“Grief is a funny thing because you don’t have to carry it with you for the rest of your life. After a bit you set it down by the roadside and walk on and leave it resting there.”
Rosamunde Pilcher
The Marin effort had started with a request to the Marin County Civil Grand Jury in 1997 to investigate decisions by Judge Michael Dufficy and Commissioner Sylvia Shapiro that placed children at risk. That investigation was halted abruptly by County Counsel. Undaunted, Grand Jury chairman Martin Silverman and other citizens, including local activist Jean Taylor, contacted Karen Winner.
The February 28, 2000 Marin County Winner report Findings on Judge Michael Dufficy, Commissioner Sylvia Shapiro and Court-Appointees in Marin County’s Superior Court in California showed the court routinely appointed favored lawyers and relied on questionable psychologists who received lucrative sums and provided reports biased in favor of the parent with the most money. She named attorney Mauna Berkov and mental health professionals Margaret Lee, PhD, Frederica Conrad PhD and Edward Oklan MD as part of the game.
The Winner report recommended having the Chief Judge of California appoint an independent prosecutor to review the cited cases. Prior to the Winner investigation, Judge Dufficy and his attorney friends, who called themselves the Family Law Elite Attorneys (FLEAS), had crude party weekends at his vacation ranch, which led to accusations of favoritism.
The Winner report recommended having the Chief Judge of California appoint an independent prosecutor to review the cited cases.
After the Winner report, the San Francisco Weekly published an article by Matt Isaacs titled “Odor, Odor in the Court” about the blatant cronyism displayed by Judge Michael Dufficy. The National Law Journal reported on the investigation when the judge became the subject of an FBI investigation, Protests began. A Blue-Ribbon Panel was formed. A Judicial Council investigation and citizen recall happened.
The protests fizzled out, the recall effort was unsuccessful, there was no prosecution, and nothing happened to the court officers.
In the midst of it all, Judge Dufficy left his family court position three months early citing a heart condition and moved on, retiring in 2010 with a handsome retirement package. He was replaced by two equally problematic judges Verna Adams and Beverly Woods.
In July 2000, Alanna Krause, a Marin County child who bore the brunt of this scam, wrote an article for the San Francisco Daily Journal titled Letting Children Speak for Themselves. She identified Commissioner Shapiro as a friend of her attorney father. Alanna herself called in nine reports to child welfare services about her father’s abuse. Nothing.
When a teacher witnessed her father physically attacking Alanna, he quickly put her into an abusive lockdown private juvenile facility. When she finally got out, after figuring out she needed to parrot what her jailors wanted her to say, the teenager fled to Los Angeles where the Juvenile Court helped her get back to her safe mother. She successfully sued her therapist who had been having an intimate relationship with her father.
We gathered mothers from the greater Sacramento area who met individually with Karen Winner. She interviewed them and closely reviewed their documents. Her May 15, 2000 Sacramento County Winner report was titledPlacing Children at Risk: Questionable Psychologists and Therapists in the Sacramento Court and Surrounding Counties.
She cited the Sacramento Grand Jury recommendations to remove child sexual abuse cases from the Family Court. We had hoped she would highlight Judge Peter McBrien who had ruined Josie Cohen and her son’s lives, but her focus was primarily on mental health professionals Sidney Nelson Ph.D.; Jeffrey Miller Ph.D.; Larry Leatham Ph.D.; and Marsha Nohl, head of Associated Family Therapy for Effective Recovery (A.F. T.E.R.) They received lucrative court appointments and recommended placing children at risk.
The report showed patterns of inaccuracies and misleading statements by professionals who were supposed to be acting in a neutral capacity. Their distortions invariably strengthened the case against parents trying to protect children and provided judges and commissioners with expert “cover” for their frightening decisions. She found judges had abrogated their independent decision–making authority to mental health professionals. Her most pointed comment was, “…pedophile-friendly views have infiltrated the courts in Sacramento and surrounding communities.”
“…pedophile-friendly views have infiltrated the courts in Sacramento and surrounding communities.”
Her primary recommendations were to:
- Create a statewide Grand Jury with checks and balances that would be empowered to investigate child abuse, and
- Have federal authorities investigate these professionals for criminal collusion with alleged molester parents. She recommended immediately suspending payments to experts and child attorneys and launching an investigation into criminal collusion between professionals and judicial officers who place children at risk with alleged perpetrators.
She recommended four agencies to investigate civil rights and criminal violations:
- Independent state prosecutor appointed by the California Chief Justice
- Statewide Grand Jury
- Federal prosecutor
- U. S. Department of Justice
There was a well-attended press conference where Karen Winner publicly castigated evaluators for using parental alienation syndrome to disadvantage the parent trying to protect. She said family law judges were essentially conceding their decision-making responsibilities to evaluators, as they routinely rubber-stamped decisions. The Daily Recorder had an article by Tom Nadeau, Report Calls for Reform Of State’s Family Courts.

The only outcome of the effort was that we heard that evaluator Jeffrey Miller Ph.D. stepped away from his practice. We didn’t hear much from Sidney Nelson Ph.D. after he was mentioned at the press conference. Marsha Nohl kept going until she died in 2010.
Our first decade was exciting, if not successful in ending the dangerous practices. We were driven by a sense of urgency and the fire of experiencing such egregious human rights violations against children and mothers. We were certain the truth would prevail but figured we needed a better plan.
One of the early events was the Planning Summit for the Safe Child, organized by Elize St. Charles in 2000 and again in 2001 as part of the San Diego FVSAI conference. The event was co-sponsored by Leadership Council, Children’s Institute International, Our Children Our Future and Family Violence Sexual Assault Institute, and included mental health professionals, attorneys, judges and child advocates. Our lofty goals included:
- Create a national database of cases.
- Work toward federal investigations.
- Hold public hearings and educational campaigns, including letter writing.
- Create a public relations media campaign and a Speaker’s Bureau.
- Hold national demonstrations.
- Develop a coalition of ethical professionals.
- Maintain an advocacy system with wraparound support.
- Remove child sexual abuse cases from Family Court.
- Create a court watch program for citizen oversight.
- Encourage multi-disciplinary interview centers.
- Collect court satisfaction surveys/Performance Evaluations and recall judges.
- Apply for grants.
- Change laws
The laws we wanted to change were to:
- Develop high quality, uniform required professional training.
- Disconnect child support from parenting time.
- Presume primary custody to the primary parent who did most caretaking.
- Create child centered laws, including an age for child’s choice.
- Ensure children are competent witnesses and full parties to custody cases.
- Have attorneys for children advocate only for their safe wishes.
- Develop strong accountability for professionals.
- Eliminate mediation when there is domestic violence or child abuse.
- Eliminate custody and visitation recommendations by auxiliary professionals.
- Eliminate junk science and in chamber meetings and follow the rules of evidence.
- Admit all evidence of violence/abuse on a standardized form.
- Have law enforcement thoroughly investigate all crimes against children.
- Prohibit forced visits between children and their identified abusers.
- Use supervised visits only for violent/incestuous parents.
- Ensure safety is an affirmative defense.
- Use a safe relative for temporary care, instead of foster care.
- Have a safe hotline for CPS, family court, law enforcement whistleblowers.
Our little organization’s mission was to conduct research, advocate for safe parents and educate whoever would sit still about this impossible-to-believe situation. We got an 800 number and board insurance. People donated money and items, including an old car and an even older trailer which had us scratching our heads on how to turn them into cash. I kept careful books.
Our goal was to fix the situation. We thought our work would be done within a few years and we could go back to our normal lives. We obviously had no idea what we were up against.
Our goal was to fix the situation. We thought our work would be done within a few years and we could go back to our normal lives.