“When I despair, I remember that all through history the way of truth and love have always won. There have been tyrants and murderers, and for a time, they can seem invincible, but in the end, they always fall. Think of it–always.”
Mahatma Gandhi
On February 21, 2007 Assemblyman Ira Ruskin authored AB 612 to address the use of Parental Alienation Syndrome (PAS). The language was amended and ultimately provided that “nonscientific labels and diagnoses that are not consistent with diagnostic or medical standards generally accepted by the medical, psychiatric and psychological communities are specifically excluded as allowable diagnoses for court use as part of a child custody evaluation.” His excellent staff member Elise Flynn Gyore was strong, savvy and ready for the coming pushback from fathers’ rights proponents and others who stood to lose from the bill.


The court industry went into shock. They immediately marshaled their forces to make sure the bill failed. We had no idea how clever their plan would be. The bill wound its circuitous way through the Assembly Judiciary Committee, the Assembly floor vote, the Senate Judiciary Committee and got to the Senate floor.
It was abruptly sent to the inactive file by Senator Ellen Corbett, who had voted for it merely a month before. This was odd, since we had found that once a bill makes it through the committee vetting, it is pretty much pro forma for the rest to vote yes on it. Usually.
I smelled a rat.
Assemblyman Ruskin began the bill again the following year.
To our surprise, Elise had been recruited and left her position to work for Senator Ron Calderon who insisted she come to work right away, although he did not even have a desk or an office for her. Assemblyman Ruskin’s new staff member Valerie was smart but did not have the same fighter personality type as Elise. Valerie and I attended a preliminary meeting with a family law attorney, an appellate attorney and a problematic psychologist. It was daunting, to say the least, and we were outmaneuvered.
The bill was halted again on August 25, 2008, first by Senator Corbett, then by Senator Ron Calderon. He shipped it off to the inactive file where the bill died again. Kind Assemblyman Ruskin probably never thought of this as tricky pushback. We thought the recruitment of Elise was planned.
Later, the FBI raided Senator Ron Calderon’s office. There was yellow tape across the door. It was shocking to see. He was accused of accepting bribes for legislation regarding workers’ compensation and pleaded not guilty to 24 charges of wire fraud, bribery, money laundering and falsification of tax returns. He later pled guilty to mail fraud and was sentenced to 42 months in prison. His brother Assemblyman Thomas Calderon pled guilty to money-laundering. They were not the best of the best.
April 6, 2007 was a big day. We held a Legislative briefing at the State Capitol to present information on the family court crisis. We discussed the estimated 100,000 divorce cases in California each year. 50,000 involved one or more children. Reports of child sexual abuse were nearly always ignored even though less than 2% of custody cases had child sex abuse allegations and only a tiny few were considered maliciously fabricated, mostly alleged by fathers. We referred staff members to the Child Sexual Abuse Fact Sheet for more information.
A contingent of father rights proponents drove all the way up from San Diego to attend and contradict us when we said children need safety. One said out loud to me, in a very loud voice with his beet red face right up in mine, that he believed children needed fathers even when those fathers beat or sexually abused them.
One (father) said out loud to me, in a very loud voice with his beet red face right up in mine, that he believed children needed fathers even when those fathers beat or sexually abused them.
Agreeing we needed a national lobbying platform with structure to be a federal umbrella for the smaller local groups in various states, Marivic helped our coalition begin planning. We launched the National Safe Child Coalition the same day as the Legislative briefing. We started methodically meeting with Legislators in Sacramento, following the lobbying training by the domestic violence agencies, while mothers met with their own Legislators locally, armed with one-page summaries of their cases.
On April 7, 2007 we held the Thirteenth Annual Child Sexual Abuse Awareness conference The Abuse Survivor Movement and the Backlash. Our keynote speaker professor Randy Noblitt Ph.D. and his wife Pamela Perskin Noblitt discussed the False Memory Syndrome and Parental Alienation Syndrome, both used to discredit abuse allegations, one for adults and the other for children. They too were puzzled by the strangely lukewarm media attention to child abuse. They had written Cult and Ritual Abuse: Its History, Anthropology and Recent Discovery in Contemporary America back in 1995, another wonderfully validating book.

Karen led an excellent Courageous Kids panel discussing Child Abuse or Alienation? One of the young women had received a scholarship to Harvard after writing her entrance essay about her participation in Courageous Kids Network. Meera Fox and Marivic Mabanag led a Safe Child Coalition workshop and gave proposed solutions. Meera rocked back on her heels and parried the strutting fathers’ rights men who had showed up to heckle, with elegant and powerful words and a piercing gaze right at them. They wilted. We had music and a pizza party celebration. It was hard to remember to celebrate, but we needed it to keep our spirits up.
On May 11, 2007, as a Mother’s Day tribute, Arizona human rights attorney Dianne Post filed a petition on behalf of ten protective mothers and one adult child with the Inter-American Commission for Human Rights for violations of the American Declaration of the Rights and Duties of Man. Two of the cases were CPPA members, and two other California cases were presented under seal due to the danger of retribution.

CA NOW and Irene Weiser from Stop Family Violence coordinated the media. We had a media event at the State Capitol in Northern California and one in Southern California with actress Nancy Lee Gran.

We were so pleased. We waited expectantly for a reply and investigation.
Once again, nothing.
The petition has languished ever since then, with little acknowledgement and no action. It felt like we were constantly walking through hip-deep mud.
Attorney and former prosecutor Wendy Murphy said it well in the title of her 2007 book And Justice for Some: An Expose of the Lawyers and Judges Who Let Dangerous Criminals Go Free.

The year before, Colin Ross M.D. had updated his earlier book Bluebird: Deliberate Creation of Multiple Personality by Psychiatrists and renamed it The CIA Doctors: Human Rights Violations by American Psychiatrists.
Based on original documents received from his Freedom of Information Act request, Dr. Ross exposed the United States Central Intelligence Agency funding of top-secret experiments from 1950-1972 at leading universities including Harvard, Yale, Cornell, Johns Hopkins and Stanford. He also exposed cruel mind control programs including BLUEBIRD, ARTICHOKE, MKULTRA, MKSEARCH and MKNAOMI. Most ritual abuse survivors had been reporting government mind control training in childhood, in addition to dark religious rituals.
These books lent credence to survivors’ memories.