Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 14: Center for Court Innovation

“The judiciary wields enormous power but is utterly mysterious to most Americans.”

Done Willitt

I was asked to testify for AB 1435 (Dickenson), a bill to make sports coaches mandated reporters. That was easy. One of my abusers had been the Air Force Academy football coach. The Chair of the Public Safety Committee Tom Ammiano became noticeably upset, saying he was gay and there was a perception that gays were predators. Fortunately, the bill was signed into law in September.

We went to Phoenix, Arizona for a March 16-17, 2012 event titled Our Broken Family Court System cosponsored by the National Alliance of Professional Psychology Providers and the Nicholas and Dorothy Cummings Foundation. Dr. Cummings’ daughter was a protective mother. Dr. Lenore Walker, author of The Battered Woman’s Syndrome, David Shapiro, Judge Marjory Fields, John Caccavale PhD, Toby Kleinman, Lenore Walker, Bob Adler, Eli Newberger, David Shapiro, Ricky Greenwald, Garland Waller, Rita Smith, Kathleen Russell, and protective grandparents Helen and Jim spoke. The room was filled with protective mothers and psychologists.

The first day focused on the problem, the second day focused on solutions. Psychologist John Caccavale flatly said there should be no evaluators.

Psychologist John Caccavale

Judge Marjorie Fields said court transcripts were crucial. Garland Waller showed No Way Out But One. The talks were turned into a book. Copies were provided to all members of Congress.

Bob Adler suggested that better law enforcement was needed, and a Constitutional due process taxpayer suit might be a direction to go, reasoning that we paid taxes, but the government did not deliver safety. I liked that idea but had no idea how to make that happen.

Bob Adler

It didn’t seem there was much impact from the books that were distributed to all Congressmembers, but maybe behind the scenes the issue of family court placing children with abusers was being noticed. We were a relentless coalition.

Journalist Jane Stevens launched ACESConnection in 2012 to bring knowledge and networking to governmental agencies and private organizations regarding the concepts of how adversity negatively affects children when they become adults, leading to major physical, emotional and behavioral disorders. The name was changed to PACESConnection in 2021 to include both positive and adverse childhood experiences.  The intent was to inform people, organizations, and communities about a new understanding of human behavior that had been emerging since the 1980s. 

Jane started organizing a revolution, bringing federal and state governmental agencies into trauma-informed knowledge and urging them to act. Her strategy was sure-footed and highly successful. She told us she had come to one of our Davis Child Sexual Abuse Awareness Conferences and found her calling. 

Professionals learned about the ACE study and there began to be a national friendly competition to see which schools and institutions could create the best programs to tend to children’s needs, rather than punish them when they were hurting.  Schools even reduced their suspension rate dramatically by asking children what was happening to them. That brought me to tears. What a wonderful outcome.

Journalist Jane Stevens

At the same time, the US Department of Justice, Office of Violence Against Women (OVW) released the Family Court Demonstrations Initiative Call for Concept Papers to “provide guidance to courts around the country in implementing proven procedures and practices related to custody and visitation to help keep domestic violence victims and their children safe from further violence and trauma.”  

This was real progress.  We were delighted. It was a tangible outcome of the four roundtable discussions that began in 2008. Keeping children safe in custody and visitation decisions was front and center. 

The spotlight was finally shining directly on family court.

Four demonstration sites were chosen: Circuit Court of Cook County in Chicago, Ill.; Family Court of the State of Delaware; Hennepin County Family Justice Center in Minneapolis, Minn.; and Multnomah County Family Court in Portland, Ore. 

The Office of Violence Against Women (OVW), The National Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges (NCJFCJ), The Battered Women’s Justice Project (BWJP), the National Institute for Justice (NIH), and the Center for Court Innovation collaborated to improve outcomes for domestic violence victims and their 15 million children exposed to domestic violence each year. Acting Director Bea Hanson said, “Ensuring the safety of domestic violence victims and their children during and after court proceedings is an essential component of the Family Court Enhancement Project (FCEP).”  

Bea Hanson

A commitment to improve litigants’ access to justice emerged as a common goal for all four Family Court Enhancement Project sites, according to the Battered Women’s Justice Project (BWJP).  This would seem self-evident, but the method used for those demonstration projects was unique, allowing the court professionals to actually walk in litigants’ shoes. The path consisted of:

  • Committed leadership. Judicial leadership and cooperation with community stakeholders ensure continued efforts to improve access and safety for survivors.
  • Experience the process. Court professionals walked through their own systems, participating as if they were survivors. They learned a lot and decided the court should present a safe, welcoming environment with clear signage directing litigants to the resource center. User-friendly information should be in plain language, clear information about the law and court processes, and in multiple languages. Expanding the protection order docket reduced stress, confusion and time in court.
  • Universal systematic screening for domestic violence. Universal screening should identify domestic violence and provide options, safeguards, and choices. (The BWJP method of screening takes 5-10 minutes.)
  • Train mediators. Mediators should be trained both in mediation skills and in domestic violence dynamics, victim and perpetrator behavior, effects of violence on parenting and on children, safety measures such as supervised visits. Survivor’s wishes for mediation should be considered.  There should be separate waiting areas and flexibility about sessions. Survivors could end a session if they felt unsafe or opt out of mediation if they believed it was not safe or appropriate. This resulted in truly voluntary and safe agreements, when made. Parenting plans would consider safety needs and the family’s specific situation.
  • Court navigator. Navigators guide litigants through their case, meet procedural requirements and prepare for court appearances, mediation and other key proceedings. Facilitators trained in domestic violence can help with forms and other aspects of the case. An on-site advocate can help with safety planning and link survivors to other services and resources. Guidance and support from advocates and legal aid during the protection order process help.
  • Child-related relief expediter. A “child-related relief expediter” might be included for protection orders, including custody and visitation provisions.  The expediter connected litigants to community services, including advocates, legal services, counseling, and supervised visitation providers.
  • Judges in favor. Judges continue to refer appropriate cases in large numbers. They were impressed with the agreements reached by the parties and notice a positive change in litigants’ demeanor when they return to court.

A prevailing belief among key stakeholders, including judges, advocates, and attorneys, that visitation is almost always inappropriate and, even if desired by victims, not likely to be safe. The Cook County court and community culture even favored eliminating contact with abusive parents. They created a way to negotiate a mutually acceptable, safe visitation order through a carefully designed process that accounts for the effects of domestic violence, including coercive controlling abuse. 

A prevailing belief among key stakeholders, including judges, advocates, and attorneys, that visitation is almost always inappropriate and, even if desired by victims, not likely to be safe.

“Survivors in these communities now have safer and more trauma-informed processes, more and better-informed choices, more community and court support, and a clearer path to a safe future for themselves and their children,” according to the Battered Women’s Justice Project (BWJP).

BWJP said feedback from litigants, attorneys, advocates, and judges was uniformly positive that the process was safe, workable, effective, and felt fair and able to meet their needs. 

gavel and scale on desk

This was far more successful than we had dreamed. The question was how to replicate in California courts, especially the hotspot counties where some ethical attorneys refused to appear because the bias against women and children was so great.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.