Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 15: Problematic Evaluators

“Expert: a man who makes three correct guesses consecutively.”

Laurence J. Peter

We managed to halt an omnibus Judiciary Committee bill AB 2303 until they removed the clause giving minors’ counsel immunity.  I brought a letter in person to the Deputy Chief Counsel for the Assembly Judiciary Committee stating our objections, and that part was deleted. It was another small Pyrrhic victory.

California family courts continued doing an end run around the requirements for evaluators that were so carefully put in place by Senator Ortiz. Evaluators were still being appointed under a different code section (Evidence Code 730) reserved for experts and therefore technically did not have to follow the protocols that lobbyist Melissa Knight Fine and she had laid out. The psychologists ordered by the court and paid by the parents would order psychological testing, then pathologize the traumatized victim parents.

We lobbied for AB 2893 (Mountjoy) which would make it harder for registered sex offenders to receive custody. Democrats did not like Republican Dennis Mountjoy and were not interested in passing the bill. Members of Incest Survivors Speakers Bureau rallied and walked the halls of the Capitol, pursuing Legislators who were going to vote against it, explaining what a crucial bill this was. Somehow good prevailed and it passed. Some ISSB members became lobbying fans that day. It was exhilarating.

Members of Incest Survivors Speakers Bureau rallied and walked the halls of the Capitol, pursuing Legislators who were going to vote against it, explaining what a crucial bill his was.

On September 6, 2006 AB 2893 was signed into law by Republican Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger. We were invited to the bill-signing ceremony with all the fanfare. We stood on the platform behind the Governor as he signed. The press snapped pictures, and the cameras rolled. We thought surely that would help. The year before, the Governor had signed SB 594 (Torlakson) prohibiting a parent from having custody if that parent resides with a registered sex offender.

Surely children would be protected now.

But the caveat that was forced on Assemblyman Mountjoy on his last days in the Legislature was that the court could still make a finding that there was no risk and still place the child with a registered offender. We couldn’t imagine that would ever be done, but we were again so wrong.

On August 24, 2006, the Marin Independent Journal published an article titled Mom acquitted of abducting child: Ex-Marin woman’s case under close watch by family court critics by Nancy Isles Nation. Protective mother Jonea Rogers was completely exonerated after fleeing with her 3-year-old daughter in August 2000 when social services and law enforcement did not protect the toddler from physical and sexual abuse by her father and grandfather. Her attorney Peter Goodman did an excellent job defending her and the jury did not believe the father’s testimony.  Jonea’s family law attorney Barbara Kauffman said this was a landmark case.

The family law court did not return the child to her mother despite her exoneration.

Jonea Rogers holding painting of her daughter

The Evidentiary Admissibility of Parental Alienation Syndrome: Science, Law, and Policy by Jennifer Hoult was published in the Children’s Legal Rights Journal in June 2006.

An analysis of precedent-setting decisions and law review article referencing Parental Alienation Syndrome found PAS was inadmissible under standards of Frye v United States, Daubert v Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Kumho Tire Company v Carmichael and Rules 702 and 704(b) of the Federal Rules of Evidence.

Richard Gardner MD’s theory of viewing “adult-child sexual contact as benign and beneficial to the reproduction of the species” was exposed. But family courts kept using alienation to deny child abuse. They pivoted to the label “parental alienation,” dropping the “syndrome” part in many cases. Garland Waller made the film Debating Gardner showing the underlying methodology.

…PAS was inadmissible under standards of Frye v United States, Daubert v Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Kumho Tire Company v Carmichael and Rules 702 and 704(b) of the Federal Rules of Evidence.

On August 2, California NOW sent a strong, pointed letter calling for the California members of Congress to initiate a federal investigation into family courts. They recommended the US Government Reform Committee investigate the operation of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Administration of Children and Families’ Access and Visitation and Responsible Fatherhood programs for misuse of funds, encouraging illegal court practices and other fraudulent practices.

California NOW sent a strong, pointed letter calling for the California members of Congress to initiate a federal investigation

They called the crisis in fatherlessness a “false premise” which was responsible for mothers losing custody to their abusers. They named Wade Horn Assistant Secretary of HHS as having a conflict of interests as past president of the National Fatherhood Initiative, which received a $500,000 non-competitive grant shortly after Horn became acting HHS Assistant Secretary. We had known nothing about this and had no idea how to approach such underhanded federal shenanigans.

In 2006, former Oklahoma state legislator and Judge Donald Thompson was convicted and sentenced to four years in prison for using a sexual device almost daily under his black robe and exposing himself during a murder trial of a man accused of shaking a toddler to death. If it had not been so tragic, it would have been high comedy. He did not inspire confidence in two branches of the government. California ex-judge Ronald Kline pled guilty to child pornography and was sentenced to prison in 2007.

After Family Violence and Sexual Assault Institute (FVSAI) changed its name to the Institute on Violence, Abuse and Trauma (IVAT) and joined with Alliant International University, they were linked formally with an institution that offered advanced degrees for psychologists. 

Conference coordinator and FVASI founder Bob Geffner Ph.D. ABN, ABP was an expert in evaluating reports by local family court evaluators and making mincemeat of them. That helped protect children. He hosted other international summits and professional training and edited scholarly journals in his spare time. He had fully supported our ritual abuse workshops against the attack by the False Memory Syndrome Foundation.

But once Alliant became a partner, things shifted at the conferences. They began including “both sides” of the violence debate. We took our quilts again and had a booth. The fathers’ rights folks also had a booth nearby. It was awkward and scary.

Meera Fox from Child Abuse Solutions, Inc. led a professional multi-disciplinary team in 32 hours of training for evaluators and a four-hour judicial training titled Cutting Edge Approaches to High Conflict Custody Cases with the Honorable Sol Gothard. 

the Honorable Sol Gothard

Karen was invited to be the keynote speaker at the Illinois Coalition Against Domestic Violence children’s training in October 2006. Judith Reisman presented on child pornography at the Human Trafficking and Child Abduction conference in Los Angeles.

Family court problems began to appear in major news media. Newsweek published an article Fighting Over the Kids: Battered spouses take aim at a controversial custody strategy by Sarah Childress on  September 25, 2006. Oprah published a story in November 2006 at the very end of her thick glossy edition of Oprah Magazine called Please, Daddy, No by Jan Goodwin about the incest exception and the lack of accountability for incest offenders.

We had such high hopes for Oprah. She is a child sexual abuse survivor herself, and we all had written to her at one point or another.  But she put the baton down after that excellent article and never took up the topic of family court taking children from safe mothers and giving them to sex abuser, to our knowledge. 

Protective mother Cindy Ross got the Fairfax CA Board of Supervisors to approve Resolution 2466 on December 8, 2006, prohibiting the use of Parental Alienation Syndrome.  It was a great symbol, but the theory continued to run rampant. The Board held no sway over the Marin County judges.

Nothing changed.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.