Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 27: Advocates for Child Empowerment and Safety (ACES)

“A child, like all other human beings, has inalienable rights.”

Lucretia Mott

On January 15, 2014, protective mother Mary Seguin submitted 286 cases with evidence that children were placed with abusers to the Department of Justice in Texas. We still do not know which office received the cases and her request to investigate. All we know is that Mary disappeared off our radar screen right afterwards. We even asked a private investigator to locate her, to no avail. We never did find out what happened to the cases or to her, which was not reassuring. I fervently hoped she just decided to lower her profile.

woman holding giant stack of papers

Melissa Knight-Fine of the Legislative Coalition to Prevent Child Abuse, who helped shepherd the bill that created Family Code 3118 fourteen years before, sent a letter on January 21, 2014 to California legislators asking for a form to implement investigations in a more efficient and uniform manner. She documented the misuse of Evidence Code 730 expert witness statute which was being used to evade the protocols Senator Ortiz had so carefully spelled out. 

Nothing happened.

I attended a Judicial Summit at the Commonwealth Club on March 20 where I discovered the attorneys and presenters were well aware of the problem of the imbalance of one person being self-represented while the other was not, and the lack of court reporters to ensure the right to appeal in family court.

Nothing happened, although the idea was percolating.

In March 2014, Advocates for Child Empowerment and Safety: Movement for Divorce Court System Reform (ACES) was launched as a 501(c)(4) organization, a national umbrella to unite the many local groups working to reform Family Courts across the country.

ACES replaced our National Safe Child Coalition which had been hijacked. Marivic Mabanag, Meera Fox, Kathleen Russell and I came up with the name, and this time we made sure the paperwork was in place before announcing ACES. We figured this name was even better, since we would be moving from Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) to Advocates for Child Empowerment and Safety (ACES). Steve Burdo became Executive Director.

Law Professor Joan Meier finished perfecting the Congressional Resolution, which was fact-checked by Hogan Lovells Law Firm.

The idea paralleled Congresswoman Connie Morella’s successful 1989-1990 Congressional Resolution H. Con. Res. 172 which had 83 co-sponsors. It expressed “the sense of the Congress that, for the purpose of determining child custody, evidence of spousal abuse should create a statutory presumption that it is detrimental to the child to be placed in the custody of an abusive parent.”

Our proposed Resolution was focused squarely on children’s safety, rather on their parents. It was the beginning of a journey, a quest that finally had a discrete and achievable federal “hook.” I felt a bit like a pointer dog who had just spotted a grouse in the bushes. Now we had to figure out how to have it go forward as a bill. Again, we knew nothing about that process, but were ready to learn.

We were surprised to find out that nearly 15 years before, in 1997, Congresswoman Connie Morella had tried to pass another Congressional Resolution H. Con. Res. 182, in addition to her successful H. Con. Res, 172 which was a presumption against batterers getting custody.

Her second attempt was right on point, which probably doomed it.  It said exactly what we really wanted. With only 14 co-sponsors and not enough support, the bill was scuttled. It would have expressed the sense of Congress with respect to child custody, child abuse, and victims of domestic and family violence.

It is described fully here in case future generations wish to take it forward.

“Whereas domestic violence has serious detrimental effects on children, even when they do not directly witness such violence;

Whereas courts still hold women to higher standards of conduct than they do men;

Whereas gender bias still exists within the courts, particularly those making and affecting child custody determinations;

Whereas gender bias has long existed and still exists within the mental health system;

Whereas, as a result of this gender bias, many myths are that women make false allegations of domestic violence or child abuse, and most particularly of child sexual abuse, during divorce and custody proceedings;

Whereas false accusations by women are in fact rare, occurring no more often than do other false reports of crimes, such as bank robbery;

Whereas the myth that women make false accusations is so widely believed that many child protective service agents have policies of not bothering to investigate such allegations when made during the pendency of divorce or custody proceedings or only superficially investigate such allegations;

Whereas there are many myths that fathers are discriminated against in custody proceedings, even though studies show that fathers fighting for custody  actually win sole custody or joint custody in 40 to 70 percent of these  disputes;

Whereas the American Psychological Association’s Presidential Task Force on  Violence and the Family has found in a 1996 Presidential Report that Congress views as authoritative on questions of domestic violence, child abuse, and custody determination that-

  1. fathers who abuse their children’s mothers are more likely to dispute custody and visitation than are fathers who are not violent;
  2. there is no reliable data to support the phenomenon of “parental alienation” syndrome, although courts and custody evaluators frequently use that term and other inappropriate terms to discount the children’s fear in hostile and psychologically abusive situations; and
  3. psychological evaluators not trained in domestic violence ignore or minimize the violence and give inappropriate pathological labels to women’s responses to chronic victimization, including “parental alienation” to blame mothers for their children’s reasonable fear or anger toward their violent fathers.

Whereas many courts and professionals use the baseless parental alienation syndrome to force mothers into joint or shared parenting arrangements or to give custody to fathers, especially when mothers try to protect themselves or their children from men who abuse them or their children;

Whereas almost every custody evaluator or judge recognizes how important  familiar routines and objects are to a child, particularly in times of stress, but often fails to recognize the importance for the child of maintaining its living arrangement with the child’s primary caretaker parent;

Whereas Congress never intended that the Parental Kidnapping Prevention Act be used-

  1. to encourage forcing shared parenting arrangements when it is not in the child’s best interest;
  2. to prohibit an abused or protective parent from protecting themselves or their child;
  3. as a tool to punish a parent, without regard for the needs of the child, by removing physical custody of a child from a fit abused or protective parent; or
  4. as a tool to punish abused or protective parents who act to protect themselves or theirchildren;

Whereas when there is domestic or family violence or major discord between the parents, shared parenting arrangements, couples counseling, or mediation arrangements only exacerbate the difficulties of the children and give  the abusive parent more tools with which to victimize the other members of the family;

Whereas children who grow up not seeing abusive parents clearly held accountable for their abuse are reinforced in believing that domestic and family violence are socially acceptable and effective means of behavior; and

Whereas every State has legislation or judicial decisions that base its custody determinations on what is in the best interests of the child:

Now, therefore, be it Resolved by the House of Representatives (the Senate concurring), That it is the sense of Congress that–

  1. for purposes of determining child custody, it is in the best interest of children to have a presumption that children should have their main physical residence with their primary caretaker parent unless that parent is unfit;
  2. for purposes of determining child custody, it is not in the best interest of children to–
    • (A) force parents to share custody over the objection of one or both parents or when there is a history of domestic or family violence;
    • (B) punish abused or protective parents who protect themselves or their children;
    • (C) presume that allegations of domestic and family violence are likely to be made falsely
    • or for tactical advantage during custody and divorce proceedings; and
    • (D) make “friendly parent” provisions a factor when there is abuse by one parent againstthe other or a child;
  3. child abuse and child sexual abuse allegations should be fully and impartially investigated regardless of when they are raised or whether the child has recanted the allegation;
  4. States should be far more protective of victims of domestic and family violence in custody and visitation determinations and not order mediation, couples counseling, shared custody, mutual orders of protection, unsupervised visitation, or other measures when they may endanger victims of domestic and family violence; and
  5. States should provide training in domestic violence and child abuse, as they impact custody, child support and visitation determinations, to all professionals who interact with children and parents (including judges, attorneys, guardians ad litem, therapists, mental health professionals, custody evaluators, child protective services personnel, and court appointed special advocates). 

If only that Resolution had passed…. but sadly, it didn’t.

In April 2014, Joan Meier moved to a new phase of her study of Child Custody Outcomes in Cases Involving Parental Alienation and Abuse Allegations. The pilot study of appeals found that 95% of the trial courts had awarded joint or sole custody to alleged and adjudicated batterers.

We knew the real problem was that criminal violence and child sexual abuse was being treated like civil matters, with court personnel ignoring evidence and disbelieving victims.

Researcher Eric Nelson PhD published If You Want to Convict a Domestic Violence Batterer, List Multiple Charges in the Police Report  in 2014. His research was as practical as it was eye-opening. He found that when “multiple crimes are described or listed in the first responding police officer’s written report, there is a substantially greater odds that the suspect will be prosecuted and found guilty.” 

  • Currently, only one third of reports listed more than one crime.
  • Only 29% of single charge misdemeanor reports resulted in conviction.
  • The conviction rate was 100% when reports listed four or more crimes in their initial report (including crimes against victim children and others).
  • Children could have been listed as victims about 61% to 86% of the time.
  • Police routinely failed to list children as victims (4% of investigations).
  • 97% of cases were resolved through plea bargaining, which was cost effective.

[W]hen “multiple crimes are described or listed in the first responding police officer’s written report, there is a substantially greater odds that the suspect will be prosecuted and found guilty.

His earlier article Investigating Domestic Violence: Raising Prosecution and Conviction Rates show that convictions were helped by the responding officer:

  • Taking photographs of the crime scene.
  • Finding witnesses to the crime.
  • Obtaining protective orders to protect victims.
  • Making arrests of the perpetrators.

When law enforcement conducts a proper investigation and makes arrests, criminals are likely to be convicted. All these would help protect children of domestic violence.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.