“The more a society drifts from the truth, the more it will hate those who speak it.”
George Orwell
On May 4-6, 2018, the Thirteenth Battered Mothers Custody Conference (BMCC) was held in Albany NY titled Custody Litigation, Trauma and Recovery. As always, Mo Hannah put on the most beautiful professional conferences. Patrice Lenowitz and Lundy Bancroft premiered their play Forbidden to Protect. Catherine and I gave a talk on the history of our social justice movement Mothers of Lost Children, this time using Catherine’s beautiful slides. Along with Nancy Erickson and Alan Rosenfeld, I was presented with a Lifetime Achievement Award by Joan Meier. It was such an honor.
After the BMCC, we drove down to Washington DC to again urge Congress members to become cosponsors for H Con Res 72. We had gathered over 50 organizations as allies to support our 501(c)(4) lobbying group Advocates for Child Empowerment and Safety. It was quite impressive. The game of political Chutes and Ladders continued as the Resolution lead Congressman Meehan resigned in April due to sexual harassment charges. Texas Congressman Pete Sessions stepped in.

Back in California, ABC 10 KXTV reporter Liia Luciana had been covering the family court issue extensively, including an unsolicited interview of an alienation “believer.” She covered the historic passage of HR 113 by Assemblywoman Rubio, titled Piqui’s Resolution and Ana’s story with focused attention and caring. The Assembly floor speeches on August 23, 2018 were mesmerizing.
When Assemblywoman Rubio requested coauthors, nearly every member of the Assembly signed on, then gave Ana Estevez a standing ovation. It was a moving moment and meant a lot to Piqui’s grieving mother.
CALIFORNIA LEGISLATURE— 2017–2018 REGULAR SESSION
HOUSE RESOLUTION NO. 113
LEGISLATIVE COUNSEL’S DIGEST
HR 113, as amended, Rubio.
WHEREAS, According to the California Partnership to End Domestic Violence, one-half of the approximately 15,000 victims sheltered in California’s state-funded domestic violence programs each year are children and 75 percent of domestic violence victims have children; and
WHEREAS, The United States Department of Justice estimates that in 30 to 60 percent of families where either domestic violence or child maltreatment is identified, children experience both forms of abuse within the home; and
WHEREAS, According to the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), child abuse is a major public health issue, with a lifetime cost of over $200,000 for each victim; and
WHEREAS, According to the CDC, children who experience adverse childhood experiences, also known as ACEs, including abuse, are at an increased risk for chronic, adverse physical health effects as adults; and
WHEREAS, According to the UCLA Women’s Law Journal, research shows that victims of domestic violence are at a great disadvantage in child custody disputes and mediations when there is an allegation of domestic violence; and
WHEREAS, According to the Domestic Violence Legal Empowerment and Appeals Project, abusive parents, including those who are accused and adjudicated batterers, tend to be granted sole custody or joint custody by the courts, placing children at risk; and
WHEREAS, Article I of the California Constitution declares that all people have the inalienable right to pursue and obtain safety. A child’s safety should be a priority over all other considerations; and
WHEREAS, Court reporters should be present to create records in all family law matters, particularly in domestic violence and contested custody cases; now, therefore, be it
Resolved by the Assembly of the State of California, That all court-related professionals should be trauma-informed and trained in recognizing, evaluating, and understanding evidence and the impacts of domestic violence and child abuse; and be it further
Resolved, That a court reporter should record all hearings indomestic violence and contested custody cases, and all litigants should have access to the court records; and be it further
Resolved, That when a child witnesses domestic violence or is injured or abused,family courts should ensure that the safety of the child has priority over all other considerations in any custody or visitation decision; and be it further
Resolved, That the Chief Clerk of the Assembly transmit copies of this resolution to the California Supreme Court, the Judicial Council, and the author for appropriate distribution.
We realized the Resolution was not binding but it would make it easier to pass more substantive bills in the future. Assemblyman Mark Stone, Chair of the Judiciary Committee, had introduced AB 2044 to have child safety the highest priority in custody determinations. It passed into law with amendments. The court was to make findings that:
- Children are safe and free from abuse.
- Domestic violence in a household is detrimental to them.
- Perpetrators must demonstrate that custody or visits to them is in the best interest of the child.
The language was not clear that the findings had to be written on the record. Without transcripts, if the court neglected to make the required findings, there was no way to appeal and no oversight.
Since the California Legislature had cut the Judiciary’s budget, essentially due to waste, fraud and abuse of taxpayer dollars, many courts retaliated by eliminating court reporters, calling this due process violation a cost-containment measure.
In a 2018 case, the California Supreme Court ruled in Jameson v Desta that low-income people were given the right to a free court reporter. A Task Force was developed to implement the Supreme Court decision. The judiciary showed little interest in this due process right. Additionally, middle income litigants were out in the cold, since court reporters and transcripts were unconscionably expensive, and unions blocked low cost electronic records.
Enter Assemblywoman Blanca Rubio.
She introduced AB 2354 to require court reporters in custody and domestic violence cases. The bill died in committee due to the Judicial Council inflating estimated costs. So Assemblywoman Rubio and Senator Holly Mitchell arranged for Budget bill AB 840 to require $10 million of the Judicial Council’s $75 million discretionary funds to increase the level of court reporters in family law cases.
Several counties, including Los Angeles, already provided court reporters, and soon there were more. It was a sterling maneuver.
On September 21, 2018, the California Board of Psychology held a facilitated Child Custody Stakeholder Meeting at the California Department of Consumer Affairs. It was organized in response to complaints by the Center for Judicial Excellence, and doubtless because of the testimony we gave at the sunset hearing in March.
Kathleen brought attorney Robin Yeamans, a protective mother, and me to the meeting. In attendance were representatives from the Board of Psychology, the Board of Behavioral Science, the Judicial Council, the Attorney General’s office, the Department of Consumer Affairs, the California Assembly and the California Senate.
The Board of Psychology Enforcement Committee Chair explained they had been hearing issues regarding child custody for the past 2 years. (Apparently, they did not know the previous decade-long history we had, meeting with the former enforcement officers.)
We were assured that they cared about the issues. We learned that the Board of Behavioral Science Examiners did not oversee court mediators, even if they have a license. They described the process: an analyst reviews the complaint, contacts the non-complaining parent, forwards it to a subject matter expert, and if the complaint goes forward, involves the Attorney General’s office.
Robin Yeamans explained that before 1992, parental alienation syndrome was rarely used as a label in custody cases. When the federal Temporary Aid to Needy Families (TANF) was passed, fathers were suddenly interested in receiving custody and child support, rather than paying child support to mothers. Just as quickly, alienation theories arose as a counter to abuse allegations. It struck at parents with higher incomes and led to the rise of expensive reunification camps to reunify children with identified abusers.
Kathleen and I discussed the issue from the standpoint of litigants whose complaints were not acted upon. We recommended having custody evaluators use a template, bifurcating the licensing and investigation processes, and capping evaluators’ fees which would be paid by the court, not the litigants. The Board arranged for next steps. We were cautiously optimistic.
We kept trying to interest California’s Attorney General in these criminal events. In June 2018 we met with Assistant Attorney General Renuka George.
Nothing. We were getting tired of that “rare bug” look.