Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 12: Point, Counterpoint

“Child sexual abuse (CSA) affects children in all socioeconomic levels.”

This point-counterpoint journey, the deadly dance between those who wanted to protect vulnerable people and those who wanted to hurt them, was oddly fascinating. At times it seemed merely academic. At other times, the raw desperation of victims as prey animals circled by predators felt overwhelming. We kept searching. It was important.

Factionalism developed between those who believed the reports of incest and ritual abuse and those who did not, which caused rifts in the therapeutic community.

The opposition was ready with their counterpoint.

By 1988, Richard A. Gardner MD self-published The parental alienation syndrome and the differentiation between fabricated and genuine child sex abuse, coining a term that would have far reaching consequences.  Gardener worked with the defense team for the Maplewood, New Jersey’s Wee Care Nursery School teacher Kelly Michaels whose 1988 conviction for child sexual and ritual abuse was reversed. 

In his self-published Sex Abuse Hysteria: Salem Witch Trials Revisited, he admitted that genuine sexual abuse of children is widespread and that “the vast majority (probably over 95%) of all sex abuse allegations are valid,” yet the rest of his considerable energies went to protecting the accused. He was a prolific writer. As a physician, he received credibility as an expert witness. 

The vast majority (probably over 95%) of all sex abuse allegations are valid.” Richard Gardner, M.D.

His career as a pedophile advocate was wildly successful and his recommendations that courts remove children from alienating parents and place them in the custody of accused parents haunts society today.  He helped drive a wicked stake into the kind heart of the burgeoning child safety movement, and in 2003, drove a literal knife into his own heart when he suicided at his home in Tenafly, New Jersey.

As the survivor movement slowly gained strength, a new understanding was dawning. There were a few pioneers who broke the “don’t talk” taboo early.

Louise Armstrong wrote Kiss Daddy Goodnight: Ten Years Later in 1988.

The Courage to Heal: A Guide for Women Survivors of Child Sexual Abuse by Ellen Bass, a poet and teacher and Laura Davis, a survivor, was published in 1988. This self-help book and later workbook focused on healing and became known as the “bible” of the survivors’ movement. That same year, Victims No Longer: The Classic Guide for Men Recovering from Sexual Child Abuse was published. Author Mike Lew co-directed Next Step Counseling and Training in Northampton, MA.

Also in 1988, the Office of Victim and Survivor Rights and Services was established in California to give a voice to victims whose perpetrators were convicted.

As the subject of child sex abuse began cracking open, Boy Scout leaders were also being named as abusers. They are in a power position over young boys and in 1988, the Boy Scouts developed a Youth Protection sex education and prevention program.

Significantly, it did not include criminal background checks for scout leaders. According to their Chief Executive, pedophilia had been an issue since the Boy Scouts program began back in 1910, in direct opposition to their stated mission “to prepare young people to make ethical and moral choices over their lifetimes…” 

Two Boy Scouts

According to USA Today, “The accused tend to be men of stature in their communities, most of whom volunteered as troop leaders or assistant troop leaders. Boy Scout leaders were “police officers and members of the military, teachers and a mayor, doctors and a child psychologist. Their prominent positions offered them easy access to children and a cover if they were reported. They allegedly caught their prey in tents and homemade shelters in the wilderness, in their cars shuttling young boys back and forth to Scouting activities, and sometimes in the children’s own homes.”

“The accused tend to be men of stature in their communities, most of whom volunteered as troop leaders or assistant troop leaders. Boy Scout leaders were “police officers and members of the military, teachers and a mayor, doctors and a child psychologist. Their prominent positions offered them easy access to children and a cover if they were reported.”

After the expose, at least 50 lawsuits were filed. Inquiries were made into the Boy Scout “ineligible volunteer” files (aka “the perversion files”) which began shortly after the founding of the organization. By 2020, the National BSA disclosed in their bankruptcy filings that a at least 92,700 former Scouts had reported sexual abuse by members of the organization, including one 93-year-old victim. Between 1986 and 1991, the BSA paid over $15 million in lawsuits.

The Boy Scout scandal was frightening, but the pedophile priest scandal eclipsed it worldwide for sheer numbers of children sexually abused by men in positions of power over them.

In the late 1980’s, the pedophile priest scandal broke open, leading to the establishment of the grassroots organization Survivors Network of Those Abused By Priests (SNAP) in 1989. At a conference, one of the founders Phil Saviano agreed that growing up in the home of a sex offender was likely even worse than priest sex abuse. He gave the key to success: persistence and focus.

Investigator Frank Fitzpatrick went public as a victim of Father James Porter and located many other victims through a newspaper ad in 1990. Porter, who had been molesting children since the 1960’s, was charged with over 200 counts of child sex abuse. He began serving 18-20 years for his sexual predation in 1993.

He had even admitted his crimes in a letter to the Pope and church officials knew of the accusations, yet they transferred the cleric from parish to parish and hospital to hospital, like a walking smallpox blanket, covering up his crimes and increasing the number of victims exponentially.

Father Porter was the tip of the iceberg. Hundreds of accused priests, massive lawsuits, and a major coverup scandal were documented by the Boston Globe in hundreds of articles and the 2006 Academy Award winning movie Spotlight. By 2018, over 7000 U. S. priests were credibly accused of sexually abusing over 20,000 children since 1950, in addition to clergy from other denominations, according to the Bishop Accountability list. 

It was hard to absorb the vastness of the child sexual abuse cover up by so many people, especially clergy all the way up the hierarchy.

A Chicago priest and sociologist estimated that there were more than 100,000 child victims of priests in the United States. In France alone, an estimated 330,000  children were said to be victims of priest sexual abuse. One estimate was that 4% of all Catholic priests sexually violated children in the last half of the 20th century, which was the same for clergy from other denominations.  It is estimated the Catholic Church had paid over $3 billion since 1950 in settlements from lawsuits.

The twin Boy Scout and pedophile priest scandals opened the door to talk much more freely about child sex abuse by powerful men with secrets to hide.  A large number of the family law cases that went terribly wrong were cases of child sex abuse by wealthy fathers.

On the custody front, a new strategy was evolving, ostensibly to help children but with a definite dark twist. Terminology changed.  Former “deadbeat dads” became “deadbeat parents.” The 1988 Deadbeat Parents Punishment Act created fines of up to $10,000 and two years in prison for failing to pay child support for a child in another state. Enforcement was harsh. Parents were tracked down and forced to pay up, have their wages garnished if they didn’t, or worse. This was serious stuff which did not go well for children. Already treated like property, children became prized commodities overnight. Abusive fathers caught on that the more time they had with their children, the less support they had to pay.

Already treated like property, children became prized commodities overnight. Abusive fathers caught on that the more time they had with their children, the less support they had to pay.

It was a dream come true for incest perpetrators who could even receive support from formerly beloved, now hated mothers of their child victims. It was the perfect revenge. The title “gold-digger” quickly reversed genders and expanded exponentially.

Access to children is key for perpetrators of sexual misconduct, including educators. A 2004 report Synthesis of Existing Literature, U.S. Department of Education Office of the Under Secretary Policy and Program Studies Service reported that 4.1% to 21.1% of students responded that educators had sexual contact with them.

This is a staggering number of child victims of sexual abuse and does not include predators who come home every night for dinner, their fathers. One study showed over half (53%) of sexually abused girls are abused by their biological fathers and 15% by their stepfathers.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.