“There can be no justice until those uninjured by crime become as indignant as those who are.”
Jonathan Raven
Two days later, CA Senator Susan Rubio agreed to author a bill to implement the reauthorization. Less than a week later, Center for Judicial Excellence had prepared language.
Meera Fox from Child Abuse Solutions, Inc. began developing standardized training for court personnel.

A timeline of the mothers’ movement was posted on www.caprotectiveparents.org.
Meanwhile, Bob Geffner and his student interns were also working on protective parent research. One intern was preparing a journal article on the original Stahly national data, one was collecting new surveys for an updated research study with formal approval from the Institutional Review Board (IRB), and one was working on research on reunification camps. They would produce peer-reviewed articles that could be used in court cases.
The following week, the Stahly research was quoted in the Committee analysis for AB 2279, the custody disposition survey, which swept through the Assembly Judiciary Committee without opposition. The Judicial Council killed the bill in the Appropriations Committee by citing a suddenly inflated price tag for a survey.
On May 18, 2022 CA appellate decision A.F. versus Jeffrey F. addressed the issue of an 11-year-old girl filing a restraining order against a parent. The appellate court stated, “A.F. has the right to file a DVRO petition under the DVPA on her own behalf.”
(California Code of Civil Procedure 372(b)(1) states, “Notwithstanding subdivision (a), a minor 12 years of age or older may appear in court without a guardian, counsel, or guardian ad litem, for the purpose of requesting or opposing a request for any of the following: …..(D) A protective order pursuant to Sections 7710 and 7720 of the Family Code.” However, certain criteria apply.)
By June 1, 2022 SB 616 (Rubio), known as Piqui’s Law in commemoration of Ana Estevez’s little boy, began its journey through the California Legislature. On June 27, an emotional press conference was held in Sacramento on the steps of the Capitol. Mothers of murdered children attested to the deadly damage done by uneducated or miseducated court personnel and a deeply flawed system.
Ileana Gutierrez, the mother of the three murdered Sacramento girls, spoke in Spanish, describing her anguish. Even those who did not understand Spanish understood her completely. The next day, AB 616 swept through the Assembly Judiciary Committee 11-0 with 25 or 30 advocates calling in support. But the bill died after powerful opposition.
SB 935 (Min) became law on July 1, to increase the ability of survivors to renew restraining orders for long-term safety.
The newly formed Commission to Review the Operations and Structure of the Commission on Judicial Performance held a public meeting on July 11-12, 2022. At the end of the meeting, Kathleen gave testimony on the lack of judicial accountability, citing Katie Tagle’s case.
“Judge Robert Lemkau had called Katie Tagle a liar when she tried to get a restraining order against her estranged boyfriend, Stephen Garcia, on January 21. Ten days later law enforcement authorities found Garcia and the couple’s 9-month-old son Wyatt shot to death in a car in Twin Peaks in an apparent murder-suicide.”
Kathleen reiterated the need for Judicial Performance Evaluations (JPE), which are basically report cards for judges completed by attorneys, litigants and court staff, as exist in many other states. That idea had been slapped down hard by judges but might have a chance now.
The next year, Senator Rubio authored SB 331 to implement the Violence Against Women Act reauthorization to improve training and block reunification camps.
In late 2022, Maya Laing aged 15 and her brother Sebastian aged 11 were violently taken from their Santa Cruz home by court order to a reunification camp. (Please watch this video with support, as it is very disturbing.) The shocking video made a big impact on the community and the state. This time, even more support was garnered.
Sandy Ross of California Protective Parents Association marshalled thousands of victim mothers to educate their Legislators about the conditions in family court where children were being violently treated, ordered back into the violence, re-abused and sometimes killed. It was highly effective.

SB 331 passed into law in October 2023.
That same year, the United Nations Special Rapporteur Reem Alsalem reported that family court systems worldwide are being impacted by “deeply embedded gender bias,” which is leaving women and children vulnerable to violence and “immense suffering.”
In February 2025, California Protective Parents Association honored the many heroes who brought SB 331 to fruition. Sandy Ross brought legislators, advocates, law enforcement, educators, protective mothers and their children together. Piqui’s Law Celebration was a great success.
In New Jersey on April 21, 2025, a young woman was able to protect her younger sibling from being forced to live with their abusive father by going public. Courtney Tamagny’s extraordinary podcast Molested by my Father, the Chief of Police: Satanic Ritual Abuse has garnered national attention. Her sibling was protected. Her father remains in his position.
Also in 2025, the Judicial Council conducted a Child Custody Mediation Outcome Study that showed 55-69% of children were living with both parents without supervision even when there were allegations of domestic violence or child abuse, and even when one parent was an adjudicated perpetrator. Since only judges can make final custody dispositions, we hope the survey will reflect actual judicial outcomes.
Family Code section 1850(b) requiring custody disposition surveys was put in place by CA NOW over a decade earlier. Legislative director Jodi Hicks had told us about the section, which gave much needed government outcome data and would be an oversight mechanism. We could now tell if our new laws were making a difference.

While researching Congressional Oversight Hearings recommended by the 2018 Congressional Resolution H. Con. Res. 72, I happened across the June 30, 2026 GOP Oversight Task Force hearing Mind Control and Accountability: Uncovering the Truth of the CIA’s MKULTRA Project.
The hearing was “focused on the CIA’s MKUltra program, a covert mind control and human experimentation project active primarily in the 1950s and 1960s. Witnesses detailed the program’s extensive abuses, including non-consensual drug experiments, psychological torture, and destruction of records ordered by CIA leadership to conceal evidence.”
“The hearing highlighted the lack of prosecutions or victim compensation, the involvement of numerous institutions and researchers, and the potential continuation of similar programs today. Discussions also touched on related covert operations, the role of Nazi scientists brought to the U.S., and the challenges of obtaining full declassification of documents. The committee expressed intent to pursue further investigation, including newly discovered MKUltra files and potential foreign sites of experimentation, emphasizing the need for accountability and transparency.”
Fifty years after the first hearings, Congress was focusing again on that chilling program, which some speakers thought might still be going on in secret. That would be no surprise.
Also in 2026, The Family Violence Appellate Project (FVAP) won a groundbreaking lawsuit Family Violence Appellate Project et. al. v. Superior Court of Contra Costa in the California Supreme Court that orders the use of electronic recording when court reporters are unavailable. This would make a huge difference, as parents with a record of hearing can appeal.
The arc of the moral universe moved slightly towards the side of justice. It seemed impossible that it took at least four decades for such a commonsense solution to arrive.
On October 4, 2026, advocate Sandy Ross put together a beautiful retrospective of our Mothers Movement titled The Heart of a Movement.
We had come a long way, but the problem has not yet been solved. There was still much to do, but no longer were we banging on the door with our almost unbelievable stories of abused children whose parents are in custody disputes being placed in harm’s way. The issue was mainstream now, like domestic violence was 30 years ago.
It had been thirty years since Karen Anderson and I started this heart-breaking trek, beginning with tearful conversations, then letters, meetings, workshops, task forces, road trips, and plane rides, and finally demonstrations, resolutions and better laws. Yet the system was still working for abusers. We wondered again why it was so hard to make the changes we sought, to simply keep children safe from beatings and rapes. We realized the patriarchy still protects men, not women and children. We also know this can change.
Two generations of children had grown to adulthood since Phyllis Chesler began to family court in the 1970s, and said, “Barefoot and weaponless, the mothers fight on.”
“Barefoot and weaponless, the mothers fight on.”
We will never stop until the children are safe from violence and sexual abuse. We live by the saying, “First they ignore us. Then they laugh at us. Then they fight us. Then… we win.”