“Resistance is a sign that shows you’re going the right way”
Constance Friday
When Helen later left CA NOW in what seemed like a coup, the organization’s focus returned to abortion rights. We were focused on the rights of living children of divorce and separation, which didn’t quite fit.
Another 2002 study of 1,692 cases produced a report Domestic Violence and Visitation and Custody Decisions in New York Family Courts, Final Report. Chris O’Sullivan Ph.D. described the ironic Sophie’s Choice of a mother caught between child welfare services insisting she leave a violent abuser to protect the child, then ordered by family court to unprotect the child with visits to the abuser.
He also articulated the domestic violence advocate’s dilemma of wanting the mother safe, which then endangered the child due to family court orders to visit the batterer. The report also showed how little protection mothers’ restraining orders protected children and even had the opposite effect on visitation orders. The study found visitation was never denied to a parent enjoined by a protection order since “… fathers were more likely to persevere in securing a court order for visitation when the mother had sought and/or received an order of protection, and the perseverance was usually rewarded.”
The study found visitation was never denied to a parent enjoined by a protection order since “…fathers were more likely to persevere in securing a court order for visitation when the mother had sought and/or received an order of protection, and the perseverance was usually rewarded.”
Through his interviews with concerned matrimonial attorneys, Dr. O’Sullivan in New York City fully described the abysmal system failure in California.
- “To get children included in criminal court protection orders, the children have to be victimized; they may be included in temporary orders from the criminal court because the police report states that the children witnessed violence, but children are not usually included in permanent orders on those grounds…
- Most lawyers have never asked the court to deny visitation. Many judges respond punitively to such a request. In one court, to ask for no visitation at all ‘is to incur incredible wrath.’ Even to ask for supervised visitation creates hostility…
- The lawyers encourage the victim to file for a protection order in family court to get a hearing where they can introduce the history of abuse. …Lawyers encourage their clients to testify graphically about the abuse they have suffered, but it doesn’t always work. One lawyer complained that, even though the mother included in her petition that the father punched their teenage son in the face, the judge did not include the child in the protection order….
- Lawyers generally encourage the clients to tell the judge that it is important for the child to have a relationship with the father (70% of mothers did) …
- Sometimes the fathers file for custody in retaliation against support orders or arrest. Family court is used to harass the victim, to keep her coming back to court. ….
- (Good) law guardians come from a center that pairs social workers and lawyers; they are skilled at interviewing children and knowledgeable about domestic violence. In other counties, law guardians are unaffiliated attorneys (qualified by the state to represent children) who wander the courthouse halls and are called in to represent children …
- Forensic psychologists who conduct custody evaluations for the court ‘by and large’ recommend no limits on visitation, according to the lawyers…
- (One supervised visitation) center has been taking on the role of advocate for the non-custodial parent – usually the father and batterer (who paid the center) …
- Lawyers said they are seeing a serious surge in battered women being charged with failure to protect, at the rate of a couple of cases per month. One lawyer said that her client couldn’t get her children back from foster care even though the victim cooperated with a criminal case and the batterer was incarcerated.” (p 43-52.)
This was validating and appalling at the same time.
“Hey. How come things aren’t getting better? Evaluators should be making good recommendations now that they have to be trained about child sex abuse.”
“Dunno. Maybe training takes a while to kick in.” We were still waiting for Family Court section 3118 to transform the custody evaluation process so sexually abused kids would be protected. The plot thickened. Attorney Meera Fox of Child Abuse Solutions, Inc. (CASI) had started training evaluators and helped us figure out why nothing had changed. She visited other training programs and discovered lots of issues had reared their ugly heads:
- The training of court professionals on child sexual abuse was not standardized, as we had envisioned. Instead, training was done by private individuals, including former “parental alienation syndrome” proponents. PAS was the evaluators’ antidote to believing children’s reports of sexual abuse and taught by the Association of Family and Conciliation Courts (AFCC). It brushed abuse away as figments of a custody conflict and a vindictive parent. Most of the child sexual abuse training was a sham.
- The Judicial Council trainers but exercised little, if any, quality control or oversight of the training content on child sex abuse. It turned out there was a father’s rights advocate deep in the Judicial Council government apparatus in charge of approval of the training proposals
- California Rules of Court 5.225 was supposed to create rules for the training on child sexual abuse. The rule described 21 items for the 40 hours of training required by the Judicial Council. Child sexual abuse, the whole point of the training, was number 4 in the list, with no specified number of hours, no defined curriculum. The trainers could basically do as they wished. One trainer reserved just 10 minutes for child sex abuse tacked on to the end of the 40 hours. Training had been sabotaged.
- Training was only being given to private evaluators, mostly psychologists, who would pay to be trained. After we pointed out that the training was required for mediators also, court employees were finally trained, presumably by the same recycled “parental alienation” trainers.
- Once trained, evaluators were appointed, not under Family Code section 3118 and paid by the court under Family Code section 3112 as intended, but under Evidence Code 730 as expert witnesses. However, they were not bonafide experts in domestic violence, child sexual abuse or substance abuse, even though the majority of custody disputes were about those issues. They could certainly not to be considered experts after a brief training taught by experts in the antithesis of protecting children from sexual abuse.
- Once appointed, evaluators received quasi-judicial immunity. Parents who received shoddy reports had no way to make them accountable. They could not be sued. These lucrative appointments were reserved for system players, the ones described by investigator Karen Winner. Professionals who were well-trained by Child Abuse Solutions, Inc. and FVASI were rarely appointed.
- Evaluators gave parents psychological tests and interviewed them and their contacts. There was usually no attempt to contact law enforcement or child welfare agencies about reported crimes. They often misdiagnosed parents with maladies they had never had before, such as delusional disorders and “parental alienation syndrome”, and frequently pathologized victims of domestic violence for their fear of the batterer.
- The evaluators appointed under the expert witness code were supposed to give general information on the area of their expertise to the court, so the decision–maker has a better understanding of the subject. Instead, these non-experts made specific custody and visitation recommendations.
- Parents were not allowed to review the report to correct any errors in advance. The report with recommendations was given to the judge before witnesses were heard. It was like giving the answer to a quiz in advance. We couldn’t imagine that happening in a real jury trial, giving jurors recommendations about their decisions before they even heard witness testimony.
- Much of the information in the report was hearsay. For example, the report might state that the teacher told the evaluator on a phone call that the child was doing well, when in fact, the teacher said the child had serious behavioral problems but was managing to do most of his homework. Only direct testimony of a witness under oath is supposed to be allowed in court, since hearsay could be rumor, gossip or plain falsehood. But these reports were taken as gospel truth by the court, despite errors and omissions.
- Judges almost always followed the professionals’ recommendations. That meant the evaluator became the de facto judicial decision-maker. The judge basically outsourced decision-making, or as investigator Karen Winner put it, “abrogated” their duty. It made no difference what the witnesses had to say. Their testimony didn’t matter in the least. The decision was already made. Trials had become shams. Professor Geraldine Stahly called them “star chamber proceedings.”
- One of the most shocking parts was that custody evaluators charged whatever the market would bear. The fees were gigantic, exceeding $60,000 in some counties, and they often recommended having a second and third evaluation to continue the fee frenzy. The court rarely paid, even though the evaluation was done for the court’s need, not at the parents’ request. The parents were ordered to pay the evaluator directly. For obvious reasons, this process, which some called extortion and others called fleecing, did not happen with poor parents.
- The parent with more resources, usually the batterer father, was allowed to appear with an attorney at hearings even when the victim mother had no attorney. He often paid for the evaluation and got what he paid for. The parent with the most money won. If the appointment had been properly ordered under the Family Code 3118, the fees would be paid by the court to prevent overt bias. The court could be repaid by the parties if they had resources.
If it hadn’t been so deadly serious, it would have been farcical.