Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 8: Conflict versus Crime

“Not to punish the criminal is to punish his victim.”

Tamerlan Kuzgov

In 2015, U.C. Davis law professor Carol S. Bruch wrote Child Custody Law Needs a Course Correction: Thoughts from California. 

She reported that in both 1994 and 2010, 82% of mothers nationwide were custodial parents, practically the same as in 1968. She cited long-term research showing that reliability of parental contact, not frequency of contact, was key to children’s wellbeing. She described an alarming study of court-ordered overnight visits between infants and their noncustodial fathers that resulted in a serious deterioration in the child’s attachment to its mother, without improving the child-father attachment.

She continued. “The literature is clear that conflict is what causes problems for children, not cooperation.” She cited research showing very little decrease in hostility or litigation rates in high-conflict cases, until the children age out of the system. Given the research, “the goals for reform should be to provide child custody orders that will protect children’s healthy development. This means granting custody to the fit parent who has been the child’s primary caretaker, unless that parent is unfit to exercise custody.

“This means granting custody to the fit parent who has been the child’s primary caretaker, unless that parent is unfit to exercise custody.”

This was the same recommendation made by West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals Chief Justice Richard Neely in 1984 in the Yale Law and Policy Review The Primary Caretaker Parent Rule: Child Custody and the Dynamics of Greed.

Carol Bruch’s legislative solutions were unequivocal. “To make this possible, several doctrines must be overruled or repealed:

  • friendly parent provisions,
  • frequent and continuing contact rules, and
  •  joint-custody preferences.” 

She recommended continuing mandatory parenting classes, voluntary custody mediation and individual counseling but stated that “recommending mediation (arbitration) should be prohibited.” To lessen stress, courts should not make coercive orders except protective orders.

A Davis Police Department officer explained to me that the police were “just in and out” of domestic violence and child abuse cases and they were not the group to solve the problem. But weren’t these crimes to be properly investigated? Didn’t law enforcement think to look for evidence, for example, computer evidence of child pornography? According to new research, “child pornography offending is a stronger diagnostic indicator of pedophilia than is sexually offending against child victims.”   

I later found out that an astonishing 40% of police acknowledged they were domestic violence abusers themselves, according to studies. 

angry police officer pointing at camera

No wonder the police were just in and out. No wonder they didn’t enthusiastically collect evidence or charge abusers with multiple crimes that would result in prosecution. No wonder they ignored beaten women and children. Many were doing it themselves. I wondered if some were committing child sex crimes in addition to battering their partners.  

The apathy by law enforcement in domestic violence cases was starting to make sense.

By December 2015, convicted pedophile Nicholas Elizondo was allowed to keep custody of his little daughter despite the pro bono attorney.  California Commissioner James Compton showed that California was on par with Oklahoma, which had originally given Nicholas custody. The court reporter we got for the case had cost $600 for the hearing, but the company told us the transcript would cost $6,000. The mother could not appeal. 

An obvious question is what chance do children have whose incestuous fathers are not prosecuted?  Henry Parsons had gotten custody of his little girl and basically used her as bait, as a lure to bring her friends into his orbit. He was caught after he molested her friends. 

Having accused child sex abusers get custody posed a significant state-created danger not only for their children, but also for their friends and their schools.  It was even more horrifying that registered sex offenders getting and keeping custody of children. What if Nicholas Elizondo decided to volunteer at his daughter’s elementary school? Would the principal sit beside him all day? Or would the principal not care? What if the child wanted to have her friends overnight? Would the friends’ parents think to check Megan’s List?

It reminded me of the story of the Lords of Bakersfield, a scandal from the 1970s and 1980s, possibly as far back as the 1950s, that was blown open in January 2003 by a Bakersfield Californian article. Bakersfield is the county seat and largest city in Kern County, in the Central Valley of California.

The story was of a powerful homosexual ring comprised of prominent people, pillars of the community who lived double lives, preying on young men and boys and protecting each other through power and influence. A good-old-pedophile-boys network. A series of murders and cover-ups finally caught the attention of the press. That was where registered sex offender Nicholas Elizondo moved with his little girl. It seemed like a trafficking ring to me.

We took this sickening outcome of the Knight v Elizondo case to the Judicial Council as a case of reckless disregard of child safety and brought up the judges being trained to be highly skeptical of abuse allegations in family court.

Not a blink. No one even changed expressions.

Student court watchers for CA Protective Parents Association’s Sacramento Family Court Watch Program which had begun in 2012 had observed a total of 1,126 cases in three years.  The cases were randomly selected, depending on the students’ schedules.

We decided we had enough cases for a report but were stuck. The data had been entered into an Excel spreadsheet and everyone we talked to said that wouldn’t work to crunch data.

Attorney Maria Palazzolo, a computer specialist in her former life, just smiled when she heard our dilemma. She promptly began to analyze the data and with her help, we finished the project.  The Report on Sacramento Family Court Process (January 2016) shone a spotlight into the dark family court.

  • 14% of all family court cases involved domestic violence.
  • Three-quarters of restraining orders requests were granted.
  • However, in over a quarter of cases, the person with a restraining order was ordered into personal contact with the restrained person.
  • Half of those orders for personal contact were for custody exchanges.
  • Children were not covered by the restraining orders.
  • Over 80% of protected parties had to leave the courtroom at the same time as their abuser, despite danger of further violence.
  • 7% of cases involved child abuse allegations.
  • The court protected only 19% of those children from their identified abusers.
  • Two-thirds of the objections to custody evaluators’ reports were overruled.
  • In one quarter of the cases, one party had an attorney while the other did not.
  • In three-quarters of the cases, there was no court reporter, which precluded appeals.
  • Over 40% of cases dragged on for more than three years.

We were amused when the Sacramento Presiding Judge Kevin Culhane politely refused to meet with us, dismissing us with the comment that he couldn’t discuss individual cases. We assured him this was aggregate data, but to no avail.  His response convinced us that court watchers indeed scared judges, just like retired judge Deann Salcido had said. He did ask for a hard copy which we sent, along with copies to the Legislature and the Chief Justice.

This was concrete evidence that adult and child victims of domestic violence were not being well protected in Sacramento family court. Neither the courts nor Judicial Council seemed to care much. We never knew if our data and recommendations made any difference, but it seemed like the number of calls from frantic protective mothers in Sacramento began to reduce. 

We had hoped to kick off a statewide court watch program, but did not get traction at that time. Bandwidth and funding were always the issues. Our angel donor had retired and we had neglected to engage a professional fundraiser right at the beginning. We had wrongly assumed the situation would right itself quickly after we alerted policy makers and educated the general public. Our plan had been to go out of business once the problem was fixed. How short-sighted we had been not to realize this was a deep-seated, money-driven situation, and was, at its root, quite evil.

Family courts were working like well-oiled machines.

We thought about applying for the VAWA grants that included court watch programs in Section 1301.  However, government grants have strings, and we were told we would need to work within the court system. Fat chance. We couldn’t even get the Sacramento Presiding Judge to meet with us about our data.

Karen had done a splendid job creating a prototype court watch and research program that gave us strong data.  Court watch had a genuine potential to help.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.