Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 11: Juvenile Court

“The mark of a great society is how it treats its most vulnerable members.”

Mahatma Gandhi

The next question was what happens to the small minority of children who are deemed actual victims? An order must be signed by a judge to remove a child from a dangerous, neglectful home into foster care, rather than providing services to hopefully keep the parents from seriously injuring or killing the child. Subordinate judicial officers called “referees” often adjudicate these cases in California’s juvenile courts. They seem to have no special qualifications or training that I could discern.

little boy in suit in court room

At one point we were asked to consider a recommendation by two concerned attorneys to ask the Legislature to move child abuse cases from family court where children are treated more or less like property to juvenile court where they are supposed to be treated like human beings. 

Juvenile court does have benefits. It is focused on child abuse and neglect. Children and parents have attorneys. That could be a good thing depending on the quality of the attorney. 

One clever family law attorney said he would get the abused children moved over to juvenile court when family court had put them with a perpetrator, then have juvenile court place them with the safe parent. He had to stay on top of the situation, so the child didn’t get swallowed up into a foster care vortex. He maintained close relationships with social workers.

But the downside was just too scary. It would move children from the frying pan to the fire. Juvenile courts are nearly all closed to the public. Years later, Assemblyman Mike Feuer, who had opposed our attempt to get rid of junk science, did a good thing by authoring AB 73 which would have created pilot programs with open juvenile courts. The bill failed even though Los Angeles Judge Nash had found no downside when he tried opening his juvenile courtroom.

Citizens have zero way to pierce the darkness.  There is no effective appellate process.  Terrible things can and do happen in juvenile courts. Other family and juvenile attorneys agreed with us that juvenile courts were even worse than family courts. How could that be?

If we had not had the searing experience in Josie Cohen’s case, we would not know how badly things could go in juvenile court. Social workers substantiated her son’s sexual abuse over and over, including his father filming his rapes with a camera on a tripod which the child carefully drew for the investigator. When we complained on the child’s behalf to the director, the retaliation was swift and ferocious.  A juvenile court referee put the child in foster care instead of with his safe mother.  He was there for a year and a half.

The District Attorney (DA) refused to prosecute the case, despite urging from a Deputy DA. Law enforcement coverup was total, even after this brave kid called 911 on his own from his father’s house.

After he was returned to watch his mother die, the boy was snatched away from his beloved grandmother by another social worker because she would not say she would facilitate a loving relationship between the boy and his child rapist father. The eight-year-old resisted valiantly, but was carried away, flailing and kicking, by two large, uniformed policemen.  He was put back into foster care and, shortly afterwards, with the approval of juvenile court, turned over to his substantiated sex offender. 

The institutional betrayals were clear on every level. One person thought his father might have been a protected snitch. There were inklings of ritual abuse in the case.   It was another deadly game of Russian Roulette.

Former Texas prosecutor Randy Burton from Justice for Children has a way with words.

Former Texas prosecutor Randy Burton from Justice for Children

In the book The Women of Court Watch, he stated, “When a child is left in a ‘home’ with their abusive parents by CPS, it is like incarcerating them with their offender. They cannot escape…. And, our government is a passive co-conspirator.”

He went on. “So why would conscious decisions be made to send little children back into these hellish environments? The answer is a little-known concept that drives virtually all CPS and court decisions pertaining to the custody of abused children known as ’family preservation.’  Family preservation can be traced back to the earliest roots of our child-welfare establishment, where it was stated that it is ‘better to save the home from the child than to save the child from the home.’ This well-intentioned policy has been the goal of all CPS decisions making for a century…”

Protective parents whose children reveal physical or sexual abuse often call CWS first. They think the agency protects children and have no idea it primarily focuses on family preservation. CWS is less than helpful in family law cases. The mother’s referral is either evaluated out (no reason given), or a flurry of activity ensues. Multiple interviews occur, including with the identified offender which some call “trampling on the crime scene,” giving the illusion of action.

But when the mother has nowhere to go or does not leave the home immediately, a social worker can swoop in and take the child to foster care for failure to protect. This, ironically, is even though the agency is busily reuniting foster children with their intact families who are not risk free. 

kid in court

Law enforcement is less than interested. Sometimes there a required cross report to law enforcement, then a slight shrug of the shoulders.  Hard to know. Custody case.  Everything is ok. Mother has custody. We don’t have jurisdiction. Didn’t meet the criteria to protect. Unsubstantiated. Case closed. Custody case noted. Cross-referral to CWS. No criminal case opened.  Not enough evidence to convict. Case closed.

Didn’t meet the criteria to protect. Unsubstantiated. Not enough evidence to convict. Case closed.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.