Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 10: So Much to Learn

“Simply stated, it is sagacious to eschew obfuscation.”

Norman Ralph Augustine

I felt like I had dropped into a Dr. Seuss book, learning strange new words and acronyms, along with secret staircases and passages in the California Capitol and tunnels in the US Capitol. Kathleen and Steve from Center for Judicial Excellence discovered “Sub 5”, Legislative code for the Assembly Budget Subcommittee Number 5. We met with the staff member who oversaw the Commission on Judicial Performance budget and found out about an oversight hearing on Judicial Accountability.

It was a whole new world.

The Vice Chair of Assembly Judiciary Committee Donald Wagner had authored AB 1834, to have court reporters or electronic recording in family courts. It was sponsored by the Conference of California Bar Association. They had been listening to us after all. But AB 1834 died an early death in committee

The history went all the way back in 1982 according to the Assembly Judiciary Bill Analysis on March 21, 2016. We did not know that labor unions had previously blocked at least 14 past bills for electronic recordings.  It was quite shocking, especially hard for me, a strong supporter and union member, to know that labor had been holding self-represented litigants hostage for decades.  Self-represented litigants were especially vulnerable as they had little money to hire attorneys, much less a court reporter.

We did not know that labor unions had previously blocked at least 14 past bills for electronic recordings.

This was clearly a major scandal in California, but the press had not made an issue of it.

Kathleen Russell documented the extreme difference between California and three other states in the number of investigations (Texas 2,636 v CA 715) and the cost per inquiry (Texas $181 v CA $2,933).

It was quite helpful and made it clear that change was needed in the disciplining of judges. Complaints, dispositions and currently private admonishments needed to be public.

We homed in on committee members and started methodically meeting with their staff members. I kept spreadsheets of the meetings and names and numbers.

Kathleen pointed out again that California received an “F” in Judicial Accountability from the Center for Public Integrity because we did not have laws to require judges to:

  1. Give reasons for their decisions.
  2. Have their performance evaluated.
  3. Have their asset forms audited.
  4. Restrict their entrance into the public sector.
  5. Prohibit nepotism, cronyism and patronage in hiring judicial staff.

California received an “F” in Judicial Accountability from the Center for Public Integrity

Assemblyman Maienschein introduced AB 2098 to lower the age to seven for children to have the right to speak to the judge directly if they wished. Our opposition, the Association of Certified Family Law Specialists (FLEXCOM) weighed in against it.  We moved the age up to 10, but the opposition still pressed forward.

AB 2569 (Melendez) was introduced to keep sex offenders who are family members on Megan’s List. I testified as a survivor, explaining that I was used as bait, a lure for my little friends to be abused when I was a child.

Both bills died in committee. A theme was developing. Were our bills dead on arrival (DOA)? Was the abuser lobby that powerful?

We wrote to Marty Baron, now Editor of the Washington Post to try to interest him in a series on family courts placing children with their identified sex offenders just as he did at the Boston Globe and the pedophile priests, as depicted in the movie Spotlight.

Nothing.

We asked the Judicial Council to issue a policy directive stating that safety is the first and highest priority in all custody decisions. We asked for:

  • An Advisory Committee on Litigant Safety.
  • A statewide study of children taken from safe parents and given to abusers.
  • A record of all hearings in family courts.
  • Domestic violence advocates and valid research.
  • Victim impact statements in training.
  • An end to CCRCs who did not have the requisite qualifications and training.
  • A form to implement Family Code section 3118.
  • Pre-trial assessment screening in domestic violence cases.

We asked the Chief Justice to make sure the playing field was level when one litigant had an attorney and the other did not, as was clearly stated in Family Code section 2030(a).

“In a proceeding for dissolution of marriage, nullity of marriage, or legal separation of the parties, and in any proceeding subsequent to entry of a related judgment, the court shall ensure that each party has access to legal representation, including access early in the proceedings, to preserve each party’s rights by ordering, if necessary based on the income and needs assessments, one party, except a governmental entity, to pay to the other party, or to the other party’s attorney, whatever amount is reasonably necessary for attorney’s fees and for the cost of maintaining or defending the proceeding during the pendency of the proceeding”

It was clear.  It even said “shall.”

Nothing. Was it because custody and visitation were not specifically mentioned?

The irony was that the month before, in a presentation in Yolo County, the Chief Justice had related a story about her own mother who went up against the Redevelopment Agency and lost their home because she had no attorney. It created in the Chief Justice a desire to become an attorney.

Sex crimes against children abounded. In California, 238 people were arrested in a suspected child sex predator sting operation in April and May 2016, thanks to the Los Angeles Police Department’s Internet Crimes Against Children (ICAC) “Operation Broken Heart III.”

Entertainers, community leaders, white-collar professionals and clergy members, including a monk from Riverside and an Australian geneticist rugby player, were among those snagged by the LA Police Department’s ICAC unit, which serves a new warrant nearly every work day. 

Entertainers, community leaders, white- collar professionals and clergy members … were among those snagged by the LA Police Department’s ICAC unit

The  Canadian Centre for Child Protection, Inc. had released Sexual Abuse Images on the Internet of over 150,000 reports of child pornography in January 2016. Nearly 80% of images were of children under 12, nearly 7% were toddlers and babies. It was chilling to learn that nearly 70% of the sexual abuse images appeared to be taken in a home setting. 

It was chilling to learn that nearly 70% of the sexual abuse images appeared to be taken in a home setting. 

There were bright spots. One good piece of news was that  SB 813 (Leyva) made it through the 2016 California Legislative sausage-making gauntlet. The Legislative Digest stated in part, “This bill would allow the prosecution of rape, sodomy, lewd or lascivious acts, continuous sexual abuse of a child, oral copulation, and sexual penetration, that are committed under certain circumstances, as specified, to be commenced at any time.” As I understood the new law, children raped on January 1, 2017 or after could have that crime prosecuted at any point in time in their lives. That was a very good thing.

woman in blue coat smiling

A California appellate ruling People v Sanchez 63 Cal. 4th 665 put a crimp in California evaluators’ style by ruling that experts can still testify regarding their general knowledge in their field of expertise, but not make case specific statements.  This proved to be very helpful in getting reports by expert custody evaluators who were appointed under Evidence Code section 730 thrown out. The Family Violence Appellate Project attorneys were doing a terrific job whenever they could get a case with transcripts.

Family Violence Appellate Project  logo

Back we went to Washington DC on May 9, 2016 for our sixth Mothers of Lost Children Mothers Day demonstration at the White House. It rained again. We had umbrellas and our favorite banners. The secret service was there. They were wearing black raincoats. The guards stared at us from the rooftop.  We tried to explain to passersby why we were there, why batterers were getting custody. The most easily understood answer was “money.” 

We were delighted Mo Hannah brought the Eleventh Battered Mothers Custody Conference (BMCC) to Washington DC again. It helped so much in our lobbying efforts to have lots of mothers and advocates in the locus of power.

I spoke as a survivor at the BMCC, telling my story on resilience, to give protective mothers who lost their children a small ray of hope. We handed out the ACE survey and the companion Resilience checklist. All the items in the lists were about personal connections. Relationships were critical, both for good and for bad.

I wondered again why family courts worked so hard to break the children’s bond with their safe, nurturing primary mothers. Did they realize they could create a societal time bomb of generations of children whose abuse might turn them into angry, violent and unattached adults one day? Did they not care? Or worse, did they know it and continued doing so anyway?

That thought was even more than chilling, as was the thought it was deliberate.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.