Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 4: Change Agents

“The secret of change is to focus all of your energy not on fighting the old, but on building the new.”

Socrates

The Battered Mothers Testimony Project at Wellesley College in Massachusetts held a Human Rights Tribunal on Domestic Violence & Child Custody at the Massachusetts State House in May 2002 based on collected testimony starting in 1999. They documented the same human rights violations we were finding.  Amnesty International was involved with them.  

Co-authors Monica Ghosh Driggers, J.D. , Carrie Cuthbert and Kim Slote wrote: “It is our contention that these state practices – both actions and failure to act – violate the human rights of battered mothers and their children to bodily integrity, security of person, equal protection of the law, non-discrimination freedom from torture, an adequate standard of living, the highest attainable standard of physical and mental health, and other rights as guaranteed under international human rights law.” 

One of the attorneys who helped to author the Battered Mothers Testimony Project report later presented it to a roomful of our California judges who openly scorned and mocked her. She was utterly shocked. We were not.

One of the attorneys who helped to author the Battered Mothers Testimony Project report later presented it to a roomful of our California judges who openly scorned and mocked her.

Our Eighth Annual Child Sexual Abuse Conference on April 7, 2002 was titled Trauma and Recovery: Medical Consequences and Healing from Adverse Childhood Experiences.  Dr. Vincent Felitti, author of the seminal Adverse Childhood Experiences Study (ACE) at Kaiser was the keynote speaker and showed such kindness and humanity. One survivor Sandy said she felt like Exhibit A in Dr. Felitti’s talk on the ACE study. He sat at the table with us for the survivor panel, not flinching from our gruesome ritual abuse histories.

Dr. Felitti also presented the next day at the Department of Rehabilitation headquarters, but the director and upper-level people were noticeably absent. That was surprising, since counselors were dealing every day with clients who had high ACE scores, and the top echelon should have been supportive. Denial was everywhere.

My partner in anti-crime Karen Anderson and I went to Arizona at the request of the Arizona Coalition Against Domestic Violence in May 2002 to talk about how to form a protective parent organization.  We pretty much told our story of failures, since we had not found the way to make things better. Nobody had.

We presented at the September 2002 FVSAI Seventh Annual International Conference. I spoke on ritual abuse and showed a video of going through re-living an abuse memory. People cried.  The best part was that the False Memory Foundation (FMSF) sent out letters to all conference collaborators, including CA Protective Parents Association, before the conference. 

The FMSF was protesting the “inclusion of two sessions on Ritual Abuse (SRA) [that] undermines the credibility of the conference. There is no evidence for any organized ritual abuse conspiracy…” and asking us to “help correct this unfortunate situation.”

The letter was signed by none other than Pamela Freyd, PhD, Executive Director. She was the founder of the False Memory Syndrome Foundation and had written to all the presenters at the conference. I’m sure she did not know we were the very ones presenting the two sessions. Now that was genuinely funny.

Conference coordinator Bob Geffner sent out a fabulous email to everyone involved in the conference, fully supporting us. “The fact is that there are victims of ritualistic abuse, and that such forms of maltreatment are recognized by mental health and law enforcement.”

Karen presented on a plenary panel on “And Justice for All? Protecting Family Violence Victims in Court.”

The audience seemed shocked at the preliminary data from the Stahly survey project, which was indeed shocking. It found that children in 13 California counties were placed with their identified abusers 91% of the time and the protective parent was placed on supervised visits 54% of the time.

…children in 13 California counties were placed with their identified abusers 91% of the time and the protective parent was placed on supervised visits 54% of the time.

We surprised Bob Geffner with the annual Friend of the Child award. He was both pleased and embarrassed. We met reporter Kristen Lombardi of the Boston Phoenix who received an award from FVSAI. She had broken open the pedophile priest scandal story in Boston and opened the door for the world to know that important men sexually abused children. 

We asked her to help us expose the pedophile father scandal which she did on January 9, 2003 in her superb article Custodians of Abuse.  The article quoted Colorado attorney Alan Rosenfeld. “If we ever sat down to design the worst possible system that protects the smallest number of children, it would look a lot like the family courts look today.”

There was an immediate reaction to the article.  An abusive father sued her and The Boston Phoenix. 

In 2002, The Puppet Child by Talia Carner was published

We sent out the Child Custody Investigation/Evaluation template, asking evaluators to help us refine it and let them know about the new laws and rules. We sent information to the Little Hoover Commission oversight entity. They decided we were talking about juvenile court and assured us they were definitely on it.

We were asked to write letters in support of bills in the Legislature, including SB 1779 (Burton) to extend the statute of limitations for child sexual abuse. It didn’t pass.

The refusal to address the issue of family court judges placing children at risk seemed almost universal. Our pestering squeaky wheel only irritated the system players. Were they all snickering? We kept going because we had a human rights issue on our hands that needed to be heard. The sky really was falling on Chicken Little, if you happened to be an abused child of divorced parents.

Chicken Little, "the sky is falling"

CA Protective Parents Association turned three years old. We asked for our books to be audited to be sure we were doing them correctly (we pretty much were), became a listed member of the CA State Employees’ Charitable Campaign (United Way) and contracted with a grant writing company paying them to write a grant. It was turned down flat. 

We approached the Southern Poverty Law Center that did civil rights work.

“Thank you for your letter. Unfortunately, we can’t help your organization. Good luck.”

We tried to meet with the Commission on Judicial Performance (CJP), the entity that is supposed to oversee judges. They said a meeting was not appropriate.

We wrote to the director of the California Judicial Council Center for Children, Families and the Court about the dreadful outcome for children with attorneys for the minor.

Nothing.

However, we did manage to get their attention when California NOW requested a meeting.

On December 11, 2002, Helen Grieco of CA NOW, Antonia Burroughs of CAADV, Meera Fox of Child Abuse Solutions, Inc., Kathy Mathis of Battered Women’s Center, San Fernando Valley and I from CA Protective Parents Association met with Dianne Nunn and representatives from the Judicial Council, the Office of the Chief Justice and the Commission on Judicial Performance. 

It felt a bit like a nerdy OK Corral standoff, the two groups positioned on the edge of their chairs lined up on either side of a huge, polished wood table, yellow pads of paper and ballpoint pens in front of each.

(The meeting with the Judicial Council, the Office of the Chief Justice and the Commission on Judicial Performance) felt a bit like a nerdy OK Corral standoff, the two groups positioned on the edge of their chairs lined up on either side of a huge, polished wood table, yellow pads of paper and ballpoint pens in front of each.

“Nice to meet you.”

“Nice to meet you too.”

We went around the table carefully explaining the issue. Custody evaluators fail to follow the law and routinely recommend children live with accused incest perpetrators in contested custody disputes. We described the proposed solution: a standardized form to implement the laws and rules.

They were polite. They equally carefully explained that the development of such a form would take years to accomplish.

We smiled. Meera pushed several copies of our Child Custody Investigator/Evaluation Report template across to them and said sweetly that we had already done that, and the form was being used in training evaluators with great success and appreciation. We asked for the Judicial Council to:

  • Review the template.
  • Hold public hearings.
  • Issue a public policy statement on handling family violence cases.
  • Support legislation to improve the protection of abused children in family court.

The meeting ended quickly. We were about as welcome as Erin Brockovich presenting photographs to Pacific Gas and Electric on their toxic chemical dump into a Hinkley CA pond. 

We decided not to hold our collective breath.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.