Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 24: A Glimmer

“It’s really a wonder that I haven’t dropped all my ideals, because they seem so absurd and impossible to carry out. Yet I keep them, because in spite of everything, I still believe that people are really good at heart.”

Anne Frank

“Do you feel anything different?”

“Maybe. Just a little bit.”

On January 20, 2009, Barack Obama became the first black president of the United States. His Vice President Joe Biden had sponsored the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) and knew Camille Cooper and Grier Weeks from PROTECT personally. Not only that, but Kathleen Russell also personally knew President Obama’s Deputy Chief of Staff.

We felt a tiny spark, a glimmer of hope.

We were heartened to learn that the U. S. Department of Justice’s Office of Violence Against Women (OVW) was beginning the first of four roundtable discussions to examine the intersection of domestic violence and custody. Meeting participants included subject-matter experts in the field, judges, attorneys, domestic violence advocates, researchers, child protection specialists and protective parents.

On February 7-8, 2009, the Family Court Reform Coalition (FCRC) met in Washington DC with chair Irene Weiser, Barry Goldstein, Joy Silberg, Joan Zorza, Camille Cooper, Dara Carlin, Renee Beeker, Eileen King, Alan Rosenbaum, Rita Smith, Marivic Mabanag, Kathleen Russell, Meera Fox and representatives from National Organization for Women and DV LEAP. 

FCRC had been created to “promote reform and accountability to ensure that victims of domestic violence and child abuse are protected from abuse in child custody determinations” by exposing gender bias and denial of due process in the courts educating, developing a reform agenda, and holding wrong- doers accountable.

I felt completely out of my league, so took copious notes as ideas were generated.

Violence Against Women Act (VAWA), Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act (CAPTA) and Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF) reauthorizations gave a perfect opportunity to put in a request for family court reform.

We needed to find legislators to work on the federal issues and have one main lobby group, followed by lots of emails from protective mothers each to their own Congress members.

I learned that House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer was helpful, as was the Judiciary Committee. The idea was to tie Federal grants to specific outcomes, using the carrot of funding for states to adopt reforms. The attorneys suggested that the stick of removing state funding if the carrot did not work out.

Some advocates thought that child welfare services investigations should be used for child abuse allegations in custody cases. Knowing about child welfare in California, we were skeptical of that solution, but again, I was listening intently.

Oversight was essential. Informational Congressional briefings were needed to educate federal lawmakers. Congressional Oversight Hearings, which are the official business of Congress, could be then held and a formal report issued. For example, Congress could direct the Government Accountability Office (GAO) to call for investigations into the shenanigans behind the scenes that we suspected but could not prove.

Our group priority was to bring in sunshine and penetrate the darkness of family courtrooms, creating a new culture that was accountable to the public. 

We agreed that the priority was ensuring that the family court’s primary purpose is to ensure the safety and liberty interests of family members first, and, if possible, preserve the integrity of the family.

  • If there is no abuse, then the regular custody determination could take place.
  • If abuse is claimed, multidisciplinary review team would assess abuse claims.
  • Child custody evaluators should not be involved.
  • There must be evidentiary hearings.
  • The full history of abuse must be admitted in criminal and family court proceedings.
  • If abuse is determined by the preponderance of the evidence, the accused would have only supervised visits.

Other ideas poured out.

  • Require Judicial Performance Evaluations and/or Judicial Accountability Boards of lay people to let voters know what judges were doing and give litigants input.
  • Require judges to prioritize safety and write findings of fact and conclusions of law.
  • Have term limits for judges.
  • Have judges run for Family Court specifically.
  • Have a mandatory review of cases at the highest court.
  • Expedite appeals and remove costs, provide transcript at state expense.
  • Collect data on outcomes.
  • Emphasize federal rights, due process and rights of children.
  • Require immunity to be qualified.
  • Modernize courts by using electronic docket, filings, videoconferencing, videotaping of all hearings and electronic record entries.
  • Have an administrative process with a “trigger” for automatic case review when red flags such as continuance, motions, ex parte occur
  • Develop a Congressional Resolution to prioritize children’s safety over either parent’s claim to access or visitation, and get a sponsor to introduce it in April, which is both Child Abuse Prevention Month and Sexual Assault Awareness Month.
  • Investigate evaluator practices and expose them as fraud, through the Federal Trade Commission, Government Oversight Committee, class action, or Attorney General.

The discussion of evaluators focused on abuses of “therapeutic jurisprudence,” an interdisciplinary method “to improve the well-being of people involved in the legal process.” Evaluators were committing fraud when child abuse is alleged by using non-validated testing to perpetuate and promote a public health epidemic of child abuse.

Evaluators were not improving the well-being of anyone but the perpetrators and themselves. The best solution was to get rid of evaluators completely. Instead, an investigation team would gather cumulative abuse history to determine whether there is sufficient reason to believe abuse occurred. If so, the court would err on the side of caution, with safety as the highest priority. Unsupervised custody and visitation would not be allowed, unless the court determined in writing that there was no risk of further abuse.

The best solution was to get rid of evaluators completely.

This was exactly what we were trying to do in California through Family Code section 3118, which had thus far not been fully implemented. Courts were appointing evaluators under the Evidence Code, section 730, so they didn’t have to follow the protocols and bring such pesky things as criminal records, CPS and law enforcement reports, Victim Witness funding for therapy for crimes to the courts’ attention. They could just keep doing psychological testing and pathologizing battered mothers with false labels of delusional, alienator, or gatekeeping, and recommending that children be placed with wealthy, incestuous, violent fathers. 

We needed to fix the statute but had not had time to do that. Legislation took a long time and was fraught with pitfalls. It was all working out quite nicely for the opposition.

If it was impossible to eliminate evaluators, the group recommendation was to:

  • Study costs of evaluations.
  • Have the court pay.
  • Prevent courts from recouping costs from litigants.
  • Remove quasi-judicial immunity.
  • Treat evaluators as regular experts, with clear expertise in the subject they are addressing.
  • Narrow the scope of evaluations.
  • Prohibit ongoing referrals, so that evaluators are on a rotating basis.
  • Limit the number of appointments.
  • Cap fees and time spent on cases.
  • Improve the rules of evidence.
  • Disallow opinions on ultimate issues such as custody.
  • Ensure each litigant receives a copy of the report and raw data.
  • Prohibit the use of gender biased scales and tests not designed for court use. 
  • Ensure evaluators follow laws.
  • Prohibit pseudo-science.
  • Use a standard template.
  • Make the complaint process transparent.
  • Turn guidelines into statutes.
  • Have a national certification process.
  • Request an investigation of evaluators by the Attorney General or the Federal Trade Commission for consumer fraud.

Other ideas were to:

  • Reduce the standard of evidence for abuse to “minimize risk” or “err on the side of caution.”
  • Longitudinally track children through all agencies and court with assigned numbers.
  • Have an ombudsman or an office in a federal or state agency that oversees these cases and has the authority to intervene.
  • Have a team of lawyers and experts to set cases up for appeal.
  • Commission a state level study.
  • Have jury trials.
  • Have domestic violence courts.
  • Have a default to the primary parent/ least detrimental parent.
  • Ensure children and their safety drive the outcomes.
  • Hold attorneys accountable.
  • Hold hearings with testimony and recommendations from bigger organizations.
  • Develop standardized judicial training.
  • Create a litigant bill of rights.

We were looking for a paradigm shift to presumptive custody with the child’s safe primary parent.  The odds were so stacked against mothers protecting their children that one advocate noted the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC) acted as basically a bounty hunter for fleeing mothers. That was a perfect description. I had collected hundreds of flyers, most of which had pictures of pretty women who were missing with their children. We could guess their story.

At the end of the day, the FCRC group consensus was to focus on judicial accountability.

  1. Legal defense impact litigation against evaluators, such as a RICO/class action by NOW Legal Defense and Education Fund (renamed Legal Momentum.)
  2. Tie federal funding to state oversight and Judicial Performance Evaluations, with:
    • Custody outcome data collection to establish a pattern.
    • Court watch.
    • Electronic recording.
    • Multidisciplinary teams with law enforcement leading investigations of abuse allegations (no evaluators).
    • Evidentiary hearings for abuse cases with only supervised visits if there is sufficient reason to believe abuse occurred.
    • A citizen review panel with authority to intervene.
  3. A Concurrent Federal Resolution calling for child safety as the highest priority.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.