“In real life, strategy is actually very straightforward. You pick a general direction and implement like hell.”
Jack Welch
We settled in, got down to business and entered into a written Memoranda of Understanding in 2003 with CAADV, FVSAI and CASI to formalize our relationships. We even put together an advisory board, composed of outstanding professionals, including Linda Barnard PhD, Ruth Busch Esq, Richard Ducote Esq, Vincent Felitti MD, Alan Rosenfeld Esq, Geraldine Stahly PhD, Rev. Glenn Fuller, Judith Reisman, PhD, Lundy Bancroft, and later, Joy Silberg PhD and Bruce Perry MD. It was a pretty, glossy letterhead and they were most helpful when we needed advice.
Our networking was working.
It felt like we were in the Big League, although we still felt small, knowing we were only acting as if we knew what we were doing.
On May 6, 2003, Senator Sheila Kuehl held a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on the need for legislation to prevent children from being taken from their non-offending primary parents and being placed with their offenders by family courts. Many protective parents testified. Maybe the hearing was called because of the March presentation by Lundy Bancroft and Geraldine Stahly.

Sacramento attorney James Mize, who had become a Sacramento judge by then, also testified to the Legislature. With a straight face, he said. “I have taught family law to judges. I have taught every single newly appointed and newly assigned family law judge in the state of California for the last eighteen months… I have told them (the last 120 judges who have been through this training) Parental Alienation Syndrome does not exist, it is not to be considered.”
He failed to mention that parental alienation, without the “syndrome,” was rapidly taking the place of the non-existent junk science promulgated by pedophile-friendly Richard Gardner MD.
Senator Kuehl did not miss a beat.
“The representation that the law is working just fine, if I may so most respectfully disagree…. It may not be the case that Parental Alienation Syndrome runs wild among your judges, in terms of the way they make decision, but I can tell you in the Los Angeles County Court, it is a very, very popular consideration.”
She went on: “And how does Parental Alienation Syndrome, which has never been peer reviewed, which is junk science, and which should never be allowed, and if I had my way I would just bar the damn thing from the Evidence Code altogether. How does it play? It plays because a woman testifies or writes in her testimony that her child has been sexually abused — That’s it! And what happens? That’s Parental Alienation Syndrome because the level of proof is so high that, if there still remains a doubt, she hasn’t proven there was sexual assault and therefore she must be introducing this evidence in order to gain an advantage, and she ends up with supervised visits.”
Whistleblower Judge DeAnn Salcido later told us that Judge Mize and other trainers taught her and other new judges to be highly skeptical of abuse allegations in custody cases. This training led her to make a decision she deeply regretted in 2003, by placing Joyce Murphy’s six-year-old daughter with her father after everyone in the system refused to believe she was being sexually abused.

Joyce had a gag order so she could not even warn other parents. Six years later, the father Henry Parsons was convicted of molesting his daughter’s friends, basically using his child as a lure. Judge Salcido was drummed out of the tightly knit corps for speaking truth.
Judicial training made a difference, as long as it reinforced the pedophile agenda.
That same year, Cindy Dumas was in the midst of a similar hair-raising dilemma, trying to protect her son Damon from sex abuse by his father. She fled with him and his two brothers and hid for nearly 4 years. After a campaign to save Damon, the San Diego District Attorney dismissed the charges against Cindy and said they could return without a problem. But the fix was in. Family Court Judge Lorna Alksne put all three boys back with the abuser-father in 2011.
Damon then fled on his own at age 15 and ended up getting married the next year to stop the abuse, just like Marilyn Monroe had done many years before. Cindy and Damon went on to form the Safe Child International and The Women’s Coalition.


Emancipation helped.
Another teenager became a legal adult after getting a job and a place to live on his own. Two teenage girls fled their abuser fathers’ home, got a proper attorney and were able to have another adult become their guardian in different county. It was hard because they had to go to court after their abusive father was notified of the proceeding. They were terrified he would show up in court to object, and they would be sent back after enduring years of abuse before setting themselves free.
Meanwhile, I’d become a paper hoarder. Frantic mothers sent their tear-stained documents, showing the ignored evidence in their cases. Articles sprouted up in magazines and newspapers, along with coveted research articles. I saved them all. Hard-copy articles multiplied like coat hangers in a dark closet. The collection of videos, including those on healing from trauma by Cavalcade Productions, also grew.
We brought the big desk and chairs from our short-lived office space in Sacramento to my garage, which soon overflowed with more papers. A new little utility shed housed the former old cans of paint and lawnmowers that previously occupied the garage. A new office blossomed.
Protective mother Josie Cohen’s fiancée Ray Huckins and his nephew swept in one day with premade white bookcases that reached to the high vaulted garage ceiling. I got a little white step stool to reach the top shelves and became the librarian I played at when I was 11. I had filled our playhouse with books containing little cards in each. Remembering that the neighbor kids never returned my children’s library books, this time I didn’t lend out my treasures, but learned to scan and send them by email.
We knew the documents would one day become evidence of this massive human rights scandal.
We stored up copies of Lundy Bancroft’s The Batterer As Parent and distributed them to mostly uninterested legislators. We wanted them to know the facts documented in the book, that batterers do not make good dads. In fact, they usually made bad dads.
- Batterers often tend toward authoritarian, neglectful, and verbally abusive child-rearing
- Coerciveness is widely recognized as a central quality of battering men
- One of the areas of life heavily controlled by many men who batterer is the mother’s parenting
- A man who batters considers himself entitled to a special status within the family
- He considers he has the right to use violence when he deems it necessary
- Men who batter often have been observed to perceive their partners as owned objects
- Batterers seek custody of their children more often than non-battering fathers do
The 2003 Arizona Battered Mothers’ Testimony Project: A Human Rights Approach to Child Custody and Domestic Violence showed similar outcomes as the Stahly research.
They wrote that fundamental precepts of international human rights law were violated, including the children’s right to a violence-free life, according to the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (which the United States is the only country to not ratify.)
- A large number of judges thought that since the parties were separated, domestic violence was not a concern.
- 100% of victims were ordered to mediate with their abusers.
- In Maricopa County, perpetrators received sole or joint custody in 74% of cases.
- Having an order of protection had no impact on the final custody decision.
- Income level seemed to have the most impact on the ultimate custody decision.
- Having a custody evaluator more likely resulted in the mother losing custody.
- A mother with an attorney was more likely to win custody.
“The battered mother has to worry that if she leaves, the abuser will take her children and, if she doesn’t, that the government will,” remarked Jill Zuccardy, attorney in Nicholson v. Williams.
Junk science continued to prevail.
More books were published:
- Let My Children Go: A Mother’s Journal by Wendy Titleman,
- Laughter Calls Me: A Young Woman’s Search for Truth Leads to a Courage Battle to Save Her Children by Catherine Brown, and
- Bonshea: Making Light of the Dark by Coral Anika Theill
Karen was invited to the Bush White House and to talk with members of Congress about the national devastation. George W. Bush had been involved with the case of protective mother Debra Schmidt when he was Governor of Texas.
In May 2003, Dr. Stahly presented her research findings in Canada. That summer, I attended a think tank at the California Office of Criminal Justice Planning. We wrote articles, one at the request of the Judicial Council. Nothing changed.