“The arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice.”
Martin Luther King, Jr.
On January 19, 2019, Incest Survivors Speakers Bureau held the Annual Child Sexual Abuse Awareness Conference titled Ritual Abuse and Mind Control: History and Scope with keynote speaker Randy Noblitt PhD. We provided handouts on the Extreme Abuse Survey.
The shocking history of a survivor from an aristocratic European cult family was told. She had described global, sequential ceremonies and worked with a team to freed cult captives. Special guest Kevin Annett spoke also about rescues. His website showed that in 2017, his International Tribunal of Crimes of Church and State (ITCCS) teams successfully invaded three cult sites (Holland, France and Switzerland) of a powerful secret society and made citizen arrests of nineteen cult members. They gathered evidence including satanic regalia, torture devices and small padlocked cages, along with human remains. Eight children were rescued.
Committee for Children, formed in 1979 to help victims of child sexual abuse, held a Congressional briefing on January 28, 2019. They requested $10 million for the Center for Disease Control and Prevention to conduct research on preventing child sex abuse. Deputy Director of the Georgia Division of Family and Children Services Deborah Chosewood, Director of the Moore Center for the Prevention of Child Sexual Abuse at Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health Dr. Elizabeth Letourneay, Director of the Division of Violence Prevention at the CDC Dr. James Mercy, and Maryland State Delegate C. T. Wilson spoke powerfully and clearly.
They requested $10 million for the Center for Disease Control and Prevention to conduct research on preventing child sex abuse.
On March 19, 2019 the Center for Investigative Reporting (CIR) finally aired the article on Reveal about custody that Kathleen had asked for years before. Bitter Custody began with, “A controversial theory is swaying family court judges to award custody to parents accused of harming kids.
We trace the origins of “parental alienation” and learn how it has spawned a cottage industry of so-called family reunification camps that are making big profits from broken families.”
The CIR story highlighted abusive mothers, which was very much not the norm. We had hoped for an ongoing series that would break open this terrible problem of placing children with abusive fathers. It did expose parental alienation and the grotesque unregulated reunification camps that use pressure tactics to deprogram and change children’s fundamental reality, to try to make them love their abusers.
Again, Chinese re-education camps that began in the 1940s to control the minds of people came to mind, as well as the chilling CIA experiments that began in the 1950s to depattern people’s minds.
The theme for the April 26- 28, 2019 Fourteenth Battered Mothers Custody Conference in Albany, New York was #WeToo: Connecting the Protective Mothers Movement to the #MeToo Movement.
Adult sexual abuse victims had risen up to oppose their sexual predators. Adult victims could leave their offenders and use the civil and criminal justice system to hold them accountable. Marci Hamilton’s Child USA led the statute of limitations extension charge. New York stepped up, as did California, which passed SB 218 (Gonzalez) in 2019, including a window for filing old cases. The crime was renamed child sexual assault, instead of abuse.
This would help when the child became an adult, but we still needed prevention. Even slaves had the possibility of fleeing North to remove themselves from their owners by crossing the Mason Dixon line. Children held hostage by family courts have no North.

They are helpless, trapped in families that hurt them, held there by the very systems designed to protect them. If adults choose to disbelieve them, their voices are muted. Children were muzzled, silenced in the #MeToo movement.
An evaluation report of the Sargent Shriver Civil Counsel Pilot Program Legal Representation Makes a Difference for Vulnerable, Low Income Californians was sent to the Legislature in 2019. Los Angeles, San Diego, and San Francisco chose to supply attorneys for child custody. Other counties used the attorneys mostly for evictions.
The New York-based Stop Abuse Campaign was moving forward with the Safe Child Act to implement H. Con. Res. 72 in all 50 states.
- It would require that the health and safety of children be the first priority when family courts make decisions about child custody and visitation decisions.
- It would also require that professionals have specific knowledge, training and qualifications to effectively recognize and respond to domestic violence allegations.
- It would prohibit unscientific theories. It would require that when the preponderance of the evidence establishes a pattern of domestic violence, the safe parent receives custody and the abuser is supervised, with a safe method to reestablish normal contact.
California has many of those laws, but without strong oversight, they are ignored.
A small bureaucratic triumph happened in the shadow of the January 6, 2021 bloody insurrection that threatened to topple our democracy. It had been a personal quest to have a form to implement the multi-stepped protocol for investigating child sexual abuse in custody cases under Family Code section 3118.
The Judicial Council had thwarted the idea at every turn for 20 years which made us know it was valuable. In July 2019, Assemblywoman Blanca Rubio authored AB 1179 to require the Judicial Council to create such a form. On January 9, 2021 the long awaited FL-329 came into existence.
After two decades of horrible, preventable child homicides, and persistent pestering, we finally had a template. The next step was to make sure the courts used it. Assemblywoman Rubio was not afraid of anyone and had succeeded in staring down the Judiciary. We knew things would go well in the future when she became the chair of the Assembly Select Committee on Domestic Violence.
A woman’s work is never done.
The California Court Statistical Report showed a progressive decline in family court filings over two decades. I wondered why. California had grown from 34 million in 2000 to nearly 40 million people in 2018, yet the child population remained nearly the same, slightly over 9 million. Maybe fewer children per adult meant there were fewer custody disputes? Maybe couples with no children didn’t marry as often and just separated without involving the courts in dissolution?
| Filings in California Family/Juvenile Courts | 2001-02 | 2010-11 | 2019-20 |
| Marital (dissolutions, legal separations, nullities) | 160,000 | 154,279 | 108,457 |
| Family law petitions (paternity, child support) | 330,000 | 260,514 | 200,875 |
| Juvenile Delinquency | 92,000 | 73,231 | 31,699 |
| Juvenile Dependency | 40,000 | 39,003 | 41,326 |
Dependency court filings stayed about the same overall, but the drop in juvenile delinquency cases was dramatic. I wondered why. The court’s website answered that question in part.
“Probation’s role is to protect youth and prevent further delinquency or entry into the adult justice system. These goals are met by reducing juvenile recidivism, healing and reconnecting families, and responding to youth behavior with interventions that reduce delinquency. Working upstream with community partners like schools and other community outreach programs has reduced precursors to entry into the juvenile justice system.”
“Pursuing this strategy has changed the nature and severity of those coming into the juvenile justice system. Collaborating with social services and justice system partners gives probation more options to address public safety risks, as well as the needs of youth referred to probation. With the declining number of youth arrested, referred, and granted wardship probation – the youth now placed on supervision are those with more severe risk levels. This population, with more acute needs and higher risk levels, requires smaller caseloads to properly and successfully supervise.”
How exciting to see some progress in dry statistics.
Still, there was nothing in the report on custody disposition surveys, even though they had been required for years. Children of Domestic Violence were still losing the war in family courts.
Children of Domestic Violence were still losing the war in family courts.
Press was helping. The Washington Post ran an article on July 29, 2019,by Samantha Schmidt titled A gendered trap’: When mothers allege child abuse by fathers, the mothers often lose custody, study shows. It highlighted Joan Meier’s study showing family courts only believed mothers’ claims of child physical abuse 21% of the time and child sexual abuse 19% of the time. It was far worse when a father accused the mother of alienation.
Fatal Court: The Harm to Children in the Nation’s Family Courts has Reached Crisis Proportions by Gillian Friedman with the insistent help of Kathleen Russell from Center for Judicial Excellence, was published in the Deseret News on September 17, 2019.
The Center for Judicial Excellence focused on legislative priorities that combined children’s safety and rights with judicial accountability. Kathleen had a long-range view, which included Judicial Performance Evaluations (report cards for judges as existed in 17 other states), audit of the oversight committees for psychologists, and reform or abolishment of the toothless watchdog Commission on Judicial Performance (CJP) which received approximately 11,000 complaints in the past decade and issued exactly 60 public disciplines. Two were for Judge Peter McBrien. Other hand slaps were kept secret.
The phrase “swallow a camel and strain out a gnat” came to mind again.
It was exhausting and I was getting tired, but we couldn’t stop. We knew it would make it easier to pass laws to stop this barbarism at the state level if Congress became involved.
California Protective Parents Association, Center for Judicial Excellence, and Peace Over Violence and held a classy conference in September 2019 on the beach in Santa Monica titled Trauma-Informed Practices: Protecting Child Survivors of Domestic Violence and Child Sexual Abuse in the Family Court System. It was planned in conjunction with Cal State Northridge professor Diane Bartlow who had done research on child murders. Dr. Felitti spoke about the ACE study.