Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 25: Turned Around Cases

“The people who succeed are irrationally passionate about something.”

Naval Ravikant

We were seeing some fruits of our labors on the federal level, but they still had not translated down to the local level.

In August 2013, Joan Meier and DV LEAP updated their well-documented article Rates at Which Accused and Adjudicated Batterers Receive Sole or Joint Custody.

  • 70-75% of parents referred to mediation for custody disputes had physical aggression.
  • Many judges and family service officers do not consider violence toward women and children relevant in custody disputes.
  • Domestic violence perpetrators contest custody twice as often as non-abusers.
  • Up to 94% of fathers who sought custody received it, regardless of a history of abuse.
  • 36 of 38 trial courts gave custody to batterers. Two-thirds were reversed on appeal.
  • Multiple studies documented gender bias against women in custody litigation.

The report on Crisis in Family Court: Lessons From Turned Around Cases by Joyanna Silberg, PhD, Stephanie Dallam, PhD and Elizabeth Samson was submitted on September 30, 2013 to the Office of Violence Against Women, Department of Justice.

Dr. Silberg spoke at a Congressional briefing and conferences on the outcomes.

Joyanna Silberg, PhD

The facts were chilling.

  • 42 million women are physically or sexually assaulted or stalked by a partner in their lifetime.
  • Nearly seven million women per year are assaulted or stalked.
  • Approximately one in two marriages end in divorce, affecting a million children per year.
  • Batterers often continue or escalate their abusive behavior post-separation.
  • There is a large co-occurrence of domestic violence and child abuse (30% to 60%).
  • The probability of child abuse increases to nearly 100% with 50 acts of marital violence.
  • Daughters of batterers were 6.5 times more likely to be victims of father-daughter incest.
  • Most sexual abuse is committed by men (90%) and persons known to the child (70-90%).
  • Contested custody cases often represent a high prevalence of family violence.

Abusers may continue to use their children to exert control over their victims.

  • Some batterers use the family court for ongoing harassment, retaliation, and intimidation.
  • One form of harassment is “paper abuse,” filing of multiple complaints.
  • Fathers accused of violence were just as likely to get custody as fathers who were not.
  • Women who told mediators they were victims of domestic violence were less likely to get primary custody.
  • Custody evaluators’ knowledge of domestic violence and/or child abuse is critical.
  • Psychological tests are of little value in determining the veracity of a child abuse allegations.
  • Custody evaluators are schooled to see abuse allegations as “parental alienation syndrome” (PAS).
  • PAS is not recognized by any professional association and diverts attention from abuse.
  • Dropping the word “syndrome” still minimizes the importance of abuse claims.
  • Joint custody presumptions and “friendly parent” provisions prevent child protection.
  • These problems are institutional and endemic within family court.

Most parents in the 27 studied cases were married protective mothers.

  • Almost 60% of the mothers reported experiencing domestic violence.
  • 88% of victims received a protection order for themselves.
  • 95% of mothers hired private attorneys.

The study was conducted at two different times. Children were first placed in the custody of an abusive parent and remained there from 4 months to 9.25 years.

Time 1: Child was placed with the abuser.

  • Children from ages 3-15 years disclosed abuse by their fathers to their mothers and others.
  • 33% of cases had evidence of father’s substance abuse, 21% had evidence of father’s child pornography.
  • 70% of children disclosed sexual abuse, 52% physical abuse, 26% both types of abuse.
  • 93% of cases were reported to CPS, 63% were ruled out/unfounded, only 22% of cases were founded/substantiated.
  • 85% of evaluators recommended custody or unsupervised visits with the accused.
  • 78% of judge thought the mother was not credible.
  • 73% of GALs sided with the abuser against the child.
  • 67% of judges cited the opinion of the evaluator or GAL who did not believe a child was abused.
  • 59% of abusers got sole custody, 26% unsupervised visits, 15% shared custody.
  • Some mothers were ordered to report abuse only to a special master/parenting coordinator, not CPS.
  • Children’s health deteriorated; 27% reported medical neglect; children were denied therapy.

Time 2: Child was rescued from the abuser.

  • 88% of children reported new incidents of abuse, and 77% had more than one type of re-abuse.
  • 71% of children disclosed to mothers, who were threatened and restricted from the children.
  • 73% reported to CPS; only 20% were founded, although the children were older and clearer.
  • No custody evaluations this time. 89% therapists, 11% specialized abuse evaluations.
  • 59% of mothers hired an attorney who specialized in cases with allegations of violence.
  • Evidence and expert professionals’ reports dispelled misinformation and myths.
  • GALs sided with the perpetrator 38% of the time, even though abuse was documented.
  • Self-advocacy of older children helped; some reported abuse to CPS, some ran away.
  • In 4 cases, the father was arrested or under threat of arrest.
  • 19% of children were protected at appeal; 19% were protected but it was unclear how; 15% were protected at the final custody hearing; 15% were protected at a hearing to modify custody; others at status conferences, protective orders, mediation agreements, emergency motions. 

The authors recommended:

  1. Abuse reports should be thoroughly investigated. 
  2. Specialists in abuse should play a larger role in protecting abused children in family court.
  3. State agencies need to play a more significant role when abuse allegations are contested.
  4. Professionals and judges need to recognize faulty logic in pathologizing a reporting parent.
  5. The “friendly parent” custodial preference should not be applied in abuse cases.
  6. The Guardian Ad Litem system needs to be reevaluated.
  7. The custody evaluator system needs to be reevaluated.

The custody evaluator system needs to be reevaluated.

Why would courts and their appointees even consider these risky placements? The children were small veterans, traumatized child soldiers in domestic wars.

Research on soldiers in 2013 found that younger veterans who had childhood trauma and those who had inflicted harm on civilians or prisoners of war were much more likely to develop lasting Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). Placing children in dangerous homes is a big step in creating personal and social disorders, like the Zimbardo prison “experimentees” who treated their fellow students sadistically in less than a week. 

Injured veterans were being helped with improving trauma treatment.  

Safe parents saw their children’s blank eyes and erratic behavior and knew something was very wrong. The International Society for the Study of Trauma and Dissociation was helpful in framing the discussion of trauma, including trauma against children.

The perpetrators sprang into action. There was a huge pushback by those who stood to lose (i.e., perpetrators) when the traumatic origins of childhood symptoms, especially dissociation, became known.  A few enraged parents of adult trauma survivors who were remembering childhood abuse after traumatic amnesia filed lawsuits against their adult children’s therapists. 

The study of children with traumatic dissociation lagged after that.

We went to the NPEIV Think Tank in September 2013. Our Public Policy Action Team decided to finalize the policy statement on the Crisis in Family Court, along with rape, gun control and corporal punishment. Wendy Murphy and I worked on the family court policy statement which was published in January 2014.

At the event, Acting Director of the Office of Violence Against Women Bea Hansen said she was interested in our idea of having a Division of Violence Against Children within OVW to collect data on, and develop policies for, children who are witnesses or victims of domestic violence. She referred us back to her colleague Lauren Nassikas at the Washington DC office.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.