“Until lions start writing down their own stories, tales of the hunt shall always glorify the hunter.”
African Proverb
Greedy professionals took note, expanding their territory over the next decades. The CA NOW report put it well, “The giant family law perpetual cash machine that now comprises “family court” consists of a county’s Family Court Services division, marriage and family counselors who function as “mediators,” “special masters” and counselors, attorneys employed as guardians ad litem and special masters and psychologists and psychiatrists often recommended by mediators. Including judges, all know each other.
They refer clients to each other, market to each other, and are all necessary to make joint custody “work.”
- Also in 1988, the Conference of Chief Justices urged every Chief Justice to establish a task to study gender bias in the courts. Forty-one task force reports were submitted.
- The New York Task Force on Women in the Courts found “…that gender bias against women litigants, attorneys and court employees is a pervasive problem with grave consequences. Women are often denied equal justice, equal treatment and equal opportunity.“
- The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court (SJC) completed their gender bias study in 1989, reporting that fathers won primary joint custody more than 70% of the time when custody was disputed, regardless of abuse.
In 1989, then New York State Assemblyman Jerrold Nadler held hearings on the family court crisis in his state at the request of protective mother Amy Neustein.
That very year, the Supreme Court dealt a blow to children in DeShaney v. Winnebago County. It ruled that a state government agency’s failure to prevent child abuse by a parent did not violate the child’s right to liberty.
Parental property interest rights trumped children’s safety. The referenced 14th Amendment states in part: “…. nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty or property without due process of law….”

Protective parent Michele Etlin later made the point that children should at least have a life interest, even if they were denied a liberty interest.
The only caveat in DeShaney was that state-created danger could be considered a violation. The state certainly was creating danger for children they placed with violent and sex offending parents. But it was hard for lay people who were not sophisticated attorneys to figure out how to use this small legal window.
The child sexual abuse survivor movement was also growing, led by survivors. Healing Hearts, a new survivor group for women molested as children with a newsletter edited by Margot Silk Forrest who was affiliated with Bay Area Women Against Rape.
They saw the need for a specialized ritual abuse survivors’ group, which Caren StarDancer and Catherine Ragazzi SurvivorShip began in 1989, with a hard copy newsletter and ongoing conferences in Oakland. They compiled evidence of ritual abuse and mind control which helped validate these sadistic types of child abuse beyond most people’s ability to imagine, which often happened at the same time for many survivors.
San Diego City Attorney Casey Gwinn began to roll out an enlightened concept to help intimate partner survivors. He had prosecuted 10,000 domestic violence cases, using evidence-based prosecution, even without victim participation. He noted that victims had a difficult time navigating the various agencies which were located all over town. In 1989, his idea to co-locate agencies was rejected. His persistence rivaled ours and by 2002, the multi-agency San Diego Family Justice Center serving victims of domestic violence and their children became a reality. The “one stop shop” idea spread. It helped domestic violence victims greatly to have everything accessible in one place.
Authors such as John Bradshaw began writing about methods to heal the wounds from childhood, with books like Homecoming and videos.
In 1990, children in the rest of the world received a welcome gift. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) became effective in 1990, reflecting the “growing international consensus that children be viewed as a subject of rights and not merely as an object of rights or of protective action…. No other international treaty on human rights provoked such a consensus on the part of governments.”

The United States had contributed to the drafting and signed on to the Convention, but, shockingly, is the only country still not to have ratified it. Religious groups doggedly opposed the convention for limiting parental rights to “discipline” (hit) their children.

The term “therapeutic jurisprudence” was coined in 1990. The original meaning was to treat criminal defendants and offenders with fairness, dignity and respect, which would “positively influence an individual’s mental, emotional, and spiritual wellness.” Allowing offenders to participate in their own rehabilitative plan should lead to better outcomes, proponents reasoned.
As time went on, this applied to specialized drug, mental health and domestic violence courts. The focus was on rehabilitation, but the principle did not advocate for pretending a crime wasn’t committed or coddling offenders. Rather, it proposed using the legal system as a change agent. This was a positive, humane perspective.
However, in family court, this principle became a nightmare reality. Family court soon became a haven for mental health professionals who treated, pathologized, ignored and dismissed crimes.
Mothers could no longer give up assets to keep their children as they were surrounded by professionals who pretended to know what was best for children. That included ignoring abuse.
Worried men continued to assert that family courts were filled with women and children who made false child sex abuse allegations. The Association of Family and Conciliation Courts (AFCC) commissioned a massive study of 9,000 custody disputes in 12 family courts across the country, which was published in 1990.
The AFCC, never partial to battered mothers and abused children, discovered to their chagrin that fewer than 2% of divorce and custody cases involved child sex abuse charges.
…fewer than 2% of divorce and custody cases involved child sex abuse charges.
California created Conciliation Proceedings to cement conciliation and mediation into law, essentially moving crimes into civil court, and began collecting modest data on divorce and separation.
On the national level, the Domestic Violence Coalition on Public Policy, later renamed the National Network to End Domestic Violence (NNEDV), was formed in 1990 to promote federal legislation to impact domestic violence. That year, House Concurrent Resolution 172 passed.
Sponsored by Congresswoman Connie Morella, it resolved that it was “the sense of the Congress that, for purposes of determining child custody, credible evidence of physical abuse of a spouse should create a statutory presumption that it is detrimental to the child to be placed in the custody of the abusive spouse.”
…It was “the sense of the Congress that, for purposes of determining child custody, credible evidence of physical abuse of a spouse should create a statutory presumption that it is detrimental to the child to be placed in the custody of the abusive spouse.”
The Resolution somehow wended its way through a Congress that did not reflect the general population, of which half is female. There were a mere 31 women in Congress that year, out of 435 total members. I could barely imagine the opposition those women must have faced, lobbying for a Resolution that confronted the unadulterated misogyny and male entitlement the family court crisis represented. I wondered how many of those Congressmen were batterers themselves.
Since H. Con. Res. 172 focused on spousal violence and custody, without pinpointing sexual abuse, visitation or unmarried parents, there were no specific federal admonitions on giving custody to parents who preyed only on their children, or to unmarried partners, or to visits to batterers. Common sense bowed to legal hair-splitting.
That year, California passed AB 2700 (Roybal-Allard) to require judges to consider any history of spousal abuse before determining child custody and visitation rights. They needed to consider it, but there was no requirement to protect the children.
The federal Victims of Child Abuse Act was also passed in 1990. It authorized grants for multi-disciplinary investigation and prosecution programs, Court Appointed Special Advocate Programs, judicial training including for domestic relations courts, and victims’ rights programs.
The National Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges (NCJFCJ) called for recognition of spouse abuse as child abuse when children are present in the home. This good idea began to be interpreted by social workers as “failure to protect” if a victim did not leave the abuser and would remove the children. But if the victim did leave, the family court would likely give the children to the abuser. That led to the impossible Catch 22 when family court and child welfare services crossed wires. There was no simple answer.