Family Court. It sounds so warm and friendly. Sort of like a family vacation or a Norman Rockwell family Thanksgiving dinner with a big turkey served in a cozy dining room. But it is not as friendly as it sounds. In fact, when there are concerns about family violence or substance abuse during a divorce, family courts are not at all friendly. Custody disputes are particularly problematic.
A kind of reverse King Solomon experience is often the case. The Biblical king was asked to decide which of two women was the real mother of a baby. He suggested cutting the child in half so both could have a part.
The woman who begged the king not to kill the baby and to give him to the other woman to spare his life was wisely judged to be the real mother. In our current family courts, judges are asked to decide who is the best parent to have custody of the child and are faced with a similar dilemma.
The family court was designed, in theory, to be a more compassionate solution than other courts when a family breaks up, offering mediation to try to reduce tension and conflict. This works in families that have problems that can be mediated, such as financial disagreements or concerns about where a child is to go to school.
Sadly, it ignores the reality that many divorces are due to family violence or substance abuse, neither of which can be resolved by a session or two with a mediator.
A further problem emerges when the case returns to court with no mediated agreement. The judge is then in the King Solomon position, with angry allegations on either side. Most of the time, neither person has an attorney. They are unfamiliar with the court rules and processes and do not present their cases well. Sometimes one person has an attorney and the other does not, which makes a very unlevel playing field.
A domestic violence victim may be terrified to be in the presence of the abuser. Appeals are not a viable avenue due to high cost, thus, there is no oversight. This translates to a situation in which the judge may relax his or her judicial training and just cut the baby in half. A sacrificial lamb.
It happens all the time, as you will see, especially when child sexual abuse is presented to the court. We will now take a deeper dive into this fulminating problem, in a search for answers and solutions.