Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 19: Never Give Up

“You must do the thing you think you cannot do.”

Eleanor Roosevelt

In July, 2012, the California Department of Mental Health became the new Department of State Hospitals thanks to AB 102 which moved mental health functions over to the Department of Health and Human Services. I hoped this was a good step for patients but feared they would be even more locked into the medical model with disease labels and medication, rather than the trauma model. They needed to be asked “What happened to you?” and their story heard, which leads to healing without medication. 

These were mental injuries, not mental health “disorders.” These were the children who grew up after being battered, raped and not rescued.  I shuddered to think of the state hospitals, which were already barbarically medieval institutions housing mostly disturbed sex offenders and could only hope this change and new management would bring the local mental health agencies into the trauma-informed 21st century world.

These were mental injuries, not mental health “disorders.” 

In her July 10, 2012 Huffington Post article Dispelling the myth of gender bias in the family court system, Cathy Meyer quoted research showing married mothers spend twice as many hours as father per week in primary child care activities, and the majority of child custody cases are not decided by the courts. Few fathers seek custody in divorce. 91% of cases are decided outside of family court. Mothers gain custody as fathers choose to give them custody.  

51%Both parents agreed that the mother would be the custodial parent
29%The decision was made without any third-party involvement
11%The decision for the mother to have custody was made during mediation
5%The issue was resolved after a custody evaluation
4%The case went to trial
1.5%Completed litigation

In September 2012, FOX 11 Los Angeles launched a superb series titled Children Lost in the Family Court System in their True Crime Stories.  On September 12, teenager Damon led off a Fox 11 teaser. He had gone into hiding rather than live with his sexual abuser father.  He was refused emancipation because he would not appear in court after his father filed paperwork to send him to a brainwashing camp and decided to get married instead. On October 1, attorney Robin Sax discussed the family court crisis in Part 1. Damon and Alanna Kraus’ stories were highlighted.

As a result of his systematic endangerment, Damon and his mother Cindy Dumas went on to found  Safe Kids international and the Women’s Coalition.

In Part 2, Presiding Juvenile Court Judge Nash from Los Angeles called it a crisis. Robin Sax clarified the difference between family and juvenile courts and agreed there was a crisis in both courts.

On October 3, 2012, Judge DeAnn Salcido spoke about the mis-training she had when she became a family court judge. Her comments about judicial training are as follows: 

Reporter Gina Silva: “Deann Salcido, former family court judge who is speaking out. A former family court judge who admits to a terrible mistake. We’ve been reporting on cases in which the court punishes them (mothers) for even reporting child sexual abuse.

Reporter Gina Silva

Judge Salcido (ret): ‘It’s a jungle; it’s a circus and there’s no ringmaster to speak of. It’s a million dollar industry in which the public, the average citizen’s interest is lost.”

“What I was trained on was to be suspicious of women who brought claims of abuse during a divorce matter. I was told that repeatedly in my first year as a judge both in training in Monterey County for the new judges’ school, so not just me but a whole classroom of new judges in family court. They said to be suspicious of the timing of abuse cases which were predominately…it was women. And their mentality was that you have to make sure they are not just trying to be bitter because the husband or the boyfriend has moved on to have a new girlfriend on the scene. Well, I have to admit that I can think of one case in my first year that I made a mistake on and that mistake continues to haunt me.”

 In Joyce Murphy’s family law case, Judge Salcido gave custody to the child’s father Henry Bud Parsons who years later was convicted of abusing two of his daughter’s friends.

“I was following that ‘be suspicious of the timing of abuse cases’ mantra that I was trained on. It hurts my heart right now talking about it. The thought of one child having to suffer another day, let alone 4 more years, and then another child was molested. But at the time I made that decision, I could not have been a judicial officer more than 6-9 months, and I had the benefit of less than 40 hours of family law training, none of which included how to investigate child sexual abuse claims.”

“But by the time I realized what I had done wrong on that case, I had already started to put the pieces of the puzzle together on my own. I had a friend tell me off the record, who worked at CPS, that if CPS were to make a claim that affected somebody’s custodial rights, they were worried about lawsuits. And CPS also has a policy where if the child is considered of school age they don’t want to unnecessarily remove them from the home and put them in foster care because that increases the budget, which means taxpayers pay more.”

“What I found was that this justice system is about dollars and not about justice. At judges’ meetings, I heard judges talk about, oh, she was having a bad day, it wasn’t a real domestic violence incident, she was probably on her period.’”

“What I found was that this justice system is about dollars and not about justice.”

In Part 3, Kathleen Russell from Center for Judicial Excellence recommended avoiding courts altogether if possible, and settling the case outside of court. She described the court-appointees who made money by keeping cases in the system. Robin Sax encouraged victims to contact Fox in Part 4.  On November 16, 2012, a child spoke to the interviewer, describing his fears, and was not protected.

Investigative reporters Martin Burns and Gina DeSilva continued their year–long hard-hitting expose of the family court crisis. Other episodes told of custody disputes that went badly when there were allegations of molestation, parents who were punished for reporting abuse, Tori’s story of a child who was found dead, placement in the custody of killers and an expose of Orange County CPS as a “system of lies.”

On January 20, 2013, Commissioner Judge Friedenthal was exposed. On March 4, 2013, a child was removed from her unnamed father twice after making reports to her teacher of being molested but was returned to her dangerous father. Her safe mother was stripped of custody. It appeared the minor’s counsel had a conflict of interest. 

On June 5, 2013, Fox highlighted the story of Andra Gallegos whose son Isaac had been killed after the Judge John Pacheco said she was overreacting and he would take the child and give him to the father.

Fox News found other murders linked to family court, including Jessica Hernandez whose 9 year old son was murdered on February 26, 2013 by his father with a hatchet in Sacramento years after the father was jailed for beating Jessica.  Alicia Mesiiti’s murder in Northern California was also highlighted. Kathleen described her child homicide study of media cases in which children were murdered in the context of divorce or separation.

The series ended abruptly in the summer of 2013. Reporter Martin Burns died in a hiking accident.

Reporter Martin Burns

Many wondered if it was really an accident, due to a pattern of whistleblowers dying after they exposed the horrors of child welfare services and family court trafficking of children. Documentary maker Bill Bowen died suddenly in 2010 while in the midst of a film titled Innocence Destroyed about the children killed in child welfare services care. Georgia Senators Nancy Schaefer died in 2010 and Robert Brown died in 2011 from questionable gunshot wounds after exposing scandals in child welfare.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.