“Hope has two beautiful daughters; their names are Anger and Courage. Anger at the way things are, and Courage to see that they do not remain as they are.”
Saint Augustine
Bryan Samuels, Commissioner of the US Health and Human Services’ Administration of Children and Families, and his assistant Debbie Powell spoke at the NPEIV Think Tank on September 12, 2012. She attended our Public Policy Action Group and said she would help us. Family court was selected as the top priority for the group. Attorney Wendy Murphy and I worked on language for a platform and forwarded it to co-chairs Joyce Thompson and Billie Weiss.
We felt another small glimmer of hope.
Kathleen Russell, attorney Kim Robinson and I presented to the Domestic Violence Task Force at the Judicial Council on October 2, 2012. Even though the Task Force had already held their annual meeting, this was arranged at the request of the Chief Justice after we talked directly with her. Staff members Bobbie Welling and Julia Weber were in the room, while 13 of the 15 members of the Task Force were on the phone. We discussed the public safety concerns and recommendation by the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights to develop laws and policies to better protect women and children from domestic violence.
We pointed out that of the 200,000 divorces per year in CA, 60% of the parents had children and only 15% of custody cases were disputed. Disputed cases were often due to domestic violence, child abuse and substance abuse, and less than 2% of cases were child sex abuse cases. We gave them the Stahy research data. We explained that 90% of accused molesters and 70% of accused batterers receive unsupervised visits or full custody, and that mental health professionals were not equipped to investigate these issues.
We recommended:
- Specialized integrated domestic violence courts that err on the side of child safety.
- Gather facts and evidence entered on a standard investigative report format.
- When one side has an attorney, both sides need to be represented.
- A record of hearing is crucial for all cases.
- Outcome data on how many children are placed with identified abusers.
Two criminal court judges were stunned and stayed on afterwards to talk to us. Ventura County Judge Toy White from Ventura County suggested having a group of retired Presiding Judges visit Presiding Judges of hotspot counties to discuss these problems. We were touched that she cared. I was skeptical of it working since the problem was corruption, but it would be oversight by their peers. That was never operationalized, to our knowledge.
Presiding Justice of the Court of Appeal Judge Lawrence Kay responded to my letter to the Chief Justice. It was nice to get a response. He thanked us for our input, also mentioning the Elkins Family Law Task Force, and the Family and Juvenile Law Advisory Committee. Later we learned from Judge Borack that specialized domestic violence courts were considered too expensive.
We sought substantive change, but our hopes were ultimately dashed. Chief Justice Tani Cantil-Sakauye toed the party line, and the party seemed filled with abusers.
We sent legislative ideas to Congressman Joe Baca who had held a Town Hall on children’s issues back in 2004, hoping he was still interested.
- Oversight. Initiate a “Second Look Commission” to review cases where children are placed at risk, require attorneys for battered women when the batterer has an attorney, require a record of hearing in all hearings, and launch an investigation into family court practices.
- Fatherhood Initiative. Replace the Fatherhood Initiative with a gender-neutral parenting skills program and substance abuse programs.
- Child Support. Develop a method of child support that is not based on parenting time to avoid perverse incentives for custody to gain, rather than pay, child support.
- Protocol. Develop a national standardized investigator report template as a multidisciplinary method of ensuring child safety, instead of private appointees.
Nothing,
We kept asserting that these were fundamental civil and human rights violations, a federal issue. When Jim Crow laws ruled in Southern states and they refused to integrate schools, integration became a federal issue. Likewise, when states refuse to protect children, the federal government needs to step in. Often the children paid the ultimate price. Many child murders by parents or parental figures during separation or divorce were preventable if only the court understood the dynamics of intimate partner violence, insisted on obtaining a complete history of abuse and seriously attended to the safe parent’s concerns.
Another tragic child homicide occurred in October 2012, after Hera McLeod pleaded with a Maryland family court judge to keep her little son Prince away from her abusive ex-boyfriend. She told the judge about the man’s fits of rage. He had held her at gunpoint and threatened to kill her. He was a suspect in other murders. Still, the court allowed him to visit Prince, first with supervision, then unsupervised. On the fourth unsupervised visit, Joaquin Rams murdered the toddler by drowning. In 2017 he was convicted of capital murder.

That month, the U.S. Department of Justice launched the U.S. Attorney General’s Task Force on Children Exposed to Violence as part of the Defending Childhood Initiative. The 256 page Report of the Attorney General’s National Task Force on Children Exposed to Violence was published on December 12, 2012.
Two out of three American children are exposed to violence. It was pointed out that back in 1979, U.S. Surgeon General Julius B. Richmond had declared violence a public health crisis of the highest priority. It still was.
Effective action was needed.
With the DOJ Task Force, Congress was now fully aware there was a bigger problem than Mothers of Lost Children wearing white t-shirts and telling accounts of terrible events. We were getting more focused, and our allies were more potent. Little did we know the backdooring was also powerful.
Did I really fly back to California, then go back to Washington DC a few weeks later? Yes. There were demonstration permits to get, research on Congress members to do, and lots of appointments to make. I needed the stability of my own home to organize it all. It was a gigantic three-dimensional puzzle, and was quite intense, but we pulled it off.
We launched a big educational effort between October 22 through 29, 2012.
On October 22, 2012, coalition members, including Eileen King, Helga Leust and myself, met with Kiersten Stewart, policy lead for Futures Without Violence (FUTURES). She was well versed about the family court crisis and thought a GAO audit would be good. She was way ahead of us, and said we needed victims’ rights attorneys.
FUTURES would help with a Resolution. Kiersten suggested meeting with Bea Hanson and Allison Randall from OVW and said that Catherine Pierce was the person in charge of child protection issues at the DOJ Department of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.
We had appointments on October 24 with staff from the offices of Senators Boxer, Hagan, and Roberts, along with Congress Members Fitzpatrick, Moore, and Conyers. We were ready with our federal “ask” which was for a Congressional Resolution and Congressional Oversight Hearings. Senator Feinstein’s staff members really wanted to help, but needed data first, such as CDC statistics. I didn’t understand why they didn’t say they would order it to be conducted, since of course, there was no such data collected by the state or federal government.
Congressman Costa’ staff sent us back to Congressman Ted Poe and we had a great meeting with Blair Bjellos. We gave her a copy of the draft Resolution. Leah from Women’s Policy said they might help with a hearing, Senator Bennet’s staff suggested Appropriations and Judicial Affairs. Josh Riley from Senator Al Franken’s office was very helpful and suggested we needed to:
- Explain that the Federal hook is that these are civil and human rights violations
- Talk to the Chair of the Judiciary Committee and our own member of Congress for hearings
- Department of Justice could hold hearings
- Hearings can become legislative proposals, oversight for Federal issues
- Federal grants for best practices are possible
- Converting funding is the right path, and we need to find the existing agency
- Prepare the Resolution and who would testify at a hearing, who would oppose it
Fred Ansell from Senator Grassley’s office had never heard of the issue and was also quite helpful. He said he hated family reunification, that it was hard to make state courts behave, and these cases should be in criminal court. He explained we needed:
- An Authorizing Committee and the Appropriations Committee.
- A Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF) line item
- An Office of Management and Budget (OMB) report
- A US Attorney to order a sting operation and prosecution If there are Federal crimes by public officials, to send a message. The US Marshals might be able to help.
- He suggested having Office of Violence Against Women (OVW) call first, for credibility.
NCADV policy lead Tralonne Shorter joined us for a meeting and suggested we needed
- A one-page fact sheet
- Legitimate research that meets the standards of Congress. We needed solid proof.
- Mention previous meetings.
- Meet with Ron LeGrand, attorney for the Judiciary Committee.
- Convince California Senator Dianne Feinstein.
- Hold a briefing like we did the previous October.
- Have Ted Poe request missing data send a letter to DOJ, which must respond with data.
- Have OVW convince the Attorney Generals and District Attorneys to investigate.
- Lynn Rosenthal knew how to move through the gaps.