Digital Museum of Childhood

DOMESTIC VIOLENCE AND CHILD ABUSE 

A Coordinated Community Response

A coordinated community response to violent and sexual crimes provides victim safety and abuser accountability. It is needed to prevent re-injury and homicide and ensure appropriate intervention for abusers.  

  • The National Institute of Justice found that specialized domestic violence courts, law enforcement, prosecutor, and probation units are research-based best practices. 
  • Co-locating services in a Family Justice Center gives victims a user-friendly “one-stop shop.” 
  • Multidisciplinary interview teams (MDIT) help agencies coordinate services for interviewing child victims or witnesses. 
  • Safe Babies Courts has a multi-disciplinary team to ensure safety and permanency for infants from ages zero to three in foster care.
  • Training and certification exams for all professionals involved with parents and children in all courts must be standardized, online and in compliance with the 2022 Violence Against Women Act Reauthorization, Section 1504, also known as Kayden’s Law.
  • The Office of Violence Against Women is urged to develop a Division of Violence Against Children as an oversight body to ensure child victims and/or witnesses are safe from domestic violence and child abuse.

A. PROPER INVESTIGATION AND PROSECUTION

Investigation.

Law enforcement detectives are the investigative leads on all domestic crimes. All referrals made to child welfare services are logged and referred within one hour of receipt of report to a thoroughly screened and trained domestic violence specialist detective. 

The detective:

  • Gathers contact and initial information about the family from the reporting party.
  • Determines if there are weapons involved and if any family members are in immediate danger.
  • Obtains criminal background checks on parents and all household members.
  • Obtains reports of any previous contacts with the child welfare system, including contact information for social workers, if readily available.

When there are allegations of noncriminal child neglect, verbal abuse, or corporal punishment, a social worker from child welfare services accompanies the detective. 

The detective and social worker jointly:

  • Interview all household members separately.
  • If there are no crimes alleged or found, instruct the parents to correct neglect problems and cease verbal abuse and/or corporal punishment.
  • Refer parents to parenting classes, with a certification of completion to the detective.
  • If there is evidence of substance abuse, refer the parent(s) to substance abuse treatment with a certificate of completion and outcome brought to the detective. 
  • Refer parents to other services, including assistance with counseling as needed.
  • Encourage reports of any further problems.  

When there are allegations or threats of violent or sexual crimes, or other domestic abuse crimes, a domestic violence victim advocate from a local domestic violence center accompanies the detective.

The detective: 

  • Introduces the domestic violence advocate and briefly explains the criminal justice investigation process. 
  • Provides the non-offending parent and child victims aged 14 or older with a written checklist of each of the following steps, so the victims know what to expect.
  • Interviews the parents and each child separately.
  • Photographs any wounds or bruises on family members, and any property destruction.  
  • Gathers further information about the family, including, but not limited to, access to weapons, criminal history in other counties/states, child welfare and juvenile court history; dependency hearings and outcomes; family court history; substance abuse history; all domestic violence incidences.
  •  If the non-accused parent or other household members report they are victims of domestic violence, sexual assault, strangulation, stalking, or other crimes, records each crime and each incident separately in the report.
  • Obtains names and contact information of other potential victims and witnesses, including, but not limited to, those to whom the child disclosed a crime, such as family members. neighbors, teachers, care providers, therapists, medical providers.
  • Interviews other victims and witnesses within 3 days.

If child sexual abuse is alleged or disclosed, the detective:

  • Protects any evidence such as clothing or bed sheets from the crime scene. 
  • Requests a crime scene search warrant within 1 hour and collects evidence, including, but not limited to, electronics.
  • Arranges for an Internet Crimes Against Children (ICAC) surveillance for possible child pornography transactions.

The domestic violence advocate:

  • Schedules an immediate forensic medical exam and offers to accompany or to contact another support person, as appropriate.
  • Schedules an immediate Sexual Abuse Response Team (SART) exam if sexual penetration of an adult or child within the past 72 hours is alleged and offers to accompany or to contact another support person as appropriate.
  • Administers a standard research-based danger assessment to the non-offending parent to determine the level of danger and provides the results to the victim.
  • Assists with a safety plan if the danger assessment indicates risk or there are other safety concerns, including, but not limited to, assisting the victim(s) to obtain restraining orders and referrals to a Safe at Home program.
  • Schedules a videotaped child advocacy center/multidisciplinary team forensic interview (MDIT) within 48 hours if a crime against a child is alleged. The detective, social worker, domestic violence advocate and District Attorney may observe through a one-way mirror or other technology, including electronic communication with the interviewer.
  • Provides crisis intervention and referrals for emergency assistance, including but not limited to housing, food, medical care, counseling, support groups, trauma therapy, parenting classes.
  • Assists with filing claims for victims of crime compensation, refers victims to attorneys trained in domestic violence, including pro bono and low-cost attorneys, and provides further information about the criminal justice system 

The detective:

  • Interrogates the accused at the police or sheriff station whenever possible.
  • Requests a lie detector test.
  • If the accused alleges the other parent is violent, determines the dominant/most significant aggressor, including, but not limited to, observations of each parents’ height, weight, relative physical strength, military training, if any, occupation, etc. 
  • Arrests the accused if there is probable cause, to deter further abuse.
  • Arrests the accused immediately for any violation of a restraining order or any subsequent re-abuse, to reduce recidivism.

After a thorough investigation, the detective: 

  • Compiles all evidence.
  • Separately lists each chargeable crime, including all past-but-still-chargeable crimes, in a charging document.
  • Each act or incident of physical violence, sexual assault, strangulation, stalking, threats of violence and other criminal acts constitute a separate crime.
  • Each act of violence occurring on separate time periods constitutes separate crimes.
  • Each act of violence against each child and other victims constitutes separate crimes.
  • Other related charges can include, but are not limited to lewd and lascivious acts, sexual battery, child endangerment, possession of illegal drugs, and possession of child pornography.  
  • Forwards the report to the specialized domestic violence prosecutor unit within 5 working days from the first interview.  

Victim Advocate.

The domestic violence advocate continues to support the non-offending parent through criminal and civil court procedures. If the non-offending parent prefers, the District Attorney’s Victim of Crimes Unit assigns a victim advocate, even if there is no arrest or prosecution.

Prosecution.

Specialized domestic violence prosecution units often obtain convictions through plea bargains, including incarceration, when there are multiple charged crimes. 

  • To decrease the risk of recidivism, prosecutors include conditions of strict probation monitoring and successful completion of a 52-week batterer accountability treatment program with concurrent substance abuse treatment (unless there are no indications of domestic violence or substance abuse). 
  • A victim/witness child has no contact with the accused prior to the criminal trial, to prevent witness intimidation, retaliation or re-injury. 

Probation.

Specialized domestic violence probation units closely monitor offenders.

  • Immediately incarceration is imposed for any failure to comply with conditions, including not beginning treatment or a single violation of restraining orders.
  • Random drug and alcohol testing for 52 weeks, unless substance abuse is not indicated.  

B. SPECIALIZED PROBLEM-SOLVING COURT

Domestic Violence/Safe Child Courts.

If domestic violence or child abuse is alleged, all child custody cases are heard only in specialized Domestic Violence/Safe Child Courts that are focused on the safety of all family members with the safety of children as the highest priority, along with batterer accountability

  • A child advocate with at least 3 years of experience working as an advocate in a domestic violence center is assigned at the beginning of the case.
  • The court appoints the child advocate.
  • Substance abuse testing is court-ordered and paid by the accused, unless there are no concerns about substance abuse.
  • Other services such as mediation, child custody recommending counseling (CCRC), child custody evaluations, mental health evaluations, expert witnesses, parenting coordinators, reunification counselors, parenting coaches and other similar delegations of judicial authority are not allowed in Domestic Violence/Safe Child courts. 
  • A non-offending parent who is not able to afford an attorney s provided with a pro bono attorney with experience in prosecuting domestic violence and child abuse.

The child advocate:

  • Accompanies children aged 10 or older to provide their preferences for custody and visitation to the judicial officer in chambers with a court reporter, if the child wishes. 
  • If the child is not included under the non-offending parent’s restraining order, assists the child aged 10 or older in obtaining a restraining order, as appropriate.
  • Arranges for a multi-disciplinary team of the District Attorney representative, the law enforcement detective, the domestic violence advocate and a social worker to gather needed information, complete the appropriate sections of a form similar to the California FL-329 investigation form for each child, attach a copy of each agency’s report, ask parents to review and make factual corrections, and provide a corrected report to the family court before any evidentiary hearing.
  • Records all relevant activities and outcomes each month on a County Child Abuse Database, using a unique number/letter for each child to protect their identity.

Any determination of custody or visitation in a case where domestic violence and/or child abuse has been alleged or adjudicated shall be made only after a full evidentiary hearing with in-person sworn witness testimony. 

  • All hearings shall be electronically recorded with a stationary video camera. 
  • A court reporter may create a written transcript, if needed.
  • Parents may bring their own expert witnesses to testify in court.  
  • The court shall issue a written reason on the record for all custody or visitation dispositions.

Safe Custody and Visitation.

A child’s disclosure of a crime to any government official is given the highest weight and constitutes a presumption that the child requires ongoing protection from the accused. Restraining orders and receipt of Victims of Crime funding also create a presumption.

  • Placement with the parent most likely to protect the child from domestic abuse is safest for the child’s physical needs.
  • Placement with a non-offending parent who has been the primary caretaker is safest for the child’s emotional and attachment needs.
  • A permanent non-contact order for all victims of domestic violence is the safest type of order to ensure family safety.

If the accused is not arrested, prosecuted or convicted and any restraining order that includes the child is not extended, the child may visit the accused only after making a request for a visit and only under monitored agency supervision paid by the accused or adjudicated offender.

  • If the child initiates an unsolicited request for unsupervised visits, the multi-disciplinary team consisting of the District Attorney, the detective, the social worker, the domestic violence advocate and the child advocate must agree individually in writing that all conditions imposed on the alleged or adjudicated offender by the court have been completed and the child will be safe from re-abuse and/or retaliation before unsupervised visits are ordered.
  • The court orders random weekly drug and alcohol testing paid by the tested parent during unsupervised visits, unless there are no concerns about substance abuse. 
  • If a substance abuse test is positive, supervised visits resume until the substance abuser tests consistently negative for at least 26 weeks.
  • Any re-abuse and/or retaliation reported by the child results in the immediate arrest of the offender, with a condition of no contact with the child.
  • Only agency-supervised in-person contact is allowed when a child has reported sexual abuse, as child sex abusers cannot be reliably rehabilitated.

Oversight.

Court watchers are placed in each Domestic Violence/Safe Child courtroom.

  • If a child is ordered into unsupervised contact with an alleged or adjudicated offender without the safety protocols and safeguards listed above, the court watcher reports to the County Board of Supervisors which then elevates the case to the Presiding Judge and the District Attorney.
  • The Board conducts an annual audit of cases and forwards the audit to the federal Division of Violence Against Children within the Office of Violence Against Women to determine gaps in child protection and to determine if a corrective action plan is needed and whether funding should be modified.  

Funding.

Funding for specialized law enforcement units, domestic violence and child advocates, and court watch would come from the Victims of Crime Act (VOCA), Violence Against Women Act (VAWA), U.S Department of Health and Human Services (US DHHS) Family Violence Prevention and Services Act (FVPSA) and/or Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act (CAPTA). 

The rate of child abuse and domestic violence, along with re-abuse and homicides, would likely decline, which would counterbalance any increased costs. Child victims would have a much lower likelihood of future smoking, substance abuse, suicide, violence, mental and physical injuries and illnesses, relationship breakdown, unemployment and homelessness over their lifetimes.

That would give a fully positive meaning to the quote by Karl Menninger, M.D. “What is done to children, they will do to society.” Safe, nurtured children would lead to and bring forth a safe, nurturing society. 

We can dream.

SCHEMATA
RESPONSE TO DOMESTIC VIOLENCE OR CHILD ABUSE CALLS 

All professionals trained with standardized, online training and exam

CPS refers all DV/child abuse
to LE for investigation

If non-criminal allegations,

LE and CPS respond

If criminal allegations, LE and DV center advocate respond

LE leads investigation, photographs, interviews witnesses

Interrogates accused, lists all possible crimes, arrests if probable cause

  • If CSA alleged, obtains warrant for electronics and ICAC team

DV advocate supports non-offending parents – medical exams, RO, MDIT, SART, danger assessment, safety plan, victims’ compensation

If prosecution, child has no contact with accused

All custody dispute cases heard only in DV/Safe Child Court

  • DV advocate continues with non-offending parent even if no arrest
    • Substance abuse testing, unless not needed
    • No mediators, evaluators, parenting coordinators, etc.

Court appoints Child Advocate (CA) with 3 years of experience advocating for victims at DV center

  • CA supports child, speak to judge, helps with RO  
  • CA leads data completion on form similar to FL 329

Full evidentiary hearings are required in all DV/child abuse cases.

  • MDIT must agree individually in writing for non-supervised visits
  • Only agency supervised visits if child reports sex abuse.

Court watchers in all DV/Safe Child Courts

  • Board of Supervisors reports children at risk to Presiding Judge
  • CA provides master spreadsheet to Board of Supervisors

Division of Violence Against Children at OVW receives spreadsheets, identifies and responds to gaps in child and family safety. 

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.