“Things get done only if the data we gather can inform and inspire those in a position to make difference.”
Mike Schmoker
We started throwing more spaghetti against the wall, hoping something would stick.
We bought an entire set of Cavalcade Production videos to use for education on trauma, dissociation, ritual abuse. We presented at the September FVSAI conference again. It was terrific to be with professionals who got it, who didn’t like it, and who wanted to help fix it. That year, 2005, the FVSAI name was formally changed to Institute on Violence, Abuse and Trauma (IVAT) after merging with Alliant International University. We did not see the change coming down the track from the merger.
Geraldine Stahly presented the results from now 157 completed surveys by protective mothers. The numbers were painful and still very close to the original outcomes with 67 participants.
- Over 80% of mothers were victims of domestic violence, had primary custody, brought allegations of domestic violence and/or child abuse by the other parent to family court and were ordered to have custody evaluations.
- The children showed symptoms of sleep disorders, overwhelming anger, depression, and over half had medical or physical evidence of injuries.
- Over 60% of mothers were labeled “alienators.”
- They were threatened with sanctions if they talked publicly, were generally not represented when their ex-partner had an attorney, and lost custody in an emergency order.
- 71% of the children continued to report abuse after the custody switch.
One of the most shocking numbers was the total price of the 157 national cases: $14 million spent on professionals, with nearly $7000 average cost for evaluations. No wonder we were getting pushback from the industry.
Renee Beeker from Michigan also presented her family court watch program outcomes. She described family courts as dangerous places. True.
She put forth data to prove the danger
- Batterers convinced authorities that the victim was unfit or undeserving of sole custody in approximately 70% of challenged cases (American Judge Association)
- Fathers who battered the mother are twice as likely to seek sole physical custody of their children than nonviolent fathers, and they are more likely to dispute custody if there are sons involved. (American Psychological Association Presidential Task Force on Violence and the Family, 1996, p. 40).
- Of 123 mediations with explicit current domestic violence allegations on the court screening form, the mediator failed to account for the violence in 56.9% of the reports. (Child Custody Mediation in Cases of Domestic Violence (in CA), Violence Against Women Vol 11, No. 8, pp 1032, August 2005)
- In a random sample of 1692 cases, the court never denied custody or visitation to a parent restrained by an order of protection (Outcomes of Custody and Visitation Petitions When Fathers Are Retrained by Protection Orders, Violence Against Women, Vol. 11, No. 8, p 1071, August 2005
- Familiar patterns of abuse simply shift ground to the legal arena where current child custody laws and procedures present opportunities for new tactics of domination and control. (National Council of Juvenile & Family Court Judges, Newsletter of the Resource Center on Domestic Violence, Child Protection and Custody, Vol 4. No 2, winter 1999-2000).
In a random sample of 1692 cases, the court never denied custody or visitation to a parent restrained by an order of protection.
Renee trained community members on family law roles and rules. The reports would go to the courts, legislators, county administrators. We listened to this idea.
On November 16, 2005, we held a briefing in room 112 of the Capitol for Legislators, their staff members, and the general public with presentations by Karen, Helen Grieco from CA NOW, and Janey Stevens from CA Partnership to End Domestic Violence. The PBS documentary Breaking the Silence: Children’s Stories was shown after the briefing.
We kept hoping someone would jump in and know what to do. No one jumped in. We were told we were the only organization in the whole country doing what we were doing. That was truly incredibly pathetic.
Our kind benefactor retired from his position, but the foundation gave us a final check anyway for $25,000. We were again stunned and overjoyed. We had closed our little office to conserve resources, paid Karen as an independent contractor for one day a week to develop a strategic plan for our next few years and started working with the Educational Consulting firm on another grant. The previous grant had been turned down because the font was wrong. Nobody wanted to fund an organization trying to take on judges. They had power. We didn’t.
The Third Annual Battered Mothers Custody Conference in Albany on January 6-8, 2006 was titled Battered Women, Abused Children, and Child Custody: A National Crisis III: Unity And Action! It was a wonderful gathering, and Mo Hannah was the perfect person to host.
The list of presenters over the years covered the country and the subject of custody and abuse: Dominique Lasseur, Lundy Bancroft, Richard Ducote, Robin Yeamans, Charlie and Diane Hofheimer, Barry Goldstein, Nancy Erickson, Amy Neustein, Michael Lesher, Joan Zorza, Garland Waller, Eileen King, Karen Winner, Geraldine Stahly, Monica Driggers, Toby Kleinman, Renee Beeker, Talia Carner, Courageous Kids, Wendy Titleman, Monica Betz, Annette Zender, Marcia Pappas and others.
It was wonderful being with people who totally understood.