“Hope sees the invisible, feels the intangible, and achieves the impossible.”
Helen Keller
The next day, we met with a big group of federal officials from the US Department of Health and Human Services Administration for Children and Families (US DHHS ACF), arranged by acting Assistant Director Debbie Powell whom we had met at the NPEIV Think Tank.

The group of 8 or 9 professionals included the Director of the Family Violence Division, Marylouise Kelly, Family and Youth Services, Children’s Bureau, and the program manager of the Fatherhood Initiative.
The mothers, one by one from all different parts of the U.S., said two sentences about their case. It was like having Holocaust victims sum up their years in concentration camps. They did an incredible job. Eileen King, who was starting Child Justice, and attorney and protective mother Natalie Khawam joined us. I talked about the Federal funding that fueled the loss of children to abusers. We made it clear that it was more than a failure of child welfare services. It was an action taken by family courts.
They seemed genuinely concerned. One said she had her own custody battle. We suggested finding out if men were being advised how to get custody. The program manager of the Fatherhood Initiative said she would look into the program.
One of the professionals shared with me that it was rare to have funding for a program go on for so many years, as with the fatherhood funding. Later we heard through the grapevine that the father’s rights men had threatened to defund VAWA if their Healthy Marriage and Responsible Fatherhood funds were touched. We didn’t doubt they could do that.
The officials suggested talking to the Battered Women’s Justice Project (we had) and the American Bar Association, and Child Support Enforcement director Vickie Turetsky (I had).
Although this group had no control over the origins of the funding, we suggested the following good ideas:
- Disconnecting child support from parenting time.
- Use specialist domestic violence courts.
- Develop citizen oversight review boards.
Debbie Powell talked to the mothers afterwards. When she asked if there was anything that caused them to lose custody. They all said yes.
They had reported their child had been sexually abused to family courts.
When she asked if there was anything that caused them to lose custody. They all said yes. They had reported their child had been sexually abused to family courts.
That meeting was a lot better than being shooed away by the police, like last time.
On October 26, we met with House Judiciary Committee counsel Ron LeGrand who was horrified. He said he would work with us and wanted everything we could bring him. He was wonderful. We met with the Women’s Policy Inc, which didn’t go very far.
We met in person with Chief of Staff Allison Randall at Office of Violence Against Women and Virginia Baran on the phone. Eight of their staff were survivors, so they totally understood. They said they got hundreds of calls from protective parents and wanted information on best practices. They asked for data. All we had was Geraldine Stahly’s research. There was still no government data, despite the requirement in California for the Judicial Council to collect and report on “custody dispositions.”
- They said it was clear protective mothers did better with attorneys so that would be a good direction, since it is best to start out right.
- They had no discretionary funds. Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) did.
- OVW can’t call for an FBI probe, but The Center for Public Integrity could do an undercover investigation.
- The Appropriations Committee can withhold $$ from grants or delete funding.
- HHS Inspector General investigates grant programs to investigate fraud, to see if they were giving custody advice.
- They would send the National Institute of Justice report to the National Criminal Justice Reference Service (NCJRS) website.
- They felt Congressional hearings were mostly show, but worth trying. Every bit helped.
- We suggested civil jury trials and disconnecting child support from parenting time.
The OVW project sites had not made changes on the ground for the rest of the country. Our issue had not been resolved. We were overwhelmed and could barely process all the information, so decided to focus on the idea of a Congressional Resolution.
We had a small but moving candlelight vigil at the White House with a million children sign on October 27, with Hurricane Sandy bearing down on us. The next day, the White House was cordoned off. Despite the weather, a few of us held a vigil and speak out as the Hurricane whirled around us. The protest was eloquent and tragic. We stayed, even as it got colder and more ominous. It seemed almost Biblical, and quite fitting.
Then protective mother Vicki and I drove to State College PA, racing the storm with a snowstorm on one side of us, the hurricane on the other, and a miraculously clear path in between. We finally arrived safely at the Penn Stater Hotel and Convention Center.
We had come for the October 28-30, 2012 Penn State Child Sexual Abuse Conference: Traumatic Impact, Prevention and Intervention, arranged to assuage a worried public, and perhaps potential Penn State donors, about the Jerry Sandusky scandal. It might have been a sort of a mea culpa for the years of child sexual abuse that was allowed on their campus in the past. It was very glossy. Ernie Allen from NCMEC was slick. We already knew he chased down fleeing mothers like they were slaves.
David Finkelhor Ph.D. and other respected researchers reassured us that there had been a substantial drop in child sexual abuse over the past decade, from 16% to 4% for boys and 25% to 16% for girls. We were quite sure that was not accurate and were more than skeptical.
When I looked at the data later, the drop was only in substantiation rates. The federal US DHHS said they did not keep granular data, but California Kidsdata.org showed that child sex abuse substantiation rate dropped from 20% in 2002 to 7% in 2011 in California. This simply meant that far fewer children were believed. It was essentially a decline by disbelief.
It was essentially a decline by disbelief.
It was a truly unsettling realization that the experts in the field were twisting reality, hopefully inadvertently, although I had been warned that this was happening. The talk was loaded with trigger words such as ‘draconian measures’ and ‘partners in statutory rape.’ One presenter said it was best not to punish juvenile rapists. Why not?
A welcome relief was Lucy Berliner MSW, Director, Harborview Center for Sexual Assault and Traumatic Stress and Clinical Associate Professor, University of Washington School of Social Work and Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences.

She said 70% of people with PTSD also had depression, and that a 16-week Trauma-Focused Cognitive Behavioral Therapy was an effective treatment for children who had been sexual abused. Step one was to face up to the event and feelings. (This posited that the adult remembered the abuse, instead of having amnesia for it.) She was sure victims would soon be able to access an app and do the CBT therapy themselves. PTSD was easier than depression to cure, and recovery is done by the trauma survivors themselves.
Law professor John Myers talked wonderfully about protocol and family court reform. Survivors Elizabeth Smart, Chris Anderson and swimmer Margaret Holtzer were superb, as was Sugar Ray Leonard. I asked him to sign a copy of his book and told him about the family court issue. He was shocked and said to contact his assistant Penelope Trickett. We did.
That did not go anywhere.
We were glad to see Viola Vaughn-Eden who was now president of the Association of Professionals Solving the Abuse of Children (APSAC). She had always been a strong supporter of keeping children safe in family courts.

Back in California, on November 8, protective mother Melissa Barnett and I met with Director Cathryn Wold of Solano Office of Family Violence in Fairfield. She was horrified at Melissa’s stories of her Napa County family court case. She told us that under Marcy’s Law, victim advocates stay with the victim even when there is no prosecution. That was very good information.
The Sacramento Family Justice Center strategy meeting was on November 26 with District Attorney Jan Scully, the Sacramento Police Chief, Judge Jerilyn Borack, now in juvenile court (who was friendly this time), Presiding Judge of Appellate Court Vance Roe, CASA, Sheriff, Presiding Judge Laurie Earl, the whole Sacramento system. There was a dynamic facilitator. Public defender Gail Streck from San Diego said she went up against Casey Gwinn prosecutor and was so impressed that she “changed sides.”
The next day, I talked about the need for MDIT and a process for children that paralleled adult victims. Judge Borack said money was needed for integrated domestic violence courts. I talked to the new director Paul Durenberger.
I wanted to tell the recalcitrant Yolo County that the Sacramento judges were all in, and their claim of conflict of interest were baloney.