Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 16: More and More Child Fatalities

“The hottest places in hell are reserved for those who, in times of great moral crisis, maintain their neutrality.”

Dante

Child abuse mushroomed. Good social workers fled. Foster care was not a safe option. Perpetrators were protected. The system was failing to such a degree that it seemed to attack children, not rescue them. It seemed to work as a well-oiled machine for purposes diametrically opposed to those for which it was designed. How could that be? It was deeply troubling.

58,000 adult Americans were killed in the two decades we fought in the Vietnam war.

According to the Child Maltreatment Reports (US Department of Health and Human Services) during two decades between 2004 to 2024, about 30,000 to 35,000 children died of child maltreatment in the United States. We saw how drastically underreported child fatalities were in California through the Los Angeles confidential report in the previous chapter.

The real body count might be double that shown by the US DHHS. Where is the parade for those little ones who died in domestic battle? Where is the war memorial for children? Where is the museum of murdered children?

The number of children perishing every year was nearly the same number as adult intimate partner homicides and both were increasing.  But the death rate was much higher for children, since there were fewer children than adults in the population.

US fatalities20142017
Adult population244,800,000251,500,000
Adult domestic fatalities1,8752,137
Child population73,600,00073,600,000
Child abuse/neglect fatalities1,546  1,720

The sky really was falling on the little ones.

You might be asking by now, how does Child Welfare Services failure affect our quest to keep children from being placed with violent, incestuous parents in custody disputes in family courts?  Family court is an entirely different system, a different institution, a different silo.

The answer is that when agencies screen out or fail to substantiate a child abuse case, the rest of the system wrongly believes there was no abuse. The same dynamic happens when law enforcement does not prosecute, and since their burden of proof is much higher, that is also a common problem.  The increasing child homicides are predictable and preventable.

The answer is that when agencies screen out or fail to substantiate a child abuse case, the rest of the system wrongly believes there was no abuse.

Law enforcement did not seem to take the cases seriously, with the top level calling them “he said, she said” situations. The systems that fed into family courts were certainly broken, especially child welfare services. They were overburdened, understaffed and at times flat-out corrupt.

There had to be a better way.  We couldn’t even get something in place in our little bitty county of 200,000 where I personally knew many good people in the system.

On March 5, 2018, Kathleen Russell, Catherine Campbell and I presented at the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) Oversight Hearing by the Senate Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development and the Assembly Committee on Business and Professions.

The Board of Psychology and the Board of Behavioral Sciences were under the DCA. They were the oversight boards for psychologists. Evaluators were nearly always psychologists. These sunset hearings were no doubt usually pro forma events, but we decided to use the time to explain, as best we could, the dilemma parents were facing in family court as a result of what could only be called predatory psychologists.

We explained that private evaluators were being appointed under Evidence Code section 730 for expert witnesses. They did not follow the protocols of Family Code for investigating child abuse cases. We explained that these professionals are not regulated and charge whatever the market would bear.  They are often paid huge fees, up to $60,000 in wealthy counties, by the batterers.

This was a hot potato since the professional oversight agencies said the court has oversight, and the Judicial Council said the professional oversight agencies have oversight. As a result, there was no oversight.  We thought the Department of Consumer Affairs and the Legislature should help sort this out. We talked to the Chair of the Committee for quite a while afterwards. He was concerned.

Still, nothing.

Assemblyman Bloom tried to increase the scope of evaluators under Evidence Code 730 to a vocational evaluation bill SB 2780. We protested and the language was removed. 

Senator Moorlach tried to make an exception for family court with SB 1276, so evaluators could give hearsay-based reports and recommendations, creating an exception to the People v Sanchez Supreme Courtruling in 2016. We strongly opposed it, and the bill died.

Senator Gaines introduced SB 1220 to have law enforcement agencies use lethality assessment tools in domestic violence cases. We were in support, but it too died in committee.

It felt like a mad game of Wack-a-Mole.

But there were bright spots. One sunny afternoon, Kathleen and I had been walking the halls of the Capitol. We were headed home but stopped in our tracks when we heard a speak out on the steps of the building. We listened a bit and discovered the speaker was none other than Assemblywoman Blanca Rubio, speaking on domestic violence. As she left the podium, we hurried over to her and said we were advocates for children of domestic violence.

Assemblywoman Blanca Rubio

She gave us a big hug.

That was that. We knew we had a real friend at the Capitol. On top of that, her sister had been a victim of violence by Assemblyman Roger Hernandez.  He lost his job. His victim became California Senator Susan Rubio.

We decided to ask Assemblywoman Rubio if she would help with a California resolution for child safety. She did not hesitate for a moment, understanding instinctively that if adult violence victims were not being protected, young victims were in worse situations. In a strange turn of event, we found that Ana Estevez lived in Assemblywoman Rubio’s district and connected them.  They were both in the education field and soon became a powerful team.

On April 7, 2018, the documentary What Doesn’t Kill Me: Domestic Violence and the Battle for Custody by Rachel Meyrick was shown at a Human Rights Film Festival at University of San Francisco with a panel that consisted of educator Sarah Kerlow, Kathleen and me. We fit right in with human rights conferences.

We fit right in with human rights conferences.

The next day, California Protective Parents Association celebrated our 20th anniversary with the Twenty-Second Annual Child Sexual Abuse Awareness conference titled Domestic Violence and the Battle for Custody: Moving Toward Child Safety at the Richard Brunelle Performance Hall in Davis. Executive Director Catherine Campbell was the gracious mistress of ceremonies.

We showed Rachel Mayrick’s film. Kathleen and whistleblower Judge DeAnn Salcido presented. We talked about the well-oiled family court machine which was working exactly as it was designed to work: to protect fathers’ hegemony and ensure violent, incestuous father have access to their children.

Just in time to celebrate our Anniversary, HR 113 (Rubio) went into print. This was our California resolution that pretty much mirrored the Congressional Resolution H. Con. Res. 72.

Meanwhile, the Florida Attorney General’s Statewide Domestic Violence Fatality Review Team was documenting the profile of domestic violence murderers in Faces of Fatality: Report of the Attorney General’s Statewide Domestic Violence Fatality Review Team (2018).

Who were these murderers?

  • They carried or possessed a weapon (68%).
  • They had substance abuse histories (62%).
  • They had prior incidents, or threats of, domestic violence (55%).
  • They had a criminal history (55%). 

Other indicators of increased lethality risk were the murderer had previous attempts to strangle the victim, was unemployed and was living in a home with children not his.

We wondered if these same factors applied for child domestic violence murderers.

It was a busy spring in 2018. Budget Subcommittee No. 5 heard testimony on the Commission on Judicial Performance’s lawsuit to block the state agency Bureau of State Audits from auditing their books.  We testified that we taxpayers were now paying for the ineffective Commission on Judicial Performance (over 11,000 cases in a decade resulted in only 38 public admonishments and 4 removals of judges), the Bureau of State Audits which was thwarted in doing their job by the lawsuit, the litigation initiated by the CJP, the court process and attorneys for both agencies, and the Legislative hearings on the matter.

Tongue in cheek, I recommended mediation.

On May 21, the Legislature voted to reduce the CJP’s budget by half a million dollars. Things went much better after that and got worked out behind the scenes. The auditor and the public ultimately had our way in September 2018, when the Commission settled their suit with the Bureau of State Audits, and the audit finally began.

It had been an expensive roller coaster ride, a massive waste and abuse of taxpayer dollars that lasted for 2 years just to start the process. 

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.