Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 21: Criminal Violence Fueled by Substance Abuse

“Only the Danger Assessment was more predictive than women’s perception of re-abuse risk.”

Andrew Klein

We were still praying at 9:00 pm every night.  Karen and I kept doing whatever we could think of, to see what worked.  We kept taking our Weekly Bulletins sporadically to every California Legislator. The website Distinction in Family Courts was developed to give grades to state actors on how well they protected children. It was a type of electronic court watch that included the whole system.

Professor Mo Hannah and attorney Barry Goldstein presented at the 2008 and 2010 National Coalition Against Domestic Violence national conferences. NCADV was 30 years old by then and had done excellent work lowering the rate of domestic violence homicides, particularly for men, because women no longer had to kill their batterers to escape the beatings. It was another one of those strange ironies. Executive Director Rita Smith became a strong supporter of the growing national movement to protect children of survivors.

Researcher Andrew R. Klein spelled out clearly the problem of having domestic violence in civil court inAlternatives Practical Implications of Domestic Violence Research for Probation Officers. The typical domestic violent defendant is a male under 35 years old.

  1. Prior criminal history. There is a high correlation between general criminality and domestic abuse. Therefore, probation caseloads should be periodically re-assessed to identify abusers.  The majority of domestic violence offenders share the general characteristics of most criminals, including alcohol and drug abuse, anti-social behavior, poor impulse control, and criminal thinking. Therefore, probation supervision must deal with the general criminality of the abusers. 
  2. Substance abuse. There is a high correlation between alcohol and substance abuse and domestic violence for both abusers and, to a lesser extent, victims. (This is not to say that substance abuse causes domestic violence.) Therefore, abstinence, enforced by testing should be a default condition of supervision unless or until it is clear that the abuser does not have a substance abuse problem. 
  3. Mental health. Batterers are no more likely to be mentally ill than the general population. Only 11% of repeat re-assaulters exhibited primary psychopathic disorders. Unless otherwise indicated, general mental health counseling does not address partner violence.
  4. Victim danger assessment. Victims are more likely to underestimate their risk. Therefore, probation officers should take victim expressions of fear or safety concerns very seriously. Also, they cannot ignore the risk in the absence of victim-expressed fear or concern. Victims face a horrible dilemma, according to the research. If they stay, they are in danger of abuse and if they leave, they are likewise in danger of abuse. Therefore, probation officers cannot assume victim separation from the abuser precludes revictimization.
  5. Multi-victim abusers. Deprived of their victim, many abusers will abuse another intimate partner or family member. Therefore, it is important for officers to identify new intimate partners, alert them to their risk for abuse and take appropriate safety measures. 
  6. Re-abuse and recidivism. Among misdemeanants, domestic violence defendants are generally the highest risk defendants released on probation. Therefore, any risk instrument used that does not find that the majority of abusers constitute high risk for re-abuse and/or recidivism significantly underestimates the risk of abusers. Only the Danger Assessment was more predictive than women’s perception of re-abuse risk.
  7. When will they reoffend? Most who re-offend do so sooner rather than later. Therefore, for probation supervision to be effective in reducing recidivism, it must start off quickly and intensively in order to thwart the predictable quick flow of re-abuse and recidivism. Once an abuser is rearrested, counter measures must be redoubled to prevent the increased likelihood of still more repeat abuse and offenses.
  8. Predictive of reoffending.  Two-thirds of re-abusers are between 17 and 35 with longer criminal records, repeated domestic violence offenses/civil protective orders, alcohol/substance abuse issues, and a victim who fears re-abuse.  Other predictive factors are fleeing the scene before police arrive, defaulting in court, unemployment, firearm possession and children who are not the abuser’s children in the home. Access to prior criminal histories and defendant age will provide a basic tool for risk prediction as accurate as more elaborate instruments.
  9. Not predictive. Factors that do not predict reoffending are absence of victim injuries; whether offense is classified as a misdemeanor or felony; type of relationship with victim; whether parties are living together, separated or have a child in common; and absence of prior domestic violence record.
  10. Predictive of lethality. Factors that substantially increase the likelihood of homicide/significant injuries are
    1. access to firearms.
    2. firearms in the house (women previously threatened or assaulted with a firearm or other weapon are 20 times more likely to be murdered).
    3. probationers with firearms.
    4. stepchildren in the household.
    5. separation/divorce/child support payment order.
    6. prior death threats.
    7. threats of suicide.
    8. stalking.
    9. short courtships. 
      Therefore, probation should remove firearms and keep monitoring the abuser, his relationship and the victim’s intentions to leave, divorce, or apply for child support.
  11. Do Batterer Intervention Programs work? Victims often remain with abusers hoping they will “get better” with batterer intervention programs. 
    • Program “treatment effect” is modest.
    • Probation officers should inform victims that abuser attendance at batterer programs will not substantially reduce their risk for re-abuse.
    • Anger management has no treatment effect for batterers.
    • Up to half of abusers mandated to attend batterer programs do not complete them and are likely to be less educated, unemployed, with a history of alcohol problems.
    • Program completers are less likely to re-abuse and are more likely to be older, employed, significantly less abusive, with limited prior criminal histories.
    • Lower recidivism is due to cumulative effects of successful prosecution, probation monitoring, court ordered counseling and completing counseling.
    • Batterer programs serve as dynamic risk instruments. Therefore, probation officers should closely monitor the offender.
    • Re-abuse can be prevented if probation responds quickly and effectively to violations.
  12. Do No Contact Orders work? Civil or criminal no contact orders are not sufficient to stop re-abuse. Therefore, probation officers must warn victims that safety planning is still required even if no contact orders are in effect.
  13.  Does Specialized Domestic Violence Supervision work? Yes, specialized supervision made a significant difference in lowering re-abuse or new crimes for most abusers, but it made no difference for high-risk abusers who had failed domestic violence probation before or were sentenced concurrently for multiple domestic violence charges.
  14. Victim contact.  Specialized domestic violence supervision has a victim focus and direct communication with victims. Therefore, probation officers should attempt to contact victims.
  15. Does substance abuse treatment reduce recidivism? Increased abstinence among alcoholic men achieved because of treatment has also been found to significantly decrease partner assaults. Therefore, standard probationary conditions for intimate partner abusers should include substance abuse treatment and conditions of abstinence with testing.
  16. Does sentencing violators reduce recidivism? Batterer program failure and alcohol abuse are related to re-abuse. Permitting chronic, violent predators to remain in the community may jeopardize victim safety. Increased court monitoring and beginning programs all over headed off any expected increase in re-abuse. Therefore, probation needs to partner with prosecutors for appropriate response, including incarcerating violators likely to re-abuse.

Attorney Seth Goldstein from Child Abuse Forensic Institute presented a workshop to the State Advisory Committee on Sexual Assault Victim Services in June. His talk was titled When the Authorities Fail to Address Child Sexual Abuse in Custody Cases: The Problem of System Failure. As a former law enforcement officer specializing in child sex abuse cases, and a family law attorney, he had double clout.

Still nothing happened.

Violent, incestuous fathers were clearly protected in these cases. How could an entire system work so smoothly in concert to help them, not the children?  And why?

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.