“When spider webs unite, they can tie a lion”
Ethiopian proverb
For about a decade, we’d been actively involved in trying to make a dent in the pattern and practice of family courts ignoring abuse allegations, especially child sex abuse, and placing children at risk. We kept educating, hoping that was a key to keeping children safe.
Our Seventh Annual Child Sexual Abuse Awareness Conference was held on April 7, 2001, titled Are Children’s Reports of Sexual Abuse Minimized or Ignored? If So, Why? Judith Reisman Ph.D. author of Kinsey: Crimes and Consequences, and Bob Geffner Ph.D. spoke. The answer to the first rhetorical question was: Yes. The answer to the second question was: Probably massively effective lobbying by pedophile-friendly fathers’ rights groups. In 2001, professor and film maker Garland Waller released Small Justice: Little Justice in America’s Courts. It described the dire situation for mothers and children in our country in stark detail, which was both depressing and very validating. She gave permission for the film to be shown here.

That year, UC Davis law professor Carol Bruch wrote Parental Alienation Syndrome and Parental Alienation: Getting It Wrong in Child Custody Cases in which she neatly dissects Richard Gardner’s arguments.

“First, Gardner confounds a child’s developmentally related reaction to divorce and high parental conflict (including violence) with psychosis. In doing so, he fails to recognize parents’ and children’s angry, often inappropriate, and totally predictable behavior following separation. This error leads him to claim that PAS constitutes a frequent example of folie a` deux or folie a` trois, Shared Psychotic Disorders that the American Psychiatric Association and scholarly studies report occur only rarely.”
“First, Gardner confounds a child’s developmentally related reaction to divorce and high parental conflict (including violence) with psychosis.”
“Gardner vastly overstates the frequency of cases in which children and custodial parents manufacture false allegations or collude to destroy the parent-child relationship; PAS shifts attention away from the perhaps dangerous behavior of the parent seeking custody to that of the custodial parent. This person, who may be attempting to protect the child, is instead presumed to be lying and poisoning the child. Indeed, he warns judges not to take abuse allegations seriously in the divorce court setting in high conflict cases (severe PAS cases.)”
“Gardner believes that, particularly in serious cases, the relationship of an alienated child with the rejected parent will be irreparably damaged, probably ending for all time, unless immediate, drastic measures (custody transfer, isolation from the loved parent, and deprogram Gardner’s proposed remedy for extreme cases is unsupported and endangers children.”
“In his admitted decision to err on the side of under-identifying abusers, Gardner appears to have overlooked the policy differences between criminal law and child custody law and also to have misunderstood the distinction between the burdens of proof in criminal and civil cases in the United States.”
“To the extent that PAS results in placing children with a parent who is, in fact, abusive, the youngsters will be bereft of contact with the parent who might help them. Parent groups and investigative reporting describe, for example, numerous cases in which trial courts have transferred children’s custody to known or likely abusers and custodial parents have been denied contact with the children they have been trying to protect.”
We spoke at conferences, including in other states and even in Iceland. We talked to Amnesty International. They didn’t help. We presented at the FVSAI conference in September 2001 where we displayed the quilts made during our conferences and had an Incest Survivors Speakers Bureau booth. I made a quilted wall hanging for the auction.

In 2001, Orange County CA Judge Ronald Kline was arrested and ultimately sentenced to 27 months in prison for child pornography. We wondered about other judges.
On May 27-28, 2001, attorney Meera Fox hosted a meeting with attorney Richard Ducote, protective mother Wendy Titleman, attorney Seth Goldstein and his then wife Kay, attorney Joan Pennington and Robin Yeamans, author Elize St. Charles and me, to formulate a plan to improve the dire situation.
The primary ideas were:
- Develop a class action suit for California protective parents who were denied due
- process and lost their children for injunctive relief.
- Develop a class action suit against Richard Gardner for cases using his testimony or
- consultation. (Gardner killed himself two years later.)
- Develop a monograph about Gardner and the junk science of PAS.
- Create a website for protective parents to find what they need.
- Have a media strike force and press packet and go in force wherever there is a bad case.
- Develop a standardized form to implement Family Code section 3118.
- Develop online training with a stiff exam for custody professionals.
- Ensure mediators and evaluators do not make custody recommendations.
- Have ongoing court watch programs.
- Educate professionals and attorneys about child sex abuse.
Then on September 11, the planes hit the World Towers. Glued to the overhead televisions, we were mesmerized, watching what looked like the beginning of the end of the world.
The nation’s collective terror as the explosions ricocheted off our ears, reflecting in a macro-cosmic way the lonely terror of each attendee who had ever been stalked or beaten. We watched, over and over, a building imploding, collapsing slowly. The government’s explanations made no sense. We were doubly traumatized.

The conference continued. It was, after all, a conference on trauma.
That year, 2001, Boston University assistant professor Garland Wallar made the tragic documentary Small Justice, Little Justice in Family Court and the Illinois Coalition for Family Court Reform began, galvanized by Annette Zender. Mothers found each other one by one in Illinois and collected one paragraph Victim Impact Statements with the jurisdiction, cost of litigation, names of the judge, attorney, evaluator, GAL, and outcome of the cases. They got press, organized peaceful protests, and contacted their legislators.
It was exhausting just thinking about the work ahead. We met again to expand on our ideas, which now included:
- Stay united and build community
- Improve public relations and fundraise
- Organize around domestic violence to change the culture
- Build bridges with judicial organizations and strengthen child protective service to protect
- Provide more uniform education and training for all system professionals
- Develop unified family court one-stop shops/family justice centers
- Use a multidisciplinary investigation approach with a standard form
- Encourage domestic violence courts with specially trained judges/domestic violence advocates
- Use danger assessments and better define domestic violence
- Develop affordable legal representation for protective parents and good attorneys for minors
- Lower the standard of proof for child protection to control violent men’s access to children
- Remove junk science and have a written statement against PAS that can be used repeatedly
- Remove friendly parent laws and the incest exception
- Hold judges who do not follow the law accountable
- Fund VAWA and work on national legislation and recriminalize child abuse and domestic violence
Attorney Meera Fox formed Child Abuse Solutions, Inc. to train child custody evaluators, using a multidisciplinary format with experts in various fields.

On October 5, 2001, Child Abuse Solutions, Inc., the Legislative Coalition, and California Protective Parents Association met again with the Judicial Council, Administrative Office of the Courts, Center for Families, Children and Courts and the Office of Governmental Affairs to discuss family courts placing children at risk. We were reaching into the top echelons. We requested a policy statement and a Crimes Against Children Review Panel.
They were pleasant, non-committal.
California mothers had been contacting California National Organization for Women (CA NOW) since the 1990s about being victimized by judges, lawyers, mediators, evaluators and attorneys for children in the Family Court system.
Karen and I approached Helen Grieco just as she was being installed as the new director of the CA NOW. She said she would help as soon as she figured out her brand-new job. As a child, she had had more than a brush with the problem. She remembered saying, “Daddy, stop hitting mommy.” We were awed by her strength, knowledge and positive attitude. It appeared to be a gender-biased issue and peaked Helen’s interest.

She quickly analyzed the problem and its solution.
“We’ll just alert all three branches of government about the issue. They’ll fix it.”
She was confident. She began the Family Law Task Force, with representatives from the Attorney General’s office and Los Angeles Assemblywoman Sheila Kuehl’s senior consultant Syrus Devers. Karen and I offered the idea of a statewide Crimes Against Children Grand Jury to investigate.
By 2002, Helen and her CA NOW colleagues had conducted an excellent study of 212 mothers, titled Family Court Report. It found fathers committed domestic violence in 86% of the cases and child abuse in 76% of the cases. Despite evidence of abuse, the fathers had unsupervised or full contact with the children in 69% of cases.
They presented the report to all three branches of the California government.
Nothing.