“No army can withstand the strength of an idea whose time has come.”
Victor Hugo
On January 12-14, 2007, a Truth Commission was held at the Fourth Annual Battered Mothers Custody Conference in Albany, New York. It documented the serious injustices suffered by protective mothers within the divorce court system. I was one of the commissioners, along with Chairman Richard Ducote Esq., Nancy Erickson Esq., Barry Goldstein Esq., Eileen King, Patti Jo Newell, Gwen Wright, and Joan Zorza Esq.
The testimony from sixteen non-offending mothers whose children were removed from them and placed with violent, incestuous fathers was excruciatingly stark. Karen was one of the mothers who testified. She and the others were articulate, describing the tragedies that ripped their lives apart, as their small, abused children were ripped from their arms and given to violent, incestuous fathers.

We wrote up the common themes and possible solutions, and gave the document to everyone we could think of. The Leadership Council posted it on their website. Ideas included:
- Educate elected representatives about these problems.
- Get national data on how many children are sent to live with abusers.
- Prevent violence through the following methods:
- Develop a standard national curriculum for a certification in domestic violence, child abuse, substance abuse.
- Specialized integrated domestic violence courts with multi-disciplinary interview protocol, certified judges.
- Child safety must be the highest priority.
- Use domestic violence risk/danger/lethality screening.
- Integrate the domestic violence community to help develop qualifications and standards.
- Use child trauma screening by child abuse experts.
- Use of civil burden of proof – preponderance of the evidence.
- If criminal burden met, that is prima facie evidence of abuse.
- No mediation with abusers.
- Prohibit urging removal of protective orders.
- Protective orders for adult victims must cover children who witness domestic violence.
- No mutual protection orders. The dominant aggressor needs to be identified.
- Define primary aggressor and presume that domestic violence primary aggressors, child abuser, habitual substance abuser have only supervised contact until strict interventions are completed.
- Supervised visits only for violent parents, with training/standards for monitors.
- Prohibit unsupervised visits with sex offenders.
- Allow children to seek safety on their own if court will not provide safety.
- Court process
- Move case expeditiously through the process to protect children.
- Approximation standard (parent who does the most caretaking) be the default when no abuse.
- Low-income parents must be represented if the other parent is represented.
- Disallow improper delegation of judicial authority to appointees, employees.
- Prohibit retaliation.
- Prohibit ex parte hearings – null and void if party is not noticed or present.
- No coerced stipulations and agreements.
- Open courts and records.
- Admit all admissible evidence.
- Videotape interviews.
- Disallow gag orders so litigants can speak publicly about their case.
- Allow self-represented litigants to speak and be treated with respect.
- Have customer satisfaction surveys.
- Use clear language: a man abused a woman, not a woman was abused by man.
- Jury trials.
- Limit judicial and quasi-judicial immunity.
- Recusal heard by a separate judge.
- Make it easier to recall judges.
- Have competency exams.
- No appointments of professionals.
- Judicial review by citizens for oversight.
- Stronger oversight.
- Court-appointees/employees
- Only gather facts and not make recommendations.
- Children can dismiss advocates or attorneys if no protection/wishes.
- Child attorneys and appointees must be paid by the court.
- Limit to area of expertise.
- Use proper investigations for allegations of DV, child abuse, substance abuse.
- Use standard data gathering instrument.
- Prohibit court-connected (appointed) professionals.
- Cap fees and number of cases.
- Litigants do not need to reimburse if did not want professional.
- Allow litigants to seek appropriate therapy, not court-appointed therapists.
- Disallow treatment to convince a child that abuse did not occur.
- Disallow junk science.
- Children as parties
- Define “best interests” highest priority as “child physical/sexual safety.”
- Use a multi-disciplinary interview team to interview children.
- Children allowed to testify directly.
- Talk with child, place with safe parent.
- Use volunteer Court Appointed Special Advocates, not paid attorneys.
- At age 12, develop own custody plan unless chooses offender.
- Oversight
- Administrative review of cases where children forced to live with abusers by an entity outside judiciary such as the Attorney General or a statewide grand jury, or an independent citizen review/oversight committee, or a grievance committee with domestic violence and child abuse expertise with power to remove a child to safe parent if they are being abused.
- Court watch.
- Discipline and remove professionals who show favoritism or gender bias or endanger children.
- Congress investigate misuse of federal funding.
- Sanctions against abusers and courts.
- Consider a class action for children over 18.
- Obey all human rights statutes, treaties, due process, constitutional law.
The outpouring of ideas was wonderful, and many echoed those of previous Task Forces. The Family Court Reform Coalition (FCRC) was formed, with CPPA as one of the founding members. It was a coalition of 80 professionals and battered women who lost custody, a strong national advocacy group. It was not structured as an official organization, but rather an email list moderated by Irene Weiser.
The Family Court Reform Coalition (FCRC) was formed… a coalition of 80 professionals and battered women who lost custody.
There was another tangible outcome several years after the Albany BMCC Truth Commission. After a publisher from Civic Research Institute read the report, she asked Mo Hannah and Barry Goldstein to write a book. As a result, Domestic Violence, Abuse and Child Custody: Legal Strategies and Policy Issues was published in April 2010.
The California Partnership to End Domestic Violence (CPEDV) fact sheet showed U.S. statistics that were worse than we had imagined. More than 1 in 3 women experienced rape, physical violence, and/or stalking by an intimate partner in their lifetime.
Dianne Cranley founded Talk About Abuse to Liberate Kids (TAALK) that year, but we did not connect until years later. She focused on identifying the signs of grooming, to prevent the next step of contact sexual abuse from happening. Her book 8 Ways to Create Their Fate: Protecting the Sexual Innocence of Children in Youth-Serving Organizations and training have been embraced by insurance companies that were tired of paying out huge sums when schools and other organizations did not prevent the sexual abuse of children in their charge.
We were invited to join CPEDV as an affiliate organization. They had great lobbying tips.
- First, an honest story about real people. We had those.
- Next, do your research to find out what issues interest the Legislator and put yourself in their shoes as they might imagine the headlines on your bill idea.
- Finally, get to know people your Legislator knows and build coalitions.
We joined CPEDV on February 13, 2007 for their Legislative Day. It was fun and exciting. We learned how it was supposed to be done, and it seemed to make a difference.
That day, we met in person with Assemblywoman Sally Lieber and her staff member Barry Steinhart and asked her to author a bill to stop corporal punishment of children. We nearly fell over when she said yes. A week later, on February 22, she authored AB 755.

I was even more amazed that she was forced to change the initial language from prohibiting hitting a child to prohibiting hitting a child with an implement. She tried to amend CA Penal Code 273a to read “authorize the finder of fact to consider the use of an implement, the throwing, kicking, burning, or cutting of a child, the striking a child with a closed fist, the striking a child under the age of 3 on the face or head, the vigorous shaking of a child under the age of 3, the interference with a child’s breathing, or the brandishing of a deadly weapon upon a child when determining whether or not a defendant willfully caused any child to suffer, or inflicted unjustifiable physical pain or mental suffering on a child.”
What could possibly be more reasonable?
We were stunned at the overwhelming opposition, led by religious groups. The bill died a in the Appropriations Committee, as did my trust in groups that clung to Old Testament ideas of sparing the rod. Did they also believe in an eye for an eye and sacrificing goats? It was quite a lesson in power politics. Churches even brought in teenagers to defend their right to be hit. The teens testified they needed to be hit so they would do right.
They must not have read the research in The Case Against Corporal Punishment of Children: Converging Evidence From Social Science Research and International Human Rights Law and Implications for U.S. Public Policy by Elizabeth Gershoff and S. H. Bitensky on how corporal punishment actually increases oppositional and aggressive behavior. They clearly missed what Jesus said regarding little children. They did not understand what Jesus would think about adult bullies who hit the little children He cherished.