“There is no denying that there is evil in this world but the light will always conquer the darkness.”
Idowu Koyenikan
As we were sorting out roles and paperwork for our brand-new organization, collaborative law arrangements geared up, ostensibly to reduce acrimony and save money through participation (and payment) by parents. Major concerns about these arrangements were described by attorney Carol Bruch, professor of law at U.C. Davis in her article Child Custody Law Needs a Course Correction: Thoughts from California.
As equality between genders was being grudgingly accepted in many areas including employment, women from lengthy marriages with traditional childcare and homemaker duties were being denied spousal support and expected to join the workforce. Professor Bruch cited a comment from a Legislative Committee Chair showing a cold disregard for their dilemma.
“You women asked for equality,” he said, “and now you’ve got it.”
Professor Bruch found that it took over 2 decades to replace the “tender years” rule with the vague, neutral “best interests of the child” standard, but only 3 years to enact joint custody in 24 states.
Around 1997, we connected with New York sociologist, researcher and protective mother Amy Neustein who was extremely knowledgeable. She had written hundreds of articles and been on countless broadcast media, beginning in 1987. She was tireless in speaking out for the muzzled sexually abused children. She had lost her 6 year old daughter to the father after the child reported sexual abuse in 1986, and had founded Help Us Regain the Children (HURT), a New York-based legal research and advocacy center, to track custody battles involving child sex abuse allegations.

Amy had conducted a decade-long study on mothers who asked the family court to protect their sexually abused children, and found few were protected. She found that in 70% of cases, mothers were ordered to send their children to visit their abusers unsupervised. In 20% of the cases, the mother lost custody to the abusers. That left only 10% of sexually abused children protected. In 1999, Amy and her colleague Ann Goetting, Ph.D. publishedJudicial Responses to the Protective Parent’s Complaint of Child Sexual Abuse in the Journal of Child Sexual Abuse, 8(4):103-122.
She also found courts used shockingly punitive methods such as refusing to hear evidence of child sex abuse, prohibiting mothers from testifying, holding mothers in contempt, putting them in jail, and forbidding them to have any contact with their children.
She and attorney Michael Lesher wrote Madness to Mutiny: Why Mothers are Running from Family Courts and What Can be Done About it published by Northeastern University Press/University Press of New England. She edited Tempest in the Temple: Jewish Communities and Child Sex Scandals, published by Brandeis University Press. She became our early mentor.
“We need to do something. What should we do?”
“Go to the Legislature.”
We knew that the tried-and-true trick by accused perpetrators is to squeal loudly, “False Allegations!” The truth is that false reports of child abuse were rare. Children are unlikely to fabricate this type of abuse. The Denver Department of Social Services 1987 study of 551 cases of possible sexual abuse determined that a miniscule 1.5% of cases brought by children were considered false. Ten years later, the 1997 National Child Abuse and Neglect Data System (NCANDS) Report, Statistics on Intentionally False Reports found that less than 1% of child sex abuse reports were considered intentionally false. Section D-9, from Tables 3.1 and 3.2:
| STATES | TOTAL REPORTS | UNSUBSTANTIATED | INTENTIONALLY FALSE |
| Florida | 186,726 | 92,337 | 868 (0.5%) |
| Missouri | 80,185 | 49,490 | 460 (0.6%) |
| Vermont | 2,309 | 1,257 | 18 (0.8%) |
| Virginia | 51,227 | 37,282 | 457 (0.9%) |
| TOTAL | 320,447 | 180,366 | 1,803 (0.6%) |
The Denver Department of Social Services 1987 study of 551 cases of possible sexual abuse determined that a miniscule 1.5% of cases brought by children were considered false.
If over 98% of child sexual abuse reports were likely to be true, why were only 10% of children being protected in family court? It was a distorted mirror opposite of what it should be. But we did not know how to do any of the things that were needed to fix the problem, especially with the Legislature. At the time, we were focused mostly on education, breaking the silence about child sex and ritual abuse with our conferences, and trying to let the public know these terrible outcomes were happening.
[T]he 1997 National Child Abuse and Neglect Data System (NCANDS) Report, Statistics on Intentionally False Reports found that less than 1% of child sex abuse reports were considered intentionally false.
Catch 22 was published in 1998 for the Davis Enterprise to try to explain the inexplicable. “The term ‘protective parent’ has recently been coined to describe a parent who attempts to protect a child from a violent or incestuous spouse. It appears, at first glance, to be an apt and descriptive phrase. However, it is a misnomer. The parent who seeks to protect his or her child from abuse often walks innocently into a Catch-22. In fact, some parents liken it to stepping into a bear trap.”
The Fourth Annual Child Sexual Abuse Awareness Conference began our process of starting to try to stop the problem by educating the public. Our kickoff was An Ounce of Prevention on April 4, 1998 with Sheila Kuehl’s wonderful counsel Syrus Devers and Sharon Ito from Channel 10.
That year, Melissa Knight Fine appeared at the conference and asked for a few minutes to speak to the audience. Of course, the answer was yes. She was from the Legislative Coalition to Prevent Child Abuse and had previously worked on a bill to make priests mandated reporters of child abuse and neglect, designed to slow the pedophile priest abuse. Despite fierce opposition by the Catholic Church, the bill was passed.
She looked like an angel and, appearing in our lives out of thin air, knew how to do exactly what we knew was needed but did not know how to begin. We explained the issues in family court, of children being placed with violent, incestuous parents. She understood immediately and began to work on legislation with Senator Deborah Ortiz from Sacramento. It was very exciting. She was the person we needed in this battle against the wickedness of people sexually abuse children and cover it up.

In 1998, Jeanne Maie Lorena and Paula Levy published Breaking Ritual Silence: An Anthology of Ritual Abuse Survivors’ Stories. Slowly the secrets were creeping out from behind closed, locked doors.
In Southern California, protective mother Idelle Clark and other mothers from Alaska, Michigan and New Jersey started United for Justice in 1999 after Idelle received hundreds of calls when her case was highlighted in a Los Angeles New Times. Protective mother Irene Jensen’s case was also covered.
Outside of California, also unbeknownst to us, in 1998 the Leadership Council on Child Abuse and Interpersonal Violence was formed in the East Coast as a non-profit scientific organization “to intervene in the cycle of violence by educating society about the role of childhood maltreatment in the development of mental disorders and to support justice for victims of violence.”
They are a “multidisciplinary group of scientists and professionals in psychiatry, psychology, law and journalism committed to providing accurate mental health information to the public and promoting the ethical applications of psychological science to human welfare.” Their website posts current and past research on the problem of custody and abuse.
A few of the heroes involved with the Leadership Council are Joyanna Silberg Ph.D.; Stephanie Dallam R.N., Ph.D.; Phyllis Stein R.N., M.S.N.; Bessell van der Kolk M.D.; Fran Waters L.M.F.T.; Charles Whitfield M.D.; Robert Geffner Ph.D.; Toby Kleinman Esq.; Alan Scheflin J.D., M.A.; Richard Ducote J.D.; Nancy Ericson Esq.; Seth Goldstein J.D.; Hon. Sol Gothard J.D.; Joan Meier Esq.; Eli Newberger M.D.; Frank Putnam M.D.; Anna Salter Ph.D.; Joan Zorza J.D.; and the late Paul Fink M.D. Their excellent resources gave us access to studies and high-level professionals.
More articles came out about “Parental Alienation Syndrome,” showing it was pedophile-oriented “junk science.” Stephanie Dallam wrote Dr. Richard Gardner: A Review of His Theories and Opinions on Atypical Sexuality, Pedophilia and Treatment Issues and made a revealing table comparing Gardner’s ideas with those of the North American Man Boy Love Association (NAMBLA), a pedophile organization.
Also in 1998, researcher Kathleen Faller wrote The parental alienation syndrome: What is it and what data support it? concluding that “No data are provided by Gardner to support the existence of the syndrome and its proposed dynamics.”