly deny the abuse and turn the blame on the victim or person reporting the abuse. In cases of child sexual abuse, the claim that the allegations were false was nearly universal but shown to be patently untrue.

The 1994 Canadian research Ontario Incidence Study of Reported Child Abuse and Neglect, Toronto: Institute for the Prevention of Child Abuseshowed that 9% of 42,000 allegations of child abuse involved separating or divorcing parents.

Only 1.3% of mothers and 21% of fathers’ allegations of child abuse were considered intentionally false. This flew in the face of the narrative by abusive fathers, who insisted mothers were making up false allegations in order to get custody. The fingers pretty much pointed right back at the abusive fathers. But the fathers’ right groups rolled on anyway, undeterred, repeating these falsehoods.

Only 1.3% of mothers and 21% of fathers’ allegations of child sexual abuse were considered intentionally false.

Things did not improve. Children were either left in dangerous homes by child welfare services or given to abusers by family courts. Child deaths were increasing. Proving sex abuse was difficult to do in any court, since there are usually no witnesses.

A 1994 study, confirmed by later research, found that girls who were sexually penetrated rarely showed abnormal vaginal examination findings.  That meant there would likely be no physical evidence of child rape.

A 1994 study, confirmed by later research, found that girls who were sexually penetrated rarely showed abnormal vaginal examination findings.  That meant there would likely be no physical evidence of child rape.

The child’s testimony was all a prosecutor would have to go on, since there were usually no witnesses. The good news was that to convict a perpetrator in a criminal trial in Louisiana, all it took was the testimony of an eight-year-old child sexual abuse victim, thanks to their excellent legal protections. “[T]he victim’s testimony alone is sufficient to establish a prima facie case of either rape or sexual abuse.”

“[T]he victim’s testimony alone is sufficient to establish a prima facie case of either rape or sexual abuse.”

But that proof was not considered sufficient for family court even to protect a child under the much lower civil “preponderance of the evidence” burden of proof. The Superior Court of Pennsylvania noted that “preponderance of the evidence is defined as the greater weight of the evidence, i.e., to tip a scale slightly is the criteria or requirement for preponderance of the evidence.”

Except in Louisiana, family courts were ignoring children’s reports of sex abuse even when there was medical evidence. Parental Alienation Syndrome (PAS) was everywhere, like the plague, used to undermine the person who brought issues of child sexual abuse to the court. 

In 1994, Cheri Wood published The Parental Alienation Syndrome: A Dangerous Aura of Reliability, stating, “PAS testimony should not be admitted in court because of the causation and evidentiary problems with the theory. Because of the dangerous aura of reliability and trustworthiness extant in Dr. Gardner’s self- published theory, admission of PAS is inevitable and particularly disconcerting.” 

That year, Jessica Pearson and Jean Anhalt published Enforcing Visitation Rights—Innovative Programs in Five State Courts May Provide Answers to This Difficult Problem, citing additional studies that indicated that, “safety concerns feature prominently in many visitation disputes.’

A war of words began. A plethora of articles and books sprouted up in the 1990s espousing alienation theories overlaid with a patina of science on this handy but non-scientific concept created by a pro-pedophile physician. 

By 1994, the Social Security Act began giving $60 million in grants to states for family preservation and family support services.  They were particularly focused on maintaining children in their own homes, posited on fixing their parents who would not abuse their children.

Congress is a lumbering beast that slumbers until groups of citizens gather in outrage at a critical problem, and force change. There were increasing concerns over the number of children floating around in foster care like driftwood. The pendulum moved toward maintaining children in their families. Was it more damaging to children to be abused by their own family members or by strangers?

Research showed that children often did better living with their own abusive families than with sometimes abusive or uncaring strangers in foster care.  Child welfare policy swung from removing children from dangerous homes (child protection) to trying to preserve families (child welfare) through services. This became a double-edged sword for children when their parents could not be rehabilitated. It was a gamble.

A huge step forward in protecting abused women was the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA), authorized in 1994 as part of H.R. 3355, the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act. 

The handiwork of many domestic violence advocates and then Senator Joe Biden, VAWA was designed to improve criminal, legal and community-based responses to violent crimes against women. It was administered by the U.S. Departments of Justice’s Office of Violence Against Women (OVW) and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. VAWA worked to get all agencies working together.  

woman jumping outside

Subsequent VAWA reauthorizations mentioned children 221 times, but children were not afforded the same protection as adult domestic violence victims.  The protection for a young woman on her 17th birthday was far different that the protection on her 18th birthday.

Child domestic violence victims were separated out and siloed into the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, to be served separately and not equally. Those services did not have a policy of “safety first.”

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.