Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 19: Gender Bias in the Courts

“Many women do not recognize themselves as discriminated against; no better proof could be found of the totality of their conditioning.”

Kate Millett

In July 1996, the Judicial Council of California Advisory Committee on Gender Bias in the Courts completed their extensive research in Achieving Equal Justice for Women and Men in the California Courts Final Report. “As a leader of the task force movement put it, family law is an ‘area in which gender bias is rampant in the courts. . ..  probably because this is an area in which judges have the greatest discretion and where biases are the strongest.’” 

tiny woman standing next to giant man

The advisory committee found:

  • There was gender bias in the administration of family law.
  • Family law needs greater priority, more accessibility to the public, and more research.
  • Child support awards were too low and the duration of child support too short.
  • Child support is used inappropriately as a bargaining chip in custody disputes.
  • Child support has a disproportionate impact on the primary caretakers, usually women.
  • Custody decision-making is best cured by judicial, attorney, and mediator education.
  • Research on custody arrangements in the best interests of children is urgently needed.
  • Custody battles should be resolved quickly, and trials should be given preference.

“Where child abuse allegations are made in the course of a custody dispute, the committee found little evidence of rampant false allegations by mothers against fathers to gain an advantage in the custody dispute or to punish the father for leaving. Instead, the committee found other explanations for the apparent tendency of allegations of child sexual abuse to surface in the context of a divorce when they were not made prior to the separation of the parties.”

“The committee found that stereotypes and prejudices influence decision-making in the area of custody disputes. One example is the tendency to doubt the credibility of women who make allegations of child abuse and characterize them as hysterical or vindictive, even when medical evidence corroborates the claim.”

“The committee found that stereotypes and prejudices influence decision-making in the area of custody disputes. One example is the tendency to doubt the credibility of women who make allegations of child abuse and characterize them as hysterical or vindictive, even when medical evidence corroborates the claim.”

“The committee determined that there is an urgent need for speedy and expert resolution of these disputes. Among the committee’s recommendations for eliminating gender bias in custody decisions were calls for increased funding of research on joint custody and adoption of a model protocol for judges asked to resolve custody disputes involving allegations of child sexual abuse. In that regard, the committee believed that family law judges should be provided with access to existing investigatory reports on child abuse allegations and should have the power to order a separate investigation.”

The advisory committee also found:

  • There were serious misgivings about the fairness of mandatory mediation for women.
  • The level of qualifications and training of mediators was not uniform.
  • Mediator recommendations should be in writing.
  • Bench officers should state the reasons for relying on a mediator’s report in orders.
  • Parties need to be informed about mediation, how information is used, grievance procedure.
  • The custody evaluation process should be studied.

They found that judges rate the family law assignment as their lowest preference by a wide margin.

  • Working conditions for family law judges are substandard.
  • Public information on family law is grossly inadequate.
  • Inequities in the award of attorney’s fees present serious obstacles to obtaining attorneys.
  • Legislation is needed to ensure each party has access to representation.
  • A uniform statistical reporting system in family law is needed.
  • The judicial system needs to be educated so the nightmare of domestic violence is abated.

“Because 95 percent of the victims of domestic violence are women, the judicial system’s unequal and inadequate treatment of such victims and of the crime of domestic violence raised serious issues of gender bias. The evidence gathered by the committee demonstrated that when domestic-violence victims seek protection from the court, they are often further victimized by the process and by their experiences within the judicial system.”

woman cowering away from man

“The committee found that legislative efforts to protect victims of domestic violence have not been adequately enforced. In 15 recommendations and 11 separate findings, the committee sought to address the difficulties faced by domestic-violence victims who seek to obtain the protection that the law guarantees, and to suggest new or modified procedures and legislation to help ensure that the judicial system adequately, effectively, and fairly protects those who are battered from further abuse.” There were more findings:

  • Victims lack information about procedures.
  • Judiciary and law enforcement lack of understanding of the realities of domestic violence.
  • Restraining orders need enforcement to prevent further abusive behavior.
  • Mandatory mediation places the alleged batterer and the victim face-to-face.
  • Alleged batterers exert undue influence in a negotiated resolution of the dispute.
  • Custody and visitation orders frequently fail to include provisions to prevent further abuse.
  • Batterers had unrestricted access to their children and to their abused spouse.

“The judicial system needs to recognize the harmful effect of domestic violence on children who witness violence, even if children are not themselves physically abused.”

 The advisory committee further found:

  • The criminal justice system also disfavors victims of domestic violence, as these crimes are too frequently treated less seriously than similar violence against strangers.
  • Availability of pre-guilty plea diversion for those accused of spousal abuse is needed.
  • Batterers who escape any punishment are not effectively deterred from further abuse
  • The message given to both victims and batterers is that the judicial system does not consider domestic violence to be a serious crime.
  • Statewide standards to monitor effectiveness of domestic violence diversions are needed.
  • Understanding that domestic-violence victims are often terrified to speak up is needed.

The criminal justice system also disfavors victims of domestic violence, as these crimes are too frequently treated less seriously than similar violence against strangers.

“Because domestic violence is a crime against society, as well as an injury to the individual victim, the judicial system needs to acknowledge the seriousness of the problem and its responsibility for effective response so that the cycle of domestic violence may at last be ended.” The final report of the Judicial Council of California Advisory Committee on Gender Bias in the Courts could not have been more accurate in their analysis of the problem.

Sadly, there was no discernable change in the family courtrooms.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.