Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 26: Children’s True Rights

“There is no trust more sacred than the one the world holds with children. There is no duty more important than ensuring that their rights are respected, that their welfare is protected, that their lives are free from fear and want and that they can grow up in peace.”

Kofi Annan

Our spunky little non-profit California Protective Parents Association was changing after 13 years. Jean Travis had grown frail and was ready to retire, so Ray Huckins became our president in 2013. He and Josie Cohen had been engaged before her untimely death when her son was only eight.  Mary Kravitz became treasurer, and Liz Edmonds became secretary. Karen continued as Executive Director, maintaining the court watch program, training groups of students from California State University in Sacramento and other schools, and coordinating their court watch hours.

Protective mother Josie Cohen had been the inspiration for California Protective Parents Association. Her son had grown up in the custody of his father.

When he emerged as an adult, he sent a formal complaint in December 2013 to the Commission on Judicial Performance about Judge Peter McBrien. He stated that the judge had showed partiality towards his molester father and knowingly and repeatedly placed him in danger which resulted in great bodily harm. Staff Attorney Brad Batton from the Commission on Judicial Performance sent this earnest young man a cold form letter, stating that his complaint “showed insufficient basis for commission proceedings.”  

I found a series of California children’s rights laws as of 2013. They had more autonomy than we thought, even though they likely had no idea of these rights nor how to exercise them.

AgePermissionSource
4A child can qualify as witness in criminal courtEvidence Code section 710
Any ageA child can consent to medical care related to pregnancy prevention/treatmentFamily Code section 6925
 A child can consent to medical care/collect evidence if sexually assaulted.Family Code section 6928
 A child’s qualified relative with a Caregiver Authorization Affidavit can sign for school, medical, dental, mental health care. Can be superseded by parent unless jeopardizes life, health or safetyFamily Code section 6550  
 A child who runs away has not committed a crime, but if caught by the police, can 1. be returned home, 2. be taken in by another legal guardian, 3. apply for emancipation, or  4. become dependent of the courtWelfare and Institutions Code section 207(b)(3) https://www.reference.com/world-view/california-s-runaway-laws-449b8bc8718fcd04
 A child can call a shelter, police or CPS to say they ran away to escape abuse and ask to go into protective custody. Parents can ask police to bring the child home. The child can ask to go to a shelter.  California Youth Crisis Line 800-843-5200 Legal Services for Children -SF/Alameda 415-863-3762 Legal Services for Youth – Santa Clara 408-280-2416 National Youth Law Center, Oakland, 510-835-8098 Northern CA Family Center, Martinez 800-718-4357 800-RUNAWAY 800-786-2929 National Runaway Switchboard 800-621-4000https://www.lsc-sf.org/ https://calyouth.org/cycl/ https://www.lawfoundation.org/legal-advocates-for-children-youth-lacy/ https://youthlaw.org/about/ https://ncfc.us/runaway-youth https://youth.gov/federal-links/national-runaway-switchboard-nrs
 The parent, guardian, or caregiver (a relative who can authorize medical/dental care) may authorize in writing an adult into whose care a child is entrusted to consent to medical/dental care for the child. 
 A child can bring an action on the existence or non-existence of parentage, under conditionsFamily Code section 7630
12A child shall (and may, if younger) be made a party to the action (of parentage if parents not married) and shall be appointed a guardian ad litem if a party.Family Code section 7635
 A child may appear in court without a guardian, counsel or guardian ad litem to request or oppose a restraining order.Code of Civil Procedure 372(b)
 A child can consent to outpatient mental health treatment/counseling or residential shelter service if in the opinion of the attending professional the child is mature enough to participate intelligently or.presents a danger of serious physical or mental harm to self or to others without the mental health treatment or counseling or residential shelter services or is alleged victim of incest or child abuse.Family Code section 6924
 A child may consent to medical care of an infectious, contagious, or communicable disease, w/conditionsFamily Code section 6926
 A child alleged to have been raped may consent to medical care related to the diagnosis or treatment of the condition and the collection of medical evidence.Family Code section 6927
 A child may consent to medical care/counseling for diagnosis/treatment of a drug/alcohol problem.Family Code section 6929
 A child injured by intimate partner violence may consent to medical care/ diagnosis or treatment of the injury and collection of medical evidence.Family Code section 6930
 A child’s disclosures to a school counselor are confidential except in mandated reporting/conditions.Education Code section 49602
14A child is emancipated if married or on active military duty, or a court declares a child 14 or older emancipated if he or she willingly lives separate from parents with their consent and manages own financial affairs. Family Code sections 7120, 7121
 A child shall (and if younger, may) be permitted to address the court if the child wishes, regarding custody or visitation, unless the court determines it is not in the child’s best interest. If the court does not call a child as a witness, the court shall provide alternative means of obtaining input from the child and other information regarding the child’s preferences.Family Code section 3042
15A child may consent to medical/dental care if he or she lives apart from parents, manage own legal finances.Family Code section 6922

CA Evidence Code section 710 states, “Every witness before testifying shall take an oath or make an affirmation or declaration in the form provided by law, except that a child under the age of 10 or a dependent person with a substantial cognitive impairment, in the court’s discretion, may be required only to promise to tell the truth.”

Angela D. Evans and Thomas D. Lyon wrote in Assessing Children’s Competency to Take the Oath in Court: The Influence of Question Type on Children’s Accuracy that children aged 4 are considered able to tell the difference between truth and lie and were found to be competent witnesses in trials. 

In 2012 the National Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges passed a new best practice recommendation that frames having children in court as a presumed practice. Los Angeles Model Court came into the project with the policy of having children in court from age 4 and up. Yet, family court judges treated children as property, without a direct voice.

Yet, family court judges treated minors as property without a direct voice.

We flew back to Washington DC again, and on September 30, we took little blue invitations in person to every Congress member in the Rayburn and Longworth buildings, urging them to attend our upcoming briefing. It was, indeed, an act of faith, not to mention a whole lot of walking. It was primitive compared to groups that had the inside track and could invite staff personally by email, but at least we got the message out. We asked Ron LeGrand about a GAO audit and Oversight Hearing.

The next day we had our Domestic Violence month demonstration at the White House. We gathered with our banners and handouts, wearing our insignia white t-shirts. We marched down 15th Avenue to Pennsylvania Avenue, then rested at the Department of Justice. We marched on to the US Capitol where we had a speak out. 

There were 30-40 people on a beautiful fall day.

The government had officially shut down, but fortunately the doors were still open, so we took packets and invitations to the Cannon building. Josie’s son had come with us, and helped distribute invitations at that huge building. In all, we gave an invitation to every one of the 435 House members. It was quite a feat.  Our white t-shirts were noticed. It was very empowering for the mothers. One had just gotten out of the hospital.  One was in a wheelchair.  They powered on anyway.

On October 2, 2013, we proudly held our very own first ever Congressional briefing at 2226 Rayburn on Protecting Abused Children of Divorce and Separation. It was sponsored by the Victims’ Rights Caucus and Stop Abuse Campaign.

It wasn’t that hard to put together, sort of like a small conference.

Andrew Willis was the master of ceremonies, with his lovely British accent and clear message.  Joy Silberg, PhD presented data on the “Turned Around” cases. She did an outstanding job as did protective mothers Hera and Donnette, and advocates Barry Goldstein, and Eileen King. Professionals and mothers spoke eloquently to 14 staff members, including four from Congresswoman Pelosi’s office. Over 30 mothers attended.

There was even a reporter from the Washington Post and a photographer.

That afternoon, we met with Jessica Wixon from Congresswoman Jaime Herrera Beutler’s office, Chari Jack Kingston from Congresswoman Allison Myers office, Krista Ellis at Congresswoman Doris Matsui’s office, and Kevin Kincheloe from Congressman James Lankford’s office. He agreed we needed Congressional Oversight Hearings. We met with Veronica Wong from Congressman Darrell Issa’s office, at the same time constituents were meeting with his staff in San Diego.

The next day, Barry Goldstein and I met with Lauren Nassikas from the Office of Violence Against Women (OVW) again for an hour. Barry talked about the research. The idea of a Violence Against Children division was agreeable, but they needed funding.

The idea of an (OVW) Violence Against Children division was agreeable, but they needed funding.

They discussed having victim advocates for children who reported child sex abuse, even without prosecution.  I latched on to that viable idea. But again, funding was needed.

woman talking to child

In November 2013,  the Office of Violence Against Women (OVW) gave grants to four demonstration projects for training in promising practices for family courts to Cook County in Chicago, the state of Delaware, Hennepin County where Holly Collins’ case was held in Minnesota, and Multnomah County in Oregon.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.