“Through perseverance many people win success out of what seemed destined to be certain failure.”
Benjamin Disraeli
I was becoming a bit savvier about using the bureaucracy to help us, but it seemed an exercise in futility, as few wanted to go up against judges. Undeterred, Meera Fox and I began a Fact Sheet for Child Sexual Abuse in Custody Disputes with research showing how inhumane it is to place a child with their identified sexual abuser, since children rarely, if ever, lie about such abuse. I helped her on a case in which Ventura County Judge John Smiley placed twin boys with their father despite the father’s use of child pornography, and the children’s broken bones and repeated disclosures of sex abuse. There had been 14 reports to child welfare services.
In 2008 we asked the state agency California Commission on the Status of Women for help. Executive Director Mary Wisberg and policy director Beth McGovern responded with enthusiasm and put family law as one of their top priorities. They agreed to sponsor a review board and help with allowing children to speak directly to the court, along with support for multidisciplinary interview teams for child abuse. We were delighted.
We submitted testimony to the Commission at a public hearing in June and formally gave them some of our ideas. The Commission had more hearings. They adopted Legislative Proposals to:
- Establish an independent state-level oversight committee/commission to review child custody proceedings to better inform public policy, with a particular focus on cases with allegations of child abuse or domestic violence (priority).
- Establish a multidisciplinary team of professionals with expertise in assessing child abuse and domestic violence to evaluate cases when child custody is in dispute and such allegations are made against one of the parties.
- Strengthen the right of custodial parents to relocate without the risk of losing custody of children.
- Support a State General Fund appropriation to backfill lost federal matching incentive funds for administrative costs in child support programs.
- Require judges, mediators, custody evaluators, law enforcement officers and social workers to receive education on how to coordinate and interface with all appropriate agencies in child custody cases as a means of preventing system from failing to meet the needs of families.
- Allow children the opportunity to speak directly to the judge regarding their custody and visitation wishes and needs.
- Require judicial education regarding the dynamic of domestic violence and child abuse, including the invalidity of the “Parental Alienation Syndrome” (priority) and transgender individuals to prevent discrimination in child custody matters due to a parent’s transgender status.
- Support a request for a Joint Legislative Audit Committee to audit child custody cases involving allegations of child abuse or domestic violence.
- Establish a judicial performance evaluation system for appellate and trial court judges and commissioners using American Bar Association guidelines.
This was terrific news.
But four years later, in 2012, the Commission was defunded. The new Commission, which was back in action a year later, was not at all interested in family court issues. It felt like deja vu all over again, like another coup. Did our issue sink an entire state agency trying to protect children from abuse and daring to challenge the child endangerment system?
In August 2008, after incorporating the suggestions from the Board of Psychology into our template, I sent the updated form to Enforcement Coordinator Gina Bayless. In September and December 2008, I met with her and Executive Officer Robert Kahane Esq, about the template. Meera Fox and Bob Geffner were using it successfully for training, as it was designed to help California evaluators follow the many laws and rules for investigating child abuse.
The Board of Psychology seemed almost interested. They passed our template on to someone in their hierarchy who examined it for two years starting in 2008. In the end, they said the template was correct, but that the Board had no jurisdiction to require private court evaluators use it. They punted, saying only courts had oversight over court-appointed evaluators. We were referred back to the Judicial Council.

It was a perfect pivot by the opposition and took us right back to square one.
The game Chutes and Ladders, supposedly invented in the thirteenth century and revived in 1943, was popular in those days. I understood why. It mirrored real life well.
Bob Geffner Ph.D. and Jacquelyn White Ph.D. formed the National Partnership to End Interpersonal Violence Across the Lifespan (NPEIV). The first NPEIV Think Tank was held in September 2008, when it was decided to integrate across all aspects of interpersonal violence to link research, practice and advocacy. We presented at the annual FVSAI conference, and Kathleen Russell showed her film Family Court Crisis. She had also created a photo exhibit Family Court Crisis: Surviving a Broken System with pictures of many of our mothers and Courageous Kids that was very effective.
Over the years we met many supportive professionals, including Victor Veith, Viola Vaughan-Eden, Hastings Law professor Kelly Weisberg. It was heartening to have kind credentialed allies.
On October 28, 2008, coalition members Meera Fox from Child Abuse Solutions, Inc., Melissa Knight Fine from Legislative Coalition to Prevent Child Abuse, Kathleen Russell from Center for Judicial Excellence and I from CA Protective Parents Association met at the Capitol with Fredericka McGee, General Counsel to the California Assembly Speaker Karen Bass.

She had summoned Judicial Council representatives to her office and point-blank asked Office of Governmental Affairs Assistant Director Donna Hershkowitz and Public Affairs attorney Tracy Kenney to develop a form to implement Family Code section 3118 through administrative channels.
They smiled briefly, then without hesitation, flatly refused.
“Judges don’t want a form for evaluators to fill out. The Legislature would have to pass a law for a template.”
We stared. Seriously? The Judicial Council’s website had a form for every occasion. If they were so against a simple form to implement Family Code section 3118, it must be mighty important to have one. Frederika McGee was not used to the “treatment” and looked surprised. We were not. We decided to keep working on this political football.
Assembly Majority leader Alberto Torrico showed interest at first in legislation for a form, but it didn’t happen, at least not then.
Then we got distracted by the immediacy of the oxymoron “recommending mediation.” All California parents who could not agree on custody are sent to mediation, even those with domestic violence, substance abuse, child abuse, mental health and those infamous “high conflict” (very adversarial) cases.

Mediators in counties with “recommending mediators” made recommendations to the court on parenting plans after a brief session or two. This, of course, was not mediation at all. Mediators had been turned into mini-evaluators or de facto judges, since judges usually adopted their recommendations. Some even did full evaluations. I hoped they had better sense than the private evaluators.
Who were the litigants and who were the mediators?
Judicial Council data collection on CA mediation programs had begun in 1991, but gradually lost steam. After 1993, 1996, 1999 and 2003, it seems to have stopped by 2008. Their last report showed that an estimated 100,000 mediations were conducted that year, with increasing numbers of self-represented, culturally and linguistically diverse litigants with more complex cases.
The vast majority of mediators were white females with master’s degrees or higher (94%) who conducted domestic violence assessments only 45% of the time.
Were mediators subsequently hired who reflected the population they served? Did they assess parents for domestic violence 100% of the time? We could only hope. It was noted that severe budget cuts had occurred, which seems to have ended the data collection for the time being.
The bottom line was that we knew mediating with an abuser was dangerous for victims. We knew mediators should not be making life or death decisions. Real court investigators were needed to investigate these crimes so courts could protect the children. We wondered how to make our concerns known to the judiciary.
Then an opportunity arose.
The CA Supreme Court ruled in Elkins v Superior Court (2007) that a local rule of court conflicted with statutory law regarding witnesses testifying in person in family court. A local superior court rule in Contra Costa County “provided that in dissolution trials, parties must present their case by means of written declarations.” Jeffrey Elkins had been deprived of his ability to present live witnesses in his case.
The Supreme Court recommended forming a task force, and the California Elkins Family Law Task Force was promptly established by Chief Justice Ronald George. At that time, there were 460,000 new family law cases per year and 175 full time family court judges.
The Task Force began meeting in 2008 to improve procedures.