Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 23: Bailing

“Grief is alive, wild, untamed and cannot be domesticated.

It resists the demands to remain passive and still. We move in jangled, unsettled, and riotous ways when grief takes hold of us. It is truly an emotion that rises from the soul.”

Francis Weller

Activism replaced helplessness. The members of our little group were forced to set aside the abject grief, although it waited silently and stabbed at odd times. It was hard to watch a mother suddenly double over in pain when a reminder of her imprisoned child caught her by surprise. The long knives were sharp.

Our fledgling group got down to work.

I was still working full time at my paid job during much of this period and did what I could. Others, especially Karen Anderson and Josie’s mother Jean Travis, led. Rose Ginsberg developed a website, which was a huge step forward.

The games were on. Not knowing the rules of this gladiator sport, we forged ahead. Amy Neustein had recommended focusing on the Legislature. We were clueless about how things worked there. We thought we would just let everyone know about the problem, and somebody would fix it. We were oh, so very wrong.

We thought we would just let everyone know about the problem, and somebody would fix it.

On the other hand, the people in the domestic violence movement knew a lot by then and had carefully gone to the most effective Legislators possible, focused on the correct committees and worked behind the scenes with the appropriate staff in obscure offices that no one knew existed. It would take us years to figure out how to dance the sedate eighteenth-century governmental minuet.  We were out there doing the Twist in the wind.

The National Center on Domestic and Sexual Violence (NCDSV) was co-founded by prosecutor Sarah Buel and Deborah Tucker in 1998 to provide training and policy.  The plight of children was not yet on the radar screen of the advocates as they were too busy tending to the needs of the adult survivors.

In 1999, the Prevalence and Effects of Child Exposure to Domestic Violence published in Futures of Children showed that “…. large numbers of children are affected, although scientifically credible estimates of the national prevalence of the problem do not exist.” The report went on to say, “In general, childhood exposure to domestic violence can be associated with increased display of aggressive behavior, increased emotional problems such as depression and/or anxiety, lower levels of social competence and poorer academic functioning.”

“In general, childhood exposure to domestic violence can be associated with increased display of aggressive behavior, increased emotional problems such as depression and/or anxiety, lower levels of social competence and poorer academic functioning.”

Andrea became the lead of Incest Survivors Speakers Bureau (ISSB) and made a website. Our ISSB members were training local providers about abuse, including quarterly trainings at Sexual Assault and Domestic Violence Center and county mental health staff. Sandy DuBois was an exceptionally effective trainer. Chris, Abby and others helped with mailing and distributing flyers, making copies of programs and information. We were becoming somewhat computer literate and started an email list, collecting names of professionals and survivors from all over California.

In 1999, Brice Taylor, pseudonym for Susan Ford, wrote Thanks for the Memories: The Truth Has Set me Free! The Memoirs of Bob Hope’s and Henry Kissinger’s Mind-Controlled Slave” about her high-level CIA MK-Ultra training. In her book, she named well-known political figures and Hollywood stars as her abusers, including Henry Kissinger, Nelson Rockefeller, George Bush, Ronald Reagan, J. Edgar Hoover, Alan Greenspan, and Hollywood glitterati including Bob Hope, Bing Crosby, Frank Sinatra, Dean Martin, Elvis, Michael Jackson, Mickey Rooney, Jane Fonda, James Taylor, Barbara Streisand, Elton John and Hugh Heffner.  This was eye-opening and very hard to imagine.

I’d been speaking out on ritual abuse since 1990 and had received an overwhelming number of calls from survivors from all over the country.  We put on a conference in 1999 that seemed, even to me, quite risky.

Our Fifth Annual Child Sexual Abuse Conference on April 17, 1999, was titled The Hidden Holocaust: Ritual Abuse and Its Aftereffects and was a stunning event. We had a fee waiver for the multi-purpose room in the Veterans’ Memorial Center.  Incest Survivors Speakers Bureau, CA Protective Parents Association and other organizations co-sponsored the event. The local newspaper covered the conference.

People came from all over the country.  One of the audience members commented “I can’t believe I’m in the United States of America” after hearing about these frightening situations.

hooded figures surrounded by fire

We had an evening event at Bet Haverim, the Jewish Synagogue, but only Rabbi Doug Wolfe and one curious onlooker came.  We knew ritual abuse was an extension of the Nazi cruelties and were trying to turn the “again” in “never again,” but did not understand that using the term Holocaust was a sensitive issue in the Jewish community. I felt deep chagrin.

We wondered what the local satanists thought. Had they been there, in the audience, hiding in plain sight?

Another turning point came when we learned about the Family Violence and Sexual Assault Institute (FVSAI) conference in San Diego in September.  Like birds flying south for the winter, Karen and I started driving to their conferences once a year from Northern California to San Diego, 500 miles away near the Mexican border.

At the FVSAI (later IVAT) conferences convened by Bob Geffner, PhD, we met leaders in the effort to stop family violence and sexual abuse. It was a heady time.  There I met Dr. Vincent Felitti, who was a rock star to me. He kindly asked me to write a companion piece to his article The Relationship Between Adverse Childhood Experiences: Turning Gold into Lead article. My  Dear Doctor article seemed to write itself. 

Eventually the ACE study, which began in the petri dish of Dr. Felitti’s San Diego Kaiser Permanente obesity clinic when his patients began telling him about child sexual abuse that predated their food addiction, led to hundreds of other studies, articles and citations.

Eventually the ACE study, which began in the petri dish of Dr. Felitti’s San Diego Kaiser Permanente obesity clinic when his patients began telling him about child sexual abuse that predated their food addiction, led to hundreds of other studies, articles and citations.

The ACE study became a wakeup call to the nation, thanks in part to the work of journalist Jane Stevens. Jane had come to one of our Davis conferences when Dr. Felitti spoke, and decided she would devote her career to letting the world know this crucial information. She succeeded beyond our wildest dreams with ACES Connection, renamed PACES Connection, and contacts with federal agencies.

We also met Geraldine Stahly PhD, professor at California State University at San Bernardino at the FVSAI conference. She had contributed to the 1996 Violence and the Family: Report of the American Psychological Association Presidential Task Force on Violence and the Family that included a section on ritual abuse.  We knew we needed data and asked if she would help us. She agreed. She became the lead researcher on our study of cases of parents trying to protect their children in family court.

Attorney Richard Ducote always made us laugh at his clever comments on the rank stupidity of the bad system people.  He reminded me of Atticus Finch in To Kill a Mockingbird, up against the lynch mob.

It was wonderful to know we were not alone. Still, it did not mitigate the pain. The mothers spent many hours in tears, helplessly trying to comfort each other, praying for change, having no idea what to do to stop the carnage.

We had not yet connected with the domestic violence community at that point.  They were not part of the conferences we were attending.

Some domestic violence advocates were concerned that psychologists in general viewed domestic violence through the family strengths/ dysfunction lens with a focus on shared responsibility, rather than directly on the batterers’ acts of violence.  Counseling was proposed under that paradigm, rather than punishment.  Yet accountability including arrest and jail time had been found to be the most effective deterrent for many offenders and a reasonable solution to the problem of violent criminal acts against a partner or spouse.  

We were not aware of those nuances and were thrilled with the support and networking. However, the psychological community had a well-earned bad reputation for overlooking abuse. Many mental health evaluators tended to mislabel custody disputes that had allegations of domestic violence and sexual abuse as “high conflict” cases and attempted to treat family members with therapy, without screening for or stopping the abuse.

This happened in custody cases when the court layered on therapists, co-parent counselors, mediators, private evaluators, reunification specialists, minors’ attorneys and other “helper people,” while keeping children in constant danger and charging high fees for doing so. Naturally, the children developed ongoing mental health symptoms and needed therapy for the rest of their lives. 

All it really did was create a good living for unethical mental health professionals while increasing family chaos.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.