“In the short term, corporal punishment may produce obedience. But it is a fact documented by research that in the long term the results are inability to learn, violence and rage, bullying, cruelty, inability to feel another’s pain, especially that of one’s own children, even drug addiction and suicide, unless there are enlightened or at least helping witnesses on hand to prevent that development.”
Alice Miller
We did not know it at the time, but Congress members Luis Gutierrez, Karen Bass and Judy Chu were preparing to introduce HR 476, a Resolution for a Children’s Bill of Rights: Supporting the establishment of a national Children’s Bill of Rights. It would read:
Whereas all children and youth have the inalienable right to live in a just, safe, and supportive society; and
Whereas this right belongs to all children, regardless of gender, class, race, ethnicity, national origin, culture, religion, immigration status, sexual orientation, or ability: Now, therefore, be it
Resolved, it is the sense of the House of Representatives that every child is entitled to—
- physical well-being, including—
- (A) the right to be free from all forms of physical, psychological, or sexual abuse, neglect, and exploitation;
- (B) the right to have the child’s essential needs met, including nutritious food, safe and accessible shelter, clothing, health care, and accessible transportation;
- (C) the right to a safe and healthy environment, including homes, schools, neighborhoods, and communities;
- (D) the right to the care and protection of the State in which the child resides if there is no parent, legal guardian, or other caregiver willing and able to assume responsibility for the care and well-being of the child; and
- (E) the right to receive appropriate medical treatment, and the right to access affordable health insurance coverage, including effective therapeutic interventions for behavioral health;
- social and emotional well-being, including—
- (A) the right to develop a healthy attachment to a parent, legal guardian, or caregiver, and the right to an ongoing relationship with a caring and supportive adult;
- (B) the right to remain with a parent, legal guardian, or caregiver, except when authorities determine separation is in the best interest of the child;
- (C) the right to be reunited with a parent, legal guardian, or caregiver should separation occur, with priority given to keeping children with their family or with kin in a home setting, whenever it remains in the child’s best interest to do so;
- (D) the right to maintain direct contact with parents on a regular basis when a child is separated from a parent, including cases in which a parent is incarcerated or detained, whenever it remains in the child’s best interest to do so;
- (E) the right to access sports and other extracurricular activities that support the child’s healthy social, emotional, and physical development;
- (F) the right to a voice in matters that affect the child, and the right to participation in age-appropriate forums, including representation on youth councils and other decisionmaking bodies;
- (G) the right to have the child’s best interest taken into consideration with regards to decisions that affect the child;
- (H) the right to have appropriate legal representation and a child advocate in legal proceedings to represent the interest of the child;
- (I) the right to rehabilitative services and periodic review if detained or incarcerated as a juvenile; and
- (J) the right to have parents, elected officials, and other adults consider the effect that their decisions will have on a child’s care and community; and
- educational and life skills, including—
- (A) the right to a well-rounded, high-quality, and culturally competent education that promotes success in life and in future careers;
- (B) the right to access educational services and supports necessary to accommodate the child’s needs;
- (C) the right to a safe learning environment, and the right to be free from bullying;
- (D) the right to an education that is sufficiently funded to provide the child with the tools and technology necessary for a successful learning experience;
- (E) the right to be heard in age-appropriate ways on issues regarding the education of the child and to be represented on school boards and other decisionmaking bodies;
- (F) the right of access to training in life skills that will prepare the child to live independently and contribute to the child’s community; and
- (G) the right to protections from unfair and unsafe labor practices in the workforce
I wish we’d known about the bill. Without support, it didn’t pass.
We learned about Elizbeth Gershoff at the University of Texas at Austin. Her 2013 article Spanking and Child Development: We Know Enough Now to Stop Hitting Our Children crisply dissected spanking as not only ineffective, but harmful.

It made me think back to AB 755 by Assemblywoman Sally Lieber in 2007 that went down to defeat based on ridiculous arguments by right wing Christians that beating children was necessary.
Would Jesus ever hit a child? Of course not.
But according to the DeShaney v Winnebago County Department of Social Services Supreme Court decision, state government’s failure to prevent child abuse by a custodial parent did not violate the “child’s right to liberty.” However, there was an exception. A government must provide protection if it was responsible for creating the danger, i.e., state-created danger.
Family law attorney Maria Palazzolo and I had met at a 2015 CPEDV policy meeting and attended the Domestic Violence Coordinating Council meeting for the Sacramento Family Justice Center. They planned to locate their center right in the Sacramento Family Law courthouse. Co-location would help greatly and provide a one-stop shop for victims. Paul Durenberger from the Sacramento District Attorney’s office had made it happen.
Assemblyman Richard Bloom, a voting member of the Judicial Council, authored AB 749 to ensure court reporters for all hearings for child custody or domestic violence as an access to justice issue. It was one of our top needs. But the cost would be $100,000 per court reporter and the bill died in committee.
The lack of a record of hearing in California would turn out to be an ongoing and devastating problem for protective parents. As one attorney wryly put it, “Even Missouri has court reporters in family courts.”
Steve Burdo from Center for Judicial Excellence said we need to meet with Legislators individually with a panel of litigants and advocates, like we had done with Assemblywoman Fiona Ma. He was right
I went to Washinton DC again on November 18, for a Congressional briefing on Corporal Punishment. Joyce Thomas moderated. Deb Sendek, Viola Vaughan-Eden, Professor Elizabeth Gershoff and George Holden spoke. Elizabeth Gershoff had prepared an excellent brochure. The talks were spot on. It was so fundamental. Children were humans and should have the same protections for safety as adults, if not more.
Children were humans and should have the same protections for safety as adults, if not more.
CPPA funded the luncheon. Federal analyst Leora Rosen planned to begin a group Advocates for Supporting Protective Parents as our DC representative. I stopped in to see Krystal Williams at Sheila Jackson Lee to ask about the Resolution. They had postponed the bill but said they would get right on it.
In California, Kim Robinson, Kathleen Russell, protective grandfather Ronnie Lozano and I met with Legislative staffers and the Women’s Commission staff. We asked the Chair of the Senate Judiciary Committee Hannah Beth Jackson to initiate a Judicial Council Committee on Safety of Children in Custody Disputes.
Nothing.
The Center for Judicial Excellence was focused on improving the judiciary on more than just the family court level. Kathleen worked a miracle in getting approval for an audit of the Commission on Judicial Performance (CJP) approved. She exposed the CJP as a toothless watchdog in comparison with other states. The hearing was raucous and off base, with hot-headed litigants being impolite, but the audit moved forward despite that level of intensity.
We continued going to the Judicial Council meetings. We asked for a policy statement that child safety would be the first and highest priority in family court decisions and asked the Judicial Council to reduce adverse childhood experiences by keeping children with safe parents. I asked for a Child Safety Committee.
We also asked for the public to be provided data on custody disposition outcomes required under Family Code section 1850(b). We realized they probably weren’t collecting the data and had no intention of doing so.
The assembled group once again stared at us politely, as if we were a rare type of bug.
I met with a mother whose child was placed with a two-time registered sex offender by Yolo County Judge Kathleen White. Dave Greenwald wanted to do family court watch. Later, at Dave’s Vanguard forum, I talked about the increasing reports of children placed with accused and adjudicated batterers and pedophiles in Yolo County, the Stahly data and the Adverse Childhood Experiences study showing the damage done by abuse and trauma.
I met with a mother whose child was placed with a two-time registered sex offender…