“Institutional Betrayal is harming those who are dependent on the institution.”
Jennifer Freyd PhD
This was on the heels of the largest small body count yet in a single year in California. 2017 was a year of child carnage related to divorce and separation that sounded like an undeclared war on children. These were deaths that the press covered, which represented the tip of the iceberg, we felt sure. More little bodies, little caskets, little graves.

In January 2017, Dominic Nunn (8) was killed by his father Shakir Nunn in San Bernardino.
In March 2017, Alvin (11) and Mia Vasquez (14) were murdered in Sacramento by their father Salvador Vazquez-Oliva, who confessed to killing the children, their mother and a niece.
In April 2017, five-year-old Aramazd Andressian Jr., lovingly known as “Piqui,” was murdered by his father. He was last seen on April 21, leaving Disneyland with his father who was found unconscious in South Pasadena the next day after a failed suicide attempt. Piqui’s little body was found on July 1, 2017 in the Lake Cachuma area of Santa Barbara County, California.
His father Aramazd Andressian Sr. had been arrested, released, then re-arrested on June 23 in Nevada after partying in Las Vegas. He confessed to smothering his son with his own jacket. This case was particularly horrifying due to the father’s evident premeditation, and the courage of Piqui’s mother Ana Estevez who become a persuasive, persistent activist.

In June 2017, days before Piqui’s body was found, police climbed through an open window at the home of Alvaro Botelho da Camara in Santa Rosa California after Julian (19 mos) and Juliana Camara (6) were not brought back from a Father’s Day visit to their mother Connie Camara. Alvaro was found dead hanging from a rope. The children had been killed.
Also in June 2017, Autumn Shibley (3) was killed by her father Aaron Roman Freeman, who had a history of violence, yet had received custody of the child in San Bernardino.
In October 2017, Isabella (7) and Cristos Lopez (10) were killed in a fire at the condo of their father Henry Lopez in San Diego who was so drunk, he fell asleep with a lit cigarette. He was convicted.
In January 2018, I testified at the California Judicial Council about the immediate result of their laissez-faire attitude. These children were dead because the Council had ignored our pleas to make policies that kept children safe. They were, after all, the policy-making body for the largest judiciary in the country. They had the power, but not the desire, to fix this.
They were, after all, the policy-making body for the largest judiciary in the country. They had the power, but not the desire, to fix this.
The Pittsburgh City paper published an articleon February 28, 2018 titled Children’s advocates say family courts unfairly favor fathers, even when they’re the abusers.
Attorney Richard Ducote was quoted:
“This 9-year-old testified to the …rape that his father was committing and to sexual fondling. This is the same testimony that in criminal cases is sufficient to support a criminal conviction beyond a reasonable doubt, but in family court, it’s disregarded, because the courts favor this excuse of parental-alienation syndrome. Courts say this is simply the result of the mother coaching the child to say the father’s beating them, therefore the father should have custody.”
Attorney Joan Meier was quoted:
“What the data show is that alienation does a lot of damage when a father claims it against a mother who is claiming abuse, that it is not gender equitable, that it doesn’t work the same way in reverse. Parental alienation is very gender biased. It does a lot more damage when a father wields it than when a mother wields it. And it does more damage when she claims abuse.”
These two persistent attorneys, advocates for battered mothers and their abused children, had been telling reporters this truth repeatedly since the 1990s. After decades of anguish, when would it stop? What could we do to bring this war against children to an end?
That month, Kathleen Russell, Catherine Campbell, Melissa Knight-Fine and I met with the Attorney General of California’s Legislative Director Sirat Attipat. We told her about the family court crisis, the child murders related to divorce and separation, the FBI investigation of Solano County, H. Con. Res. 72 and what laws were needed. We asked, would they help protect children?
The silence was deafening.
Did nobody really care? My heart broke again at the systemic betrayal by the institutions designed to protect children. We picked ourselves up and forged ahead.
Psychology professor Jennifer Freyd coined the acronym DARVO to explain the deny, attack, reverse roles of victim and offender tactics we were seeing from abusers. The fundamental problem was that institutions across the whole system were enabling them, from the bottom to the top. Dr. Freyd calls it “Institutional Betrayal,” which it is.
As child sexual abuse was increasingly in the headlines, it was being increasingly ignored by the California Child Welfare Services. The child population stayed about 9 million between 1998 to 2018, as child abuse reports rose from approximately 429,000 to 487,000. Within the categories, there were notable differences.
Reports coded as child neglect rose greatly from 159,000 to 232,000. Reports coded as child physical abuse dropped from 106,000 to 93,000 and child sexual abuse dropped from 54,000 to 46,000. But the real plunge was in substantiation rates. Dramatically fewer children were considered victims. The winnowing process was fierce.
| California Child Welfare Services | 1998 | 2018 |
| Child physical abuse substantiation rates | 20.2% | 5.2% |
| Child sexual abuse substantiation rates | 20.5% | 7.5% |
It was the mirror opposite of what it should be. The overall fall in national substantiation rates were just as shocking, dropping by half, from about 32% to about 15%.
| National Child Welfare Services | 1998 | 2019 |
| National child population | 71,400,000 | 73,100,000 |
| Referrals | 2,800,000 | 4,400,000 |
| Referrals by professionals | 53.1% | 68.5% |
| Substantiated | 903,000 (32.2%) | 656,000 (14.9%) |
| Child fatalities | 1,100 | 1,840 |
What was going on around here? Each of these millions of referrals included approximately one and a half children each.
Even if nearly half were screened out as not appropriate or not enough information or not the right department or just because, millions of children were still suffering. This was a wildfire of abused kids. The firefighters attended to only a tiny portion, fewer every decade. Were social workers trying desperately to protect themselves from a tsunami of referrals and overwork by pretending away the reality of the abuse and slamming the door on an increasing number of children?
What a recipe for disaster.
And the disaster is far worse than the public reports show. A leaked confidential report dated April 16, 2012 by the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors’ Children’s Special Investigation Unit revealed that, according to the Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) Bureau of Information Services, there had been 570 child fatalities reported to DCFS in the 18 months from June 2010 to December 2011. (The cover letters described October 2010 as the beginning date of data collection, but the report shows it began in June 2010.)

This is one child fatality every single day in Los Angeles County.
The US DHHS Child Maltreatment reports showed a total of 120 child fatalities in all of California in the year 2010 and 123 in the year 2011. That was a big gap.
The report found investigation, decision-making, communication, coordination and management failures by the Los Angeles Department of Children and Family Services. This scandal was followed by a shocking audit which found that over 1000 foster home addresses matched those of registered sex offenders in Los Angeles. The Los Angeles Board of Supervisors filed a lawsuit to fight the investigation. The California Department of Social Services said the number was really 31.
It left us speechless.