Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 25: Policy Making

“In a state where corruption abounds, laws must be very numerous.”

Tacitus

Our Weekly Bulletins and t-shirts were quite effective as an educational tool.

But despite the reams of paper and gallons of ink and days of talking on the topic of the dire consequences of child abuse, and helpful allies, individual judges and commissioners kept on making astoundingly counterintuitive individual decisions, placing children in harm’s way while breaking their critical attachment to their safe mothers. This conflagration was fueled by a growing army of private court-appointed mental health professionals and attorneys who were paid directly by the parents.

The bottom line is that people simply should not hit or hurt other people. We all learned that in kindergarten. The bully was in the wrong and would be sent to the principal’s office. It must have been massively confusing for school children who were being ordered by courts, still punch-drunk from a prior beating by their father, to go another round while being taught in class that hitting was not ok. It was absurdly unfair on the face of it.

kid being bullied at school

The question was how to stop it. Nice, well-meaning therapists being supportive in couples counseling were ineffective and even dangerously complicit if they allowed criminal violence to go unaddressed. On the other hand, jail plus batterer accountability intervention, despite its lack of success with certain chronically violent sadistic bullies, brought an entirely different type of therapeutic method into play, far better suited for that population.

In October 1999, the same month CPPA became a non-profit, California Assemblywoman Sheila Kuehl brought AB 840 to fruition. Family Code section 3044 created a rebuttable presumption against giving custody of children to batterers, as recommended by H. Con. Res. 172.  Her counsel Syrus Devers knew a lot about the subject, which helped greatly. The new law helped, especially when protective mothers had ethical attorneys.

Family Code section 3044 created a rebuttable presumption against giving custody of children to batterers, as recommended by H. Con. Res. 172.  

Melissa Knight Fine from Legislative Coalition to Prevent Child Abuse found that judges relied heavily on recommendations from custody evaluators who had no standards or controls over performance, fees and recommendations. 

Her recommendations were to focus on training and education to document the issue, and to initiate legislation creating standards for evaluators and training on child sexual abuse particularly.  She estimated there were about 2,000 serious allegations of child sexual abuse per year in California. She spoke with the California Judicial Council, the administrative and policy-making body of the courts, which undertook a more in-depth analysis of the problem. 

She worked with Senator Deborah Ortiz, skillfully shepherding SB 792 through the process. It created Family Code section 3027.5 which provided that visitation rights cannot be limited because the parent reported suspected abuse or sought treatment Sadly, the author was forced to accept a hostile amendments a poison pill, and the code was quickly misused or circumvented by court professionals.

Senator Ross Johnson authored SB 433 which added Family Code section 3110.5 requiring court-connected and private child custody evaluators to have specified credentials and complete a domestic violence training program. Rules of Court 5.225 was adopted in 2002.   This was good news, although the devil was in the details. There was no standardization for the training. We learned that laws needed clarity and specificity.

court house building

On November 7, 1999, we held a free public education seminar at the Davis library, and presented the 1999 Friend of the Child Award to Washington Times Insight Magazine reporter Kelly O’Meara for her two articles Pedophilia in Court: Has Psychiatry Gone Psycho? on April 26, 1999 which featured Karen’s case along with Michele Hashimoto and Irene Jensen, and Is Justice for Sale in LA?  on May 3, 1999 based on evidence found by protective grandfather Marv Bryer, of a money trail in these cases. 

Two other excellent articles were published in this time frame in the now-defunct New Times LA by Susan Goldsmith. One was titled The Scarlet A about Irene Jensen’s case and the other A Little Girl’s Hell about Idelle Clark’s case.

“What next?”

We called New York investigator Karen Winner from The Justice Seekers. We had exactly enough money from our angel donor to pay for her to come to California for $10,000 and investigate the Sacramento County area court. She had previously investigated Santa Clara in 1997 which was also in Northern California.  We signed an agreement with her in January 2000.

We didn’t know she was also in the process of investigating the nearby Marin County family court. That was how we met our activists neighbors.  It seemed Northern CA was a hotbed of misery.

Little children were being injured, reinjured and sometimes killed. The trauma of being hurt would last a long time but could begin to be resolved through safety in a single order by a court. It seemed so clear to us. Get the kids to safety. Keep them safe. Then give them trauma therapy. The trauma of being betrayed by adults they turned to for help and left to suffer would last forever.  There must be a psychological disorder for people who recommend or order children to live or visit with violent adult abusers who out-weighed them by 150-200 pounds. Possibly “sadist” would fit.

In 1999, Jessica Lenahan Gonzales suffered a loss that would crush most people. Her three little girls Leslie (age 7), Katheryn (age 8) and Rebecca (age 10) were picked up by their father Simon Gonzales in violation of a court order. The police would not help locate him. Simon drove to the police station and opened fire. No one knows whose bullets killed the girls, his or the police. This case would surface again in 2011, thanks to Jessica’s strength and perseverance.

Jessica Lenahan Gonzales

That year we met with agencies and professionals, trying to learn the system better.

Yolo County Board of Supervisor member Lois Wolk committed her support. Yolo County developed a Child Sex Abuse Task Force.

We were in a small boat in choppy waters, on the crest of a tsunami. But we were finally right side up.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.