“I have not failed. I’ve just found 10,000 ways that won’t work.”
Thomas A. Edison
The next day, on October 12, we went to the first ever Congressional briefing on the specific damaging effects of childhood exposure to domestic violence titled Effects of Domestic Violence on Children. This large event from 10 to noon in the Rayburn building was put on by National Coalition Against Domestic Violence (NCADV) and Makers of Memories, later called Children of Domestic Violence, founded by Brian Martin in 2007 to focus specifically on children of domestic violence.
NCADV is a large, potent and well-funded organization. They had skilled lobbyists and relationships with Congress members. They had organized this very first briefing which gave the subject of children harmed by domestic violence much more gravity than our small unfunded groups could have.
They brilliantly brought the children of divorce subject into the center of the conference by including an organization founded by a good man Brian Martin. In October 2012 Makers of Memories was renamed Childhood Domestic Violence Association, the year they released their film 43 Million Secrets, re-titled The Children Next Door.

It was thrilling to hear these issues being spoken out loud in Congress. About 30 staffers attended. One panel included Courageous Kids Jennifer and Ariel who were now adults. Another panel included Anne Hoyer, daughter of Majority Leader Steny Hoyer, who had her own family court case. Congress members Sheila Jackson and Gwen Moore spoke.
For a change, the father’s rights people were outside this time, yelling in the hall, which was peculiarly satisfying.
The unplanned speaker was Congressman John Conyers who recommended Congressional Oversight Hearings.
“Congressional Oversight hearings review or study a law, issue or an activity, often focusing on the quality of federal programs and of government officials. Hearings also help ensure that the execution of laws by the executive branch complies with legislative intent, and that administrative policies reflect the public interest. Oversight hearings often seek to improve the efficiency, economy and effectiveness of government operations.”
That was exactly what we needed. We talked with Congressman Conyer’s staff and sent follow up letters, to no avail. All that was required was to reschedule the twice postponed Congressional hearings from 1994 and 1995. A Congressional Oversight Hearing is a much bigger production than a briefing, and we were told that we needed to have a federal bill already prepared in advance to submit after a Hearing. We had zero idea how to write federal legislation. We were not there yet.
An article appeared in the Washington Post on October 28, 2011, titled Predicting and Preventing Murder describing the dramatic drop by half of Maryland domestic violence homicides. This was largely due to the use of a lethality assessment used by first responders in fourteen states and Washington DC. The questions are focused on husbands or boyfriends since 85% of victims are women. The questions are similar to those in the Danger Assessment developed by Jacquelyn Campbell, PhD and reported on during the previous decade by numerous agencies.
- Has he threatened/used a weapon?
- Has he threatened to kill her/children?
- Does she think he might try to kill her?
- Does he have access to a gun?
- Has he tried to choke/strangle her?
- Is he violently/constantly jealous/controlling?
- Did she leave/separate from him?
- Is he unemployed?
- Has he tried to kill himself?
- Is there a child that is not his in the home?
- Has he followed/spied on her or left threatening messages?
This list of factors would help.
We figured if a man is dangerous enough to kill his wife or girlfriend, he is probably not safe around children. Later research by Peter Jaffe, PhD showed that was a correct assumption.

The danger assessment came to California piecemeal. The Judicial Council’s Domestic Violence Practice and Procedure Task Force issued their final report Recommended Guidelines and Practices for Improving the Administration of Justice in Domestic Violence Cases in January 2008, and later, developed and reviewed the Bench Guide for Recognizing Dangerousness in Domestic Violence Cases by Jacquelyn C. Campbell, PhD, RN and Hon. Sharon A. Chatman, Santa Clara Superior Court. Law enforcement was required to include training for danger assessments through SB 1331 (Jackson) in 2018.
We hoped it would help by providing more evidence for domestic violence survivors. But the underlying problem was that California family courts mediated cases of violence, so the evidence was never presented.
On November 1, 2011, Karen Anderson, Jessica Lenahan Gonzales and I drove to San Francisco for lunch with Monica Arenas from Futures Without Violence, based on the beautiful former Presidio military facility. Kathleen Russell and Carolyn Placente from the Center for Judicial Excellence, protective mother Jessica and I presented to the California Judicial Council Administrative Office of the Courts.
Jessica talked about the early buildup of tension and domestic violence, the set up by family court, and a protective order that did not cover her children, which led to their deaths. Everyone stayed for a half hour afterwards to talk. Even Judge Len Edwards was there, who was an enigma to us, sometimes landing on the right side of an issue, and sometimes not. They kept deferring to us to make something happen. That seemed odd. Certainly, court administrators and the Chief Justice could institute reforms.
The good news was that AB 1050 had created a sea change by letting children 14 and over talk directly to the court. That was satisfying.
Karen Anderson, Kathleen Russell, Carolyn Placente, Kim Robinson and I met with Julia Weber and Bobbie Welling from Judicial Council on November 17 regarding a template to implement Family Code 3118 protocol. Julia said they would get a meeting with the Board of Psychology and Board of Behavioral Science. She said the Chief Justice didn’t send directives, but that a Child Safety Task Force might work.
Kim explained that juvenile court trumped family court for child protection. Some clever attorneys had gotten cases of children placed with abusers by family court moved over to juvenile court jurisdiction. It is a completely different silo. The children became “wards of the court,” meaning that they were under the protection of the juvenile court. Then juvenile court placed them with their protective parents in a type of foster care situation. Since the children were wards of the juvenile court, the abuser could not get custody in family court.

But it was a huge gamble, since juvenile courts hold completely closed hearings and records are confidential. This was of grave concern to us, as anything could happen behind closed doors. The concern was that the children could be sent into regular foster care because mothers were accused of not protecting them. It was truly an Orwellian dilemma. But we needed to stay focused on family court silo. There were other advocates trying to fix juvenile courts and open them to the public.
The concern was that the children could be sent into regular foster care because mothers were accused of not protecting them.
I flew to Washington DC again to attend the first U.S. Senate hearing on child sexual abuse on December 13, 2011. The briefing was titled Breaking the Silence on Child Abuse: Protection, Prevention, Intervention and Deterrence.
U.S. Senators Robert Casey and Barbara Mikulski of the Health, Education, Labor and Pension (HELP) Committee, subcommittee on Children and Families were addressing the Penn State child sexual abuse scandal featuring child molester Jerry Sandusky. He was the assistant coach at Penn State University who was convicted of sexual abusing young boys. He accessed the children through his non-profit The Second Mile serving underprivileged and at-risk youth.
California Senator Barbara Boxer testified, along with Senators Mikulski, a former social worker, Burr, Casey, Blumenthal (PA), and Franken. There was a panel describing the problem. Sheldon Kennedy, hockey player and Sandusky victim, and a representative from the National Center for Missing and Exploited Center (NCMEC) testified. There was a panel for solutions. The head of American Academy of Pediatrics, the Minnesota Welfare Assistant Director and the Director of Child Advocacy Multi-Disciplinary Interview Team (MDIT) all testified.
We talked again to Senator Boxer’s aide Patrick, who paid a bit more attention to us that year. I followed up with letters to the Senators who had spoken on the panel about children of divorce being placed with abusers, giving the following recommendations:
- Articulate an overarching policy that child physical and sexual safety as highest priority.
- Establish an Office of Violence Against Children focused on child physical/sexual safety.
- Increase the scope of the Office of Violence Against Women for protection of children.
- Schedule Senate oversight hearings for collusion/racketeering in family court.
- Ensure that all reports of physical or sexual crimes are made to law enforcement first for proper investigation.
- Ensure children are never given unsupervised contact with sex offenders.
- Fully fund the Internet Crimes Against Children (ICAC) teams.
- Fund a national ongoing media campaign to stop violence against children.
- Create a national program to provide adult and child victims with new identities.
- Create a national Citizen Oversight Committee to review cases of children placed at risk.
- Disconnect child support from parenting time, to remove perverse financial incentives for requesting custody and parenting time.
- Replace the Fatherhood Initiative with a National Safe Parenting Skills training program.
- Develop a national database to track children through multiple agencies.
We also suggested withholding Federal dollars from any state that does not:
- Eliminate the statute of limitations for child sex abuse.
- For cases without abuse allegations, parenting time replicates pre-separation.
- Implement integrated domestic violence courts in every county.
- Implement multidisciplinary interview centers in every county.
- Develop a national standard report for abuse investigation data collection.
- Ensure both parents have attorneys if one parent has an attorney.
- Implement videotaping in family court hearings and provide tapes at low cost.
- Provide litigants no-cost administrative hearing for due process violations.
- Create a state Citizen Review Board to hear cases of retaliation.
Nothing.
Not even a “thank you for sharing.”