Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 18: Evaluators

“I’ve heard it said that shrinks aren’t simply screwed up, they’re shrinks because they’re screwed up. Where did I hear that? Why, from shrinks themselves.”

Dr. Shawn T. Smith

Ironically, we were finding that some doctorate-level psychologists were among the most dangerous professionals in the family court system. They were appointed as child custody evaluators in cases where the parents had resources.  Their huge fees were not paid by the court, but directly by the parents, so the parent with the most money could basically buy the outcome from unethical professionals. Unfortunately, a battered mother fleeing abuse did not normally have resources. After interviewing and testing family members, and pathologizing trauma symptoms, psychologists frequently recommended children be placed at risk.

Custody evaluations became yet another trap for abused mothers and children. Evaluators seemed to have taken a page from Freud’s playbook on incest.  They seemed to know all about the label “parental alienation syndrome” that was used to blame the mother for reporting her and her child’s abuse and firmly ignored or minimized domestic violence, despite the danger it posed. 

Every court door seemed to have a savage tiger behind it. If a child reported abuse, the mother would be branded an alienator. If the mother fled domestic violence alone, she abandoned the children. If a child made too many disclosures, the mother would be removed entirely from the child’s life, particularly if those allegations were about child sex abuse.

tiger standing in wooden structure

In case there are doubts about the fathers’ rights agenda, the Fathers’ Manifesto, written in 1995, states in part: “We signatories to the Fathers’ Manifesto, responding to natural and Biblical laws, in defense of our nation and our families, hereby declare and assert our patriarchal role in society. America is an experiment in freedom, and the feminist experiment in freedom, under the guise of “equality,” unleashed a panoply of social ills which have become a cancer on our land, led to the moral and economic destruction of our nation, made America a house divided unto itself, created a vast underclass with a bleak and bankrupt future, and is the greatest national disaster we have ever faced.”

…the Fathers’ Manifesto, written in 1995, states in part: “We signatories to the Fathers’ Manifesto, responding to natural and Biblical laws, in defense of our nation and our families, hereby declare and assert our patriarchal role in society.”

They went on. “Recognizing patriarchy to be the greatest creator of wealth, prosperity, and stability civilization has ever known, we hereby demand that our children, homes, lives, liberty, and property be unconditionally restored to us. We hereby demand replacement of the doctrine of Parens Patria with the Biblical doctrines upon which this nation was founded. We hereby recognize and reaffirm that patriarchy is the order established under God and under His Natural Law.” (CA NOW Family Court Report 2002).

“Parens Patria” means the public policy power of the state to intervene against an abusive or negligent parent, legal guardian, or informal caretaker, and to act as the parent of any child, individual or animal who is in need of protection.” 

By undermining the strides made by women over the past century, including repealing the right to vote, men would perpetuate patriarchy and return women to the status of property, barefoot and pregnant in the kitchen. These groups were extremely influential in shaping forced shared custody statutes and lobbied for fathers to get full and total custody in all cases.

Some women fought back physically after years of being battered. They were suffering from a specific form of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) which became known as “battered woman’s syndrome.” The condition was acknowledged in legislation. By 1995, 12 states had enacted statutes providing for the admissibility of expert testimony on battering and its effects, leading to the possibility that their homicide sentences could be commuted on the basis of “battered woman’s syndrome.” 

Information was getting into the public domain, as the internet became commercialized and more books were written.

  • Florida attorney Elizabeth Kates began documenting the fathers’ rights movement on her website The Liz Library.
  • The Hostage Child: Sex Abuse Allegations in Custody Disputes by Leora Rosen, Ph.D. and Michele Etlin was published in 1996. It shocked the conscience of the conscious.
  • An articleAllegations of Sexual Abuse in Divorce by Kathleen Faller, Ph.D. and Ellen DeVoe was published. The data showed that protective parents who had medical evidence or reported more severe/frequent child sexual abuse that had been committed against their children, received sanctions more often, including switching custody to the accused, placing the child in foster care, reduction of visits, prohibition against seeking medical care for the child or reporting further abuse, and jailing. It too shocked the conscious. 

Realizing there was a problem, good judges began trying to educate their peers on the dangers of child abuse and domestic violence. The National Judicial Education Program (NJEP) published a model judicial education curriculum Adjudicating Allegations of Child Sexual Abuse When Custody is in Dispute in 1996, piloted in Alabama and Colorado.

That year, the Virginia-based American Judges Association released Domestic Violence and the Courtroom: Understanding the Problem… Knowing the Victim. The report noted that “One of the most common reasons given for resuming an abusive relationship is the fear that the abuser will act on the threats of taking the children from the victim. Studies show batterers have been able to convince authorities that the victim is unfit or undeserving of sole custody in approximately 70% of challenged cases.”  

“One of the most common reasons given for resuming an abusive relationship is the fear that the abuser will act on the threats of taking the children from the victim.

Studies show batterers have been able to convince authorities that the victim is unfit or undeserving of sole custody in approximately 70% of challenged cases.”  

The government continued to change policies, which had tremendous impacts on custody cases. The Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996 (PRWORA) implemented major changes to social welfare policy. It replaced the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services’ Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC), which had begun in 1935, with the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF).

TANF encouraged work instead of welfare. It required fathers to pay child support. It discouraged poor mothers from having more children by mandating a five-year lifetime award for benefits. It was designed to provide assistance to needy families; end dependence on government benefits by promoting job preparation, work, and marriage; prevent and reduce the incidence of out-of-wedlock pregnancies; and encourage two-parent families. The legislation seemed designed to return society to an earlier more traditional social paradigm.

The federal legislation contained a particular poison pill for mothers and children, called Healthy Marriage and Responsible Fatherhood (HMRF). Grants were designed to bring fathers back into families and train them for work, so the state (i.e., taxpayers) didn’t have to support their children.  Again, it sounded benign, but these laws had negative unintended consequences for children of divorce.

The Office of Child Support Enforcement (OCSE) funded Responsible Fatherhood Demonstration Projects in 8 states to improve the employment and earnings of under and unemployed noncustodial fathers, and motivate them to become involved in the lives of their children. HMRF gave annual awards of $150 million, and Access and Visitation gave grants of $10 million per year to states to support noncustodial parents, usually fathers.

Healthy Marriage and Responsible Fatherhood programs even reached long arms into prisons to re-connect felons with their families, perhaps in hopes that encouraging a relationship with their children would prevent recidivism.  Children should not be expected to rehabilitate felonious fathers, who may have been imprisoned for battery of their mothers, drug abuse or other behaviors that would not make good role models for children.  It was either grossly ill-conceived or a deliberately malicious policy, social engineering at its zenith.

woman and two children visiting father in jail

Fathers were elevated, even receiving their very own federally funded website www.fatherhood.gov.  There was no motherhood.gov. Mothers who applied for these federally funded services were turned away from the federal fatherhood program.

Abusive men quickly figured out, or were told, that if the mothers of their children didn’t want them back into the nest, and if they got custody of the children, the mothers would have to pay child support to them. As it was hard to get a job as a felon, this was a dream come true.  It turned the tables. It provided a strong financial incentive to get custody. 

For abused mothers and children, TANF was yet a further trap. They were blindsided. 

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.