Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 22: International, National, State and Local Efforts

“Unity is power; without unity women cannot fight for their rights anywhere.”

Nawal El Saadawi

We learned that the United Nations Entity for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women had published Progress of the World’ Women 2011-2012: In Pursuit of Justice.  An overview of their recommendations for gender discrimination for countries across the world, which now included the US, was blunt. 

  • Support women’s legal organizations.
  • Support one-stop shops to reduce attrition in the justice chain from report to conviction. 
  • Train judges and monitor decisions.
  • Implement gender-responsive reparations programs.
  • Put gender equality at the heart of the Millennium Development Goals.
  • Implement gender-sensitive law reform.
  • Put women on the front line of law enforcement for sexual assault reports.
  • Invest in women’s access to justice.
  • Increase women’s access to courts and truth commissions.
  • Use quotas to boost the number of women legislators.

This was shocking to us, in part because we didn’t think anyone cared, and in part because it was tangible evidence there was something terribly wrong. We had been taught from kindergarten onward that the United States was a paragon of equality. We were finding that was entirely untrue yet many of us clung to myths. Now the covers were pulled back.  Was this because of Jessica Lenahan Gonzales’ international case, and the protective mothers’ cases that Arizona attorney Dianne Post has sent to the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights?

George Washington University Law Professor Joan Meier, who had created the DV LEAP appellate project in 2003, introduced us to attorney Ray Calamaro from Hogan Lovells Law Firm in Washington DC.

They were lobbying for safety in the Hague Convention and wanted to connect with CA Senator Barbara Boxer who was the Chair of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, Subcommittee on International Operations, Human Rights, Democracy and Global Women’s Rights. What a mouthful.

It seemed a bit odd, since they were describing Hague Convention cases in which mothers fled TO the United States for safety. We were working to protect mothers who fled FROM the United States for safety, like Holly Collins and her flight to The Netherlands.  The 1980 Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction which went into force in 1983 had often not been helpful when American mothers tried to protect their children in another country.

The phrase was “internationally abducted by a parent from one member country to another.”  It invoked images of burly fathers kidnapping their children for sex trafficking in Thailand and provided an expedited method to return children. Alas, it was quite the opposite. We saw mothers fleeing because courts give those burly fathers their children for sex trafficking at home.

We saw mothers fleeing because courts give those burly fathers their children for sex trafficking at home.

Still, we wanted to have the Hague process protect all women and children. I was happy to oblige, so I went to Jack London Square in Oakland on February 12. It was hard to find Senator Boxer’s office.  Jeffrey Edelson, the new chair of the UC Berkeley’s School of Social Work, attorney Sudha Shetty from the Goldman School of Public Policy, a protective mother who had fled to the US for safety, and I met with Senator Boxer’s staff Jennifer Tang who was concerned about mothers and children, and Ariana Reks, who seemed pro-father. Ray Calamaro and Eileen King were on the phone. 

I never knew if there was any benefit from that meeting, but it was certainly interesting.

In January 2013, California Senators Jim Beall and Ricardo Lara authored SB 131 to create a window for recovery of damages which was signed into law in September. SB 326 (Beall) to specify permission for sex offenders to go on a school campus. I was shocked that an administrator could authorize a registered sex offender to volunteer, after notifying parents.  They should be nowhere near children under any circumstances.

More problems were cropping up in my own backyard. A Yolo County mother lost her children to an accused sex abuser thanks to the new judge who seemed to be a fathers’ rights proponent.  Cameron Handley who had developed the Yolo County Multi-Disciplinary Interview Center validated the county’s growing problem.

On March 7, 2013, I met with Yolo County Board of Supervisor Jim Provenza, a former family law attorney with Yolo County Assistant District Attorney Jonathan Raven and CA District Attorneys’ Association director Jean Jordan on the phone.  Jim Provenza said he would look into a Safe Child Task Force.

Jonathan Raven came up with the idea of having UC Davis law students advocate for victim children. I suggested having Victim Advocates from the District Attorney’s office to be court-appointed, like Court Appointed Special Advocates (CASA).

Jonathan Raven came up with the idea of having UC Davis law students advocate for victim children.

In April 2013, Child Justice was founded by Eileen King to provide pro bono legal services for lower court and appellate court cases that protect Maryland and Washington DC area children who were “lost in the system” after exposure to family violence, physical and or sexual abuse, substance addictions or neglect. They helped to ensure children’s rights were legally protected from abusive parents.

Assemblyman Brian Jones authored AB 958 to have the confidential custody evaluator report be given to a licensing board.  The bill died in committee. Later a similar bill passed to create Family Code section 3025.5 to give access by licensing entities. Senator Jim Beall authored SB 131 to eliminate the statute of limitation for child sex abuse which passed through the Legislative hoops but was vetoed by Governor Jerry Brown. It was crushing then, but later, the statute of limitations was extended.

On April 26, Barry Goldstein said he would be glad to become president of the National Safe Child Coalition. Tammi Stefano was planning to incorporate, which I assumed meant doing the paperwork for the current board of directors. However, by August, she had staged a coup while I was on vacation and declared herself Executive Director of our organization in a hostile takeover. Unbeknownst to us, she had registered the organization’s name when she had first begun helping us.

She began to focus on foster care and juvenile court, instead of family court.

We had reaped the rewards of not filing incorporation papers ourselves. Sadly, we ultimately had to let go of the organization name and try again.  It was a hard lesson learned. The Nineteenth Annual Child Sexual Abuse Awareness conference was held on April 27, 2013. Laurie Jones put together another lovely room with lavender and flowers.  Titled National Scandal: Family Courts Placing Children with Identified Sex Abusers, keynote Linda Barnard PhD spoke on the national scandal of family courts placing children with identified sex abusers. She said mental health professionals are not the appropriate experts to investigate crimes. That is a law enforcement duty. Exactly.

Linda Barnard PhD

Geraldine Stahly, PhD and Nancy Steubner MA presented their research findings on Custody Outcomes for Protective Parents in Cases with Child Sexual Abuse. It was abundantly clear that children were routinely being placed at risk. Kathleen Russell discussed Garland Waller’s documentary No Way Out But One. 

Jane Stevens spoke on the long-term effects of child abuse, with a focus on the ground- breaking Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) study.  It showed that childhood trauma, including child sexual abuse, prevented healthy development and had become a national public health emergency.

The Courageous Kids Network (CKN) presented Damon with a medal of honor. There was a powerful survivor speaker panel, including Josie Cohen’s now-adult son who described the problem articulately. Reporter Martin Burns interviewed some of the children.  Protective grandmother Helen told her story. 

The next day, Geri, Nancy, Helen, Mac and I met about turning the data we had collected into an academic journal article.

Helen Lynn went to Sacramento to attend the Women’s Empowerment meeting. She talked to politician Betty Yee who was stunned to hear about the leaked report of 570 child fatalities from maltreatment in a period of 18 months in Los Angeles alone.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.