“We do not have to become heroes overnight. Just a step at a time, meeting each thing as it comes up, seeing it as not dreadful as it appears, discovering that we have the strength to stare it down.”
Eleanor Roosevelt
Our hopes of our new President caring about children seeking safety from dangerous fathers were soon dashed.
The day after Fathers’ Day, right after our Mother’s Day demonstration in front of his house, President Obama announced the fatherhood program, asking Congress to allocate $500 million for a Fatherhood, Marriage and Families Innovation Fund. The Temporary Aid to Needy Families (TANF) Healthy Marriage and Responsible Fatherhood, passed a decade before, had just gotten a huge boost.
“I can’t legislate fatherhood. I can’t force anybody to love a child. … What we can do is come together and support fathers who are willing to step up…. When fathers abandon their responsibilities, there is harm done to those kids. They are more likely to live in poverty, they are more likely to drop out of school, they are more likely to wind up in prison”” he said in the Washington Post article Obama visits SE Washington to announce fatherhood program
His own absentee father seemed to have led him to try to make men into good fathers. We realized he must have been envisioning fathers like his, with a high absentee rate in families. We were glad for his desire to have them “step up” but he seemed to interpret the problem as fathers who didn’t pay child support or visit their children.

There was nothing about the safety of abused children waiting for their fathers to become good men through his initiative. He had bought the fathers’ rights storyline that children need their fathers, without the caveat of ensuring child safety first.
I felt crushed. I had driven down from Lake Tahoe in a snowstorm to vote for him. But that would not stop our mothers’ demonstrations. Somebody would be listening.
We started to learn our way around Washington D.C. and decided to come back twice a year to demonstrate. We would go into the halls of Congress wearing our white t-shirts, telling our stories, hoping someone would know how to stop these human rights violations.
We learned about and honored the brave Rose Street women in Germany. “During the Holocaust, on February 28, 1943 a group of Jewish men married to German women were rounded up and put in a former Jewish community center on Rose Street in Berlin. The German wives, blinded by rage and emboldened by love, gathered and stood in front of the center.
The crowd slowly grew, almost all women, 1000 of them, and refused to leave. ‘Give us back our men,’ they insisted. By March 4, SS troops set up machine gun nests and ordered the streets cleared. The women stood.
“Six days after the protest began, Joseph Goebbels inexplicably ordered the release of the 1500 prisoners inside, some with concentration camp numbers freshly tattooed. It is still unclear why the Nazis buckled to the Rose Street Women.” (Sacramento Bee, Feb 27, 1993)

We prayed every night at 9:00 pm like the British during the Silent Minute, for a miracle to bring the children back to safety.
During World War British Major Wellesley Tudor Pole began the idea of a minute of prayer, meditation or wish for peace, “according to each person’s beliefs.” During the Second World War London was bombed nightly for nearly two months beginning on September 7, 1940.
King George VI, Winston Churchill and US President Franklin D. Roosevelt got on board with the Silent Minute and “on November 10, 1940 at 9:00, all of Briton was gathered around their radios to find out how the war was going. The announcer explained that Big Ben chiming out 9:00 would be broadcast before the news from then on. The people of Briton were asked to take that one minute during the chiming to pray for, or visualize, peace.” Millions did.
“While being interrogated by the British after the war, one Nazi official gave his opinion of why Germany had lost. He said, “During the war, you had a secret weapon for which we could find no countermeasure, and which we did not understand, but it was very powerful. It was associated with the striking of Big Ben at 9:00 p.m. each evening. I believe you called it the ‘Silent Minute’.”

In 1994 Dorothy Forster revived the Big Ben Silent Minute movement. So did we.
Meanwhile, things were getting worse on the ground in family courts.
An article by Susan Taylor Martin was published in the Tampa Bay Times on May 21, 2010 titled Controversial disorder at center of bitter custody cases. It described the chilling process of trying to brainwash children to love abusive parents they hate.
The article featured Pamela Hoch, founder of Rachel Foundation for Family Reintegration. A judge had given her custody of her two younger children after deciding their father had falsely claimed she was part of a religious cult. The older ones stayed with the father, as they were considered too attached to him. She became a true believer in the controversial junk science of “parental alienation syndrome.”
She said most of the parents they work with had “been accused of something,” including an early case when they were operating a reunification program out of a Maryland church parsonage.
A mother and son had fled for a decade from a father accused of molesting the boy. When they were caught, the 14-year-old was ordered to the Rachel Foundation to bond with his father. When he was interviewed later at age 23, he said his experience with the Foundation was traumatic and scary, saying “It’s taken every day of my life since to put myself back together in a way I see fit.”
Pamela and her second husband Robert Hoch then began operating Rachel House out of a mobile home in the Texas Hill Country in central Texas about an hour and a half north of San Antonio, possibly near a tiny place called Harper. It is a five-acre spread 22 miles from the nearest sheriff’s office. It would be hard to run away from.
A girl who went through the program said she and her sister were not allowed to eat for the first two days, then began making things up so they could eat. Robert Hoch is Vice President of the Association of Missing and Exploited Children’s Organization. There are no oversight mechanisms, since it is not a hospital, group home or mental health facility.
Back in California, we were restless. We would drive the 1000 mile round-trip to Southern CA and back at the drop of a hat, searching for allies and answers. In June, Kathleen and I met with Judge DeAnn Salcido in San Diego.
She shared that she had been trained to be suspicious of allegations of abuse during a divorce matter by the Monterey County new judge’s training. Judge Salcido had a tape of trainer Judge Mize advising judges to be suspicious of the timing of domestic violence and child abuse allegations.
Sacramento Judge James Mize, as he proudly informed Senator Sheila Kuehl in his testimony to the Legislature years before, had indeed trained judges, but apparently not in ways that would protect abused children.
Informal training by judicial supervisors mirrored the formal training message for Judge Salcido. Judges were trained to minimize allegations of abuse as a ploy to get custody. Skepticism was the norm.
Judge Salcido looked to CPS for substantiation of the abuse. A friend who worked for CPS later explained to her that the agency was afraid of lawsuits if they decided a case against a parent, so they were hesitant to substantiate cases of child sexual abuse. Since mothers usually brought the allegations to the court against the fathers, the accused fathers would use litigation tactics against the CPS agency.
A friend who worked for CPS later explained to her that the agency was afraid of lawsuits if they decided a case against a parent…
Judge Salcido was willing to speak out publicly, since the mis-training had led her to make a catastrophic decision in the Joyce Murphy case, ordering Joyce’s young daughter to live with her father who was accused of sexually abusing his daughter and who was later convicted of sex abuse of her young friends also.
The California Commission on the Status of Women held a series of public forums throughout California to determine the needs of women and children. We again brought attention to the needs of children of divorce who are placed with batterers and molesters.
On August 3, 2010, Kathleen Russell and Steve Burdo from Center for Judicial Excellence and Karen and I from California Protective Parents Association presented at the National Coalition Against Domestic Violence (NCADV) in Anaheim. Kathleen showed the Dr. Phil clip. We presented Geraldine Stahly’s research data on protective mothers losing custody to abusers and discussed earlier civil rights demonstrations. I invited people to our upcoming Mothers of Lost Children Washington DC demonstration on October 1.
Judge DeAnn Salcido was very clear in her workshop. She said court watch was effective, as was talking to the Presiding Judge. Karen and I decided we could do that.

NCADV Executive Director Rita Smith invited Judge Deanne Salcido, Kathleen and me to meet again with Lynn Rosenthal, who was the White House Advisor on Violence Against Women from 2009-2015. Her job was to help ensure battered women had resources to ensure their safety from further abuse when they left the offender.
During the meeting, Judge Salcido confirmed how biased and corrupt many of her colleagues were and described the lack of communication between family court and child welfare services. These cases were hot potatoes even for good judges. Judges rely on CWS social workers’ findings. At the same time, child welfare services rely on family court investigations.
Social workers tend to close the CWS case and turn the case over to the family court to sort out the abuse allegations. The family court would then decide there is no abuse, based on fact that the social worker closed their CWS case. It was a vicious circle. Children lost at every turn.
It sounded like a lethal Three Stooges farce.
