“I know exactly what my das’s doing. He’s using me as a bullet to kill you.”
Ten-year-old boy to his protective mother
Annalise Rice, a child who had been taken from her mother and forced to live with her abusive father in Minnesota, filed a lawsuit on May 5, 2017, stating that family court violated her due process rights and used pseudo-science to do it. The lawsuit stated in part that Annalise and her siblings were prohibited from testifying on her own behalf in order to obtain protection from the abuse. Mike Volpe covered the story. The lawsuit seemed to go nowhere. That was most discouraging.
On May 11, the Washington Post Magazine published an article by Cara Tabachnick titled They Were Taken From Their Mom to Rebond With Their Dad: It Didn’t Go Well. It described the murky underworld of court-ordered reunification camps. In this case, four Virginia children were abruptly awakened in the middle of the night by four burly adults who shuttled them to the airport.
They were flown to a four day “camp” called Family Bridges, incorporated in Mill Valley California in 2014 by Randy Rand Ed.D. The children were to bond with their father at the Larkspur Inn, assisted by Rand, his wife Dierdre Rand and psychiatrist Ed Oklan. The children left their father the day they turned 18 and never returned.
The children left their father the day they turned 18 and never returned.
Kathleen was outraged. Other such camps had sprung up previously. In 2006, Rebecca Bailey Ph.D. started Transitioning Families, trademarked Transitioning Families Therapeutic Reunification Model (TFTRMTM), as “an experiential, educational, solution-focused approach to healing families.” It was based on intervention responses to child abduction developed by the Model Treatment and Services Approaches for Professionals Working with Families of Abducted Children by the Department of Justice.
A 2016 article co-authored by Rebecca Bailey The Transitioning Families Therapeutic Reunification Model in Nonfamilial Abductions described treatment methods for non-family abductions. However, these are children being forced by court order into unwanted contact with a parent they dislike or fear, like prisoners of war or Patty Hearst who became trauma-bonded to her captors in a Stockholm Syndrome state.
Based in Sonoma County, California, with a post office box in Glen Ellen, Rebecca Bailey and her associates state on their website that they use techniques including equine therapy and cooking for 3-5 days. It sounded so benign. The children said it was a frightening ordeal. Another reunification program Turning Points for Families, filed as a New York Domestic Professional Corporation on September 14, 2017, was founded by Linda Gottlieb LMFT. These re-education camps were spreading like toxic wildfires.
Mapping Gender: Shedding Empirical Light on Family Courts’ Treatment of Cases Involving Abuse and Alienation by Joan S. Meier and Sean Dickson was published in May 2017. The researchers studied appellate and trial court opinions with alienation claims and found that when courts believed a mother committed alienation, fathers won almost every time, whether abuse was reported or not.
[W]hen courts believed a mother committed alienation, fathers won almost every time, whether abuse was reported or not.
On May 14, 2017, our annual Mothers of Lost Children Mothers’ Day demonstration was held in Washington DC. The new administration inhabiting the White House frankly scared me, and we had no interest in being arrested, so we did not demonstrate in our usual location. This time we gathered in front of Congress and marched to the Supreme Court, across from the U.S. Capitol, for a speak out. Some of us wore long white skirts which made us look more like the suffragists we so admired. I thought we looked glorious.
We held another Congressional briefing, this one titled Federal Policies That Unintentionally Endanger Children of Divorce: How to Explain the Unexplainable in Room 2148 Rayburn on May 16. Former National Institute of Justice senior analyst Leora Rosen, Ph.D. was the main speaker. She described the pattern and practice of court-ordered child abuse and federal policies that allowed this to happen.

Leora spelled out federal policies that needed changing. Three protective mothers, including Lori Handrahan, and one adult child described their experiences. Marivic Mabanag and Judith Reisman Ph.D. spoke. The day before, Lori had carried a summary of her tragic history, on one page with a picture of her little daughter, along with briefing invitations to Congressional offices, asking them to attend. Staff members arrived. Mothers arrived. We gained support for the Resolution.
Persistence was our most important weapon in this war against children. We met with Greg Laughlin from Pillsbury Law Firm, who used to be a Texas prosecutor, then a congressman and now our champion, along with his colleague Craig Saperstein. They agreed that having victims appear in person was crucial to put a face to such a counter-intuitive problem. Our mothers were excellent ambassadors. We trained them on the most effective way to present the issue and how to stay on track with key messages.
We generated ideas for potential federal solutions:
- Develop a Division of Children of Domestic Violence within the Office of Violence Against Women and a Child At Risk Classification office in the U.S. Public Health Service.
- Develop a longitudinal reporting system to track all children winding their way through various agencies in their long, perilous journey from danger to safety.
- Provide grants for a standard certification curriculum for court professionals using trauma-informed domestic violence and child abuse experts and valid research.
- Increase grants for coordinated community response to domestic violence, specialized law enforcement units and strict enforcement of all protective orders.
- Provide grants for model programs for children who report abuse to ensure protection orders during the investigation phase. If there is no criminal trial, ensure no contact with the accused until a multidisciplinary team including a domestic violence advocate agrees in writing that the child will be safe in unsupervised contact with the accused.
- Provide grants for model abuse and custody courts, with administrative processes that assess for child safety first, a standardized form for assessing risk and federal oversight
- Redirect grants for Healthy Marriage and Responsible Fatherhood to grants for Positive Parenting (non-violent parenting training) and Home Visitation Programs for prevention.
Knowing that Congressman Poe was not going to run again for Congress in 2018, the lobby team, who knew how to make these things happen, had been carefully working behind the scenes while we were busy demonstrating. Thanks to Joan Meier and Greg Laughlin, our federal Resolution H. Con. Res. 72 was next introduced by New York Congresswoman Carolyn Maloney and former Pennsylvania federal prosecutor Congressman Patrick Meehan on July 24, 2017. It still expressed “the sense of Congress that child safety is the first priority of custody and visitation adjudications.”
Methodically walking from office to office, as literal foot-soldiers of the movement, we found more co-sponsors, including Trent Franks R-AZ, Thomas Souzzi D-NY, Jamie Raskin D-MD, Anna Eshoo D-CA, Jackie Speier D-CA and John Carter R-TX. It was hard but rewarding work.
By then, CA Protective Parents Association had received over 5000 calls and emails from protective parents, of whom six were protective fathers. Four other fathers had called to yell at us. We were unimpressed. By then we knew that 90% of the mothers were domestic violence victims and 90% of children who reported child sex abuse were not protected.
By then Kathleen Russell and the Center for Judicial Excellence had documented 500 child deaths in divorce cases. The child murder data showed that national media accounts of child homicides in the context of divorce or separation has risen on average of one child homicide per week since 2008. The California child body count alone was 59 children killed in the context of custody and separation, and the national count was close to 600.

The Center for Judicial Excellence website posted a link to the 2016 Women’s Aid report, Nineteen Child Homicides that had uncovered details in England and Wales of children killed by perpetrators of domestic abuse. It took 19 child homicides for the British Parliament to begin work on improving the situation.
The report had two overarching recommendations:
- “Further avoidable child deaths must be prevented by putting children first in the family courts – as the legal framework and guidance states.”
- ”There is an urgent need for independent, national oversight into the implementation of Practice Direction 12J – Child Arrangement and Contact Orders: Domestic Violence and Harm”
Kathleen and I wanted a child safety Resolution in California with safety as the highest priority and court reporters in all custody cases, paralleling H. Con. Res. 72. We wanted the Judicial Council to report to the Legislature on family court cases and have a pilot project using best practices. How could anyone argue with such reasonable requests? We wanted children to live, not die.
We kept going to the Judicial Council monthly meetings, telling of increasing atrocities. In July 2017, I again raised the issue of needing attorneys for cases in which one party has an attorney and the other does not. I again pointed out that Family Code section 1850(b) requires a custody disposition survey, but it appears to never have been implemented. Did the Judicial Council not want anyone to know custody outcomes? This was absurd.
Was Judge Basha, who was such a nightmare in dependency court riding roughshod over child safety that the Yolo County Board of Supervisors would remove him from any child case, still sitting on the Judicial Council? And was Judge Lorna Alksne, who had said she would give custody of Cindy Dumas’ son to the father whether he had abused the child or not, still on the Council? Was the Council packed with professionals with a bias against children?
Meanwhile, the Commission on Judicial Performance’s lawsuit to prevent the Bureau of State Audits (BSA) from seeing their records boiled to a head in a San Francisco courtroom on August 17, 2017. Judge Suzanne Ramos Bolanos ultimately ruled that the Commission did not have to release their records for the audit. BSA’s lawyer Myron Moskowitz argued they should and appealed the decision.

We nagged the Legislature, which threatened to reduce the Commission’s budget.
We went to a Board of Psychology meeting in Berkeley to make public comments about the failure to oversee psychologists appointed as custody evaluators. They seemed to think their responsibility for oversight ended at the moment of court appointment and shifted to the court.
We kept pointing out that psychologists do not leave their Ph.D. at the door after court-appointment, and were hired by experts because of their degree, so the Board had responsibility for them.
Our words seemed to fall on deaf ears.