“The most dangerous man to any government is the man who is able to think things out for himself.”
H. L. Mencken
One of Professor Geraldine Stahly’s interns, Nancy Steubner, wrote her Master’s Degree thesis on Custody Outcomes for Protective Parents in Cases with Child Sexual Abuse based on the Stahly data of 399 cases.
She found that domestic violence plus bankruptcy led to loss of custody. Batterers instinctively know this equation and often take their victims to court over and over until they run out of money, then go in for custody. Her research also showed that another recipe for disaster was being a battered woman reporting abuse of her child. Only 7% of those children were protected.
Another recipe for disaster was being a battered woman reporting abuse of her child. Only 7% of those children were protected.
In August 2011, our new California Attorney General Kamala Harris learned first-hand about the family court crisis. Her Deputy Attorney General Marcia Fay suffered the ultimate loss when her 2-year-old daughter Madeline Samaan-Fay and her father Mourad ‘Moni’ Samaan were found dead on August 14 in a remote Grizzly Flats section of El Dorado County, CA, near Sacramento. The toddler had two gunshot wounds; the father died of a single self-inflicted gunshot wound.
The father had disappeared with the child a week before. Sacramento Judge Peter McBrien had refused on August 2 to grant Marcia Fay’s ex parte request to order law enforcement to locate the father when he did not return little Madeline. He also refused to order the father to be placed on supervised visits.

Although she did not answer our letter pointing out that the case was not an isolated instance, by January 2015, Attorney General Harris had launched the Bureau of Children’s Justice within the California Department of Justice to focus on crimes against children. This was heartening news.
We later met with the Bureau staff in Los Angeles and found they were focused exclusively on CPS and foster care. Attorney Julia Weng Gutierrez said, out loud, that family court was merely a “he said-she said” situation.
It seemed she saw victim children of divorce as just a by-product of jockeying for custody, and the courts seemed to feel helpless to determine whether or not a child was being abused. They assumed both parents were fit parents, and the allegations were not real.
Our team, which included Judge DeAnn Salcido and several protective mothers, was quite persuasive. The attorney was visibly rattled and seemed to believe us, at least for the moment.
But nothing happened.
We met with the CA Partnership to End Domestic Violence (CPEDV) in August 2011. They agreed specialized domestic violence courts would be the best option. Maybe specialized judges could be better trained than judicial officers who were generalists. At the very least, it would be easier to keep an eye on a single court through a court watch program, rather than cases that were spread all over city courthouses.
We drove to San Diego to the National Partnership to End Interpersonal Violence (NPEIV) Think Tank meeting on September 10, 2011. The Public Policy breakout with Wendy Murphy, Eileen King, Carolyn Placente, Rita Smith, Joyce Thomas, Billie Wiess, Glenna Tinney was great, but there was no clear plan for moving forward. No one really knew how to proceed.
We asked NPEIV to help create policies to:
- Make family court their highest priority.
- Begin a Second Look Commission to review extreme cases.
- Create specialized domestic violence courts.
- Legislate that child physical and sexual safety is our national policy.
- Work toward getting Congressional Oversight Hearings.
We sadly had to bow out of the San Diego IVAT conference, where we had gone every September for so many years, and had met wonderful advocates and professionals versed in trauma. Ever since IVAT combined with Alliant University, there were more workshops by men’s rights groups. IVAT had given an even bigger place that year to John Hamel LCSW, a San Rafael based expert witness who insisted women are more violent than men. I had to explain that survivors did not feel safe there. It was a big loss for us.
Another loss included the California Commission on the Status of Women, our staunch ally. Established in 1965, it had become a permanent state agency in 1971, then was defunded in 2012 during the recession. It was refunded in 2013 under new leadership that was not interested in our issue.
Juvenile court referee Daniel Horton was caught by police in a sting operation for sexually abusing children. He was later convicted and given a slap on the wrist. This revealed a broader pedophile-friendly situation than just family court. Still restless for action, we had started picketing once a month at the Sacramento courthouse, first at the family court, then at the downtown courthouse.
One day, we demonstrated for 1 ½ hours in front of the Sacramento main courthouse and took a booklet of cases to Presiding Judge Steve White and to Attorney General Kamala Harris.
Marivic got us tickets to the San Mateo County Bar Association’ Diversity Committee on September 20, 2011, where our new Chief Justice Tani Cantil-Sakayue was speaking. We met with her.
Actually, we cornered the Chief Justice just before the program began and explained that children were being placed in the custody of their abusers. She already knew that. It was an open secret.
Actually, we cornered the Chief Justice just before the program began and explained that children were being placed in the custody of their abusers. She already knew that.
She referred us to the Judicial Council Domestic Violence Task Force which she had previously led. This was much different from the Elkins Family Law Task Force. She, an appellate attorney, had also been on the Judicial Council. She was very funny and down to earth, and seemed to be a normal, compassionate woman. She said a Presiding Judge once yelled at her for saying domestic violence was a crime. She had to overcome her natural quiet and learn to talk over the opposition.
We felt hope again.
I talked to the Judicial Council to arrange a presentation to the Judicial Council Domestic Violence Task Force, as the Chief Justice suggested.
That year, Janice Levinson and Lundy Bancroft began Protective Mothers Alliance International on the East Coast to bring about change in family court through education, legislation reform, community outreach and enforcement of current legislation to stop granting custody and unsupervised contact of children to abusers. They were both great advocates.

Our wonderful East Coast ally Eileen King alerted us to two back-to-back Congressional briefings. The first one had been organized by two groups we knew nothing about, the Congressional Victims’ Rights Caucus and Witness Justice.
We flew to Washington DC and on October 10, 2011, a few of us demonstrated at the White House from 11:00 to 1:00.
The next day, we went to the first Congressional briefing titled Addressing the Mental Health Effects of Violence and Trauma on Children, put on by the Victims’ Rights Caucus led by Congress members Ted Poe and Jim Costa, and Witness Justice led by advocate Helga Leust.

Elizabeth Hudson and the federal U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (USDHHS) Commissioner Bryan Samuels spoke about funding. Family court was noted in the written documents but was not mentioned in the presentations. At least the subject had been opened that children were adversely affected by family violence.
We tried to speak with the US DHHS staff afterwards, but they were in a hurry to go to their next appointment. So, we walked over to their headquarters building the next day and demonstrated along with domestic violence advocate Sandra Ramos and her team.
Then we met with Andy Flick, Congressman Jim Costa’s new aide and Blair Bjellos, Congressman Ted Poe’s aide, from the Victims’ Rights Caucus to give them information about the placement of children with abusers by family courts and what we thought the federal government could do about this civil rights violation.
They were sympathetic and seemed interested in solutions.