Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 10: Other Silos

“Children do learn what they live. Then they grow up to live what they’ve learned.”

Dorothy Nolte

On February 17, 2005, California Senator Deborah Ortiz authored SB 359 to require supervised visitation when the court is made aware of evidence of risk to a child or domestic violence and prohibit unsupervised visitation to a parent who has a felony conviction of a lewd or lascivious act on a child.  The bill died in committee with no explanation.

We started a Child Custody Task Force to develop policy for California and met on July 22, 2005 with other professionals:  attorney Meera Fox, lobbyist Melissa Knight Fine, attorney Cynthia Spencer of Charter Legal Services for Children, and law professor Nancy Lemon from Boalt Law School on the phone. Jodi Hicks from CA NOW joined later, as did activist and comedian Betsy Salkind. Judge Eugene Hyman from Santa Clara, UCD law professor Carol Bruch, attorneys Janet Bowermaster and Joanne Schulman, Office of Victim Services attorney Jonathan Raven, University of Pacific law professor John Myers, and advocate Tasha Amador were our advisory board. 

Melissa explained that a successful bill has a specific focus and uses a single simple case, with clear legislative intent, unequivocal and short.

A successful bill has a specific focus and uses a single simple case, with clear legislative intent, unequivocal and short.

We started working on ideas:

  1. Adopt the approximation/primary caretaker standard for non-abuse disputed custody cases. When there are allegations of violence or sexual crimes, ensure custody is with the safe parent, with only supervised visits for the dangerous parent.
  2. Replace FC 1800 with a unified family violence court focused on victim protection. Uniformly train Judges/court professionals on domestic violence, child abuse, substance abuse.  Replace evaluators with local/regional multidisciplinary teams.
  3. Ensure that a standard template is completed by each team member and reviewed/corrected by all parties before submission to the court. (Until then, appoint evaluators only under CA FC 3118, not Evidence Code 730, paid by the court, who are recognized experts in the subject they are evaluating.) 
  4. Legislate children’s rights
    • Children are parties to the family law case, like juvenile court, and their wishes must be obtained.
    • Prima facie evidence of need for safety shall include a child’s disclosure of a violent/sexual crime to a mandated reporter or a domestic violence restraining order against a violent parent.
    • At age 12, children may choose their own safe custody/visit plan, if they wish. If they choose to unsupervised contact with the identified offender, a multi-disciplinary team of district attorney, law enforcement, child protection services, domestic violence agency must investigate and individually agree in writing that the child would be safe with that parent.
    • The child’s attorney owes the same duty to the child as for an adult client and can be removed by the child. The attorney’s appointment is limited in time, reviewed quarterly, paid by the court.
    • Strengthen emancipation ability of children who are runaways fleeing violence or sexual abuse.
  5. Due process and oversight
    • Court must make findings on the record for all hearings.
    • Prohibit ex parte contacts
    • Prohibit custody reversal in an ex parte hearing
    • Create a state multidisciplinary citizen review panel able to reverse risky custody placement
    • Have customer satisfaction surveys, and make them public every year for all counties and states
    • Amend CA Government Code 821.6 for judicial accountability
    • Amend CA Family Code 3027.5 so sexually abused children are safe; delete “solely”. 
    • Amend the CA code for rebuttable presumption so it is not so easy to rebut
    • Ensure courts do not order witness tampering

On September 6, 2005, California Chief Justice Ronald M. George appointed the Judicial Council Domestic Violence Practice and Procedure Task Force to recommend improvements to court practice and procedure in cases involving domestic violence allegations. The Honorable Tani Gorre Cantil-Sakauye Associate Justice of the Court of Appeal, Third Appellate District was on the Task Force. 

The final report and recommended guidelines came out in January 2008.  It focused on criminal trials, which didn’t help us unless law enforcement took a case forward. Even then, when the batterer emerged from jail or prison, he (rarely if ever “she”) would usually get unsupervised visits or even custody.  

“Hey, why don’t you guys fix Child Protective Services?”

“Maybe after we fix family court, but that’s turning out to be a whole lot harder than we ever imagined.”

Plus, I knew practically nothing about the juvenile court silo, except that it interacted incredibly poorly with the family court silo we were focused on. Child welfare services had shifted in 1980 from child protection to family preservation, because so many children were in foster care. Child welfare was quite different from child protection. 

Child welfare services (CWS) is an entirely separate hierarchy with a plethora of rules to follow. I decided to try to follow the money trail. State child welfare agencies spend about $30 billion a year for the safety, permanency and well-being of abused or neglected children. The money comes from a wildly complicated bureaucratic web of federal, state and local sources. A little over half comes from state and local funds, and somewhat less than half comes from the federal government. It was all very confusing. My mind boggled. 

little girl shrugging
  • Federal funds come mainly from the Social Security Act (Titles IV B and E) which is handled by the House Ways and Means and Senate Finance committees.
  • Other funds come from the federal Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act (CAPTA) handled by the House Education and Workforce and the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions committees.
  • Other funds come from the Victims of Crime Act (VOCA) handled by the House and Senate Judiciary committees.

Our taxpayer dollars pass through multiple administrative hands, each receiving their fair share.

  • The US Department of Health and Human Services, Administration of Children and Families, Office of Children’s Bureau administers and oversees state child welfare programs. 
  • In California, the state Department of Social Services sends funds to county agencies.
  • County agencies administer direct services.
  • CA Welfare and Information Code governs juvenile courts to ensure due process and make orders. Juvenile delinquency (minors charged with a crime) and dependency (minors who are abused or neglected) are governed by different sections of the code and rules of court.

County agencies, which are called by various names just to add to the confusion, employ underpaid, overworked, sometimes case-hardened social workers who then make the hard front-line decisions. There’s an understandable high turnover.

This was making me dizzy. 

The first decision of the agency is whether to “screen out” or “evaluate out” a referral. Referrals that make it through the first gate are investigated. The case comes to a next juncture, “case disposition.” Allegations are substantiated (victim), unsubstantiated (not sure) or unfounded (untrue).  

  • In 1998, there were 2.8 million referrals. 34% were screened out. 903,000 were substantiated. 
  • In 2018, there were 4.3 million referrals. 44% were screened out. 678,000 were substantiated.

There was a massive increase in referrals, yet fewer children were considered victims. What?  The system began swallowing a camel and straining out a gnat over two decades.

The system began swallowing a camel and straining out a gnat over two decades.

Even the percentage of physically and sexually abused children shrank.

  • In 1998, 53.5% were neglected. 22.7% were physically abused. 11.5% were sexually abused.
  • In 2018, 60.8% were neglected. 10.7% were physically abused.   7% were sexually abused.

What was going on? A social worker explained to me that they were coding abused children as “neglected” more often because it was easier to prove. On the one hand, we have to credit social workers for that work-around, if it led to protecting kids.

A social worker explained to me that they were coding abused children as “neglected” more often because it was easier to prove.

But that designation skewed the rate of physical and sexual abuse. Adults reported that rate of both childhood physical and sexual abuse was nearly three times as high as was being shown by government data. This was a huge disconnect. 

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.