Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 2: Into the Street

“Protest against injustices belongs only to honorable and courageous people!”

Mehmet Murat İldan.

On February 1, there was yet another Elkins Family Law Task Force meeting in San Francisco, even though they had already launched AB 939, the bill to implement the Task Force findings. This was well in advance of their final report, which was issued two months later.

AB 939 ignored our pleas for child safety.  They mandated laws that appeared to be the exact opposite of the California Supreme Court ruling that witnesses and due process were crucial in family court and were still substituting in the concept of “case management.”

All these meetings were after the fact, since the train had already left the station. Attorney Barbara Kauffman was fabulous, talking about the need for oversight. The Task Force members would not meet our eyes.

We went outside and across the street, unfurled our big banners protesting the placement of children of divorce with abusers. 

Safety First protest

By a quirk of fate, we met whistleblower Michael Paul. He told us that the Judicial Council had been hiring unlicensed construction contractors without the required bidding process.  57 whistleblowers had been fired.

Chief Justice Ronald George (also known as “King George” by his subjects) was on the hotseat with the Legislature. Kathleen and I started methodically visiting Legislators.

We, along with two unions, American Federal, State and Municipal Employees (AFSCME) and Service Employees Internation Union (SEIU). and the newly formed Alliance of California Judges, urged them to vote to authorize and fund a formal audit of Marin and Sacramento court mediators.

They did. We were thrilled. I was so impressed at how Kathleen’s idea and connections worked.

Somehow, she also managed to get a meeting with Lynn Rosenthal at the White House.

The White House

A few weeks later, FCRC’s Irene Weiser also received a call from Lynn Rosenthal to talk about federal policy. Our main ideas were to:

  1. Hold Congressional hearings and have a Congressional Resolution.
  2. Put the Access to Visitation program under VAWA.
  3. Request a GAO performance and fiscal investigation into the Fatherhood programs.
  4. Make receipt of child support optional to reduce the financial incentive for custody.

Back in California, on February 19, 2010 Assemblyman Jim Beall from Santa Clara County authored AB 2475. It started out limiting the immunity of private custody evaluators and mediators, was changed to standardizing the complaint process, and died in the Appropriations Committee. There was a pattern of effective bills not making it out of that committee.

Karen and I met with Sacramento Presiding Judge Thomas Cecil and Sacramento Family Court Presiding Judge Julie Setzer on February 25. Judge DeAnn Salcido had recommended that strategy. They had contacted us in response to our letter about the crimes against children by Sacramento family court. They listened to our reasons for suggesting they move twice-reprimanded Judge Peter McBrien to another court where he could not harm children.

Judge Cecil was sarcastic and mean at first, then mellowed out.  He seemed to like Karen and opened up, agreeing that child sex abuse was a real thing, and that children should not be transferred to an identified offender. But we’d seen that look before. Patronizing. Pretending to not be annoyed by us.  

Nothing came of it.

We went to a Women Dialogue meeting in Sacramento and spoke with Secretary of State Debra Bowen and Assemblywoman Mariko Yamada. They said they would help.

Nothing.

Meanwhile, the California Bureau of State Audits (BSA) began working on the audit of Marin and Sacramento Superior Courts regarding the lack of qualifications and training for mediators.  It appeared to be a dry bureaucratic remedy. It stalled out temporarily, then became bureaucratic high drama.

After the two courts refused to yield their records, BSA threatened them a subpoena.

Later we found out Marin court was busily shredding a huge quantity of mediator notes, pretending they were not used in court, which was entirely untrue. Attorney Barbara Kauffman was clear that these were essential documents in hearings and trials. Marin had something to hide.

The Elkins Family Law Task Force was formed to implement the conclusions of People v Elkins Contra Costa Superior Court. “A local superior court rule and a trial scheduling order in the family law court provided that in dissolution trials, parties must present their case by means of written declarations. The testimony of witnesses under direct examination was not allowed except in “unusual circumstance.” 

To repeat, this was not how courts are supposed to work. Declarations are hearsay (out-of-court statements that are usually inadmissible in court) and family court needed to operate like any other court by allowing witnesses to testify under oath.

The Elkins Family Law Task Force was formed to improve court processes. It had 38 members. The Task Force was not part of the Judicial Council, but its members were judges and court personnel. Four of the judges on the Task Force were well known to the mother’s movement for placing children at risk.

The Task Force published its findings in April. The report began with a quote from the Elkins case. “In light of the volume of cases faced by trial courts, we understand their efforts to streamline family law procedures. But family law litigants should not be subjected to second-class status or deprived of access to justice….”.  They pointed out that:

  • Over 75% of family law cases have at least one self-represented party.
  • Issues of child custody, support and property may be complex.
  • Many people cannot afford $300 per hour attorneys with $5,000 retainer.
  • People who start out with attorneys at the beginning of their cases often run out of money and become self-represented before their cases are over.

To our surprise, the Task Force made recommendations regarding child safety and domestic violence procedures, thanks to our input.  An entire section was dedicated to improving domestic violence procedures, investigating abuse allegations, piloting the use of “3118 investigations” that required that specific information be brought to the court on the parents’ history of abuse, and obtaining the child’s participation.

We were very grateful that Chairwoman Zelon had heard us and was concerned.

But it was to no avail. The Legislators in the Judiciary Committee had already written AB 939 to roll out the recommendations of the Task Force way before the report was even written. There was not even a nod to the suffering children, despite the recommendations of the Task Force, in the new bill AB 939. The section of the report on child safety was basically ignored. We had no idea how to counteract this bait and switch. The nuances were subtle, and the story never made its way to the press.

I finally looked at a list of the members who served on the California Judicial Council, the top policy-making body over the huge California court system.  Oddly, Senator Ellen Corbett and Assemblyman Mike Feuer were among the 21 voting members. Was it appropriate to have two branches of government blended together in an interlocking directorate? That is when two companies have the same people on their respective boards of directors, thus linking them together.

Was it appropriate to have two branches of government blended together in an interlocking directorate? 

Were the two Legislators there to keep an eye on the judiciary to protect the public? We were concerned, at least at the appearance of impropriety, if not the possibility for collusion.

It made for strange optics in separation of governmental powers of Executive, Legislative and Judicial branches to have 10% of head of the Judiciary made up of Legislators from another branch of government.  It completely contradicted the concept of “checks and balances” among the three branches of government. Kim Turner, Executive Officer of the notorious Marin County Superior Court was on their 7-member Advisory Board.  That was an even stranger optic.

The two-day Sixteenth Annual Child Sexual Abuse Awareness conference, cosponsored by Incest Survivors Speakers Bureau (ISSB), California Protective Parents Association (CPPA) and International Violence, Abuse and Trauma (IVAT), began on April 9, 2010 at the Sierra Health Foundation in Sacramento.  The topic was Whistleblower Children: What Happens When Children Report Sex Abuse?

Obviously, like other whistleblowers, they face severe retaliation. We had a wonderful film festival, showing documentaries Family Court Crisis: Our Children at Risk, Pray the Devil Back to Hell and two Cavalcade films on the Effects of Adverse Childhood Experiences.

The second day, former Los Angeles prosecutor and television personality Robin Sax spoke at the Veterans’ Memorial Center in Davis, along with the Yolo County District Attorney’s office, on prosecuting cases of child sex abuse.

former Los Angeles prosecutor and television personality Robin Sax

We held a West Coast Truth Commission, for mothers to speak out about how their child abuse cases were handled. It was painful to hear their histories. 

The Yolo County Multidisciplinary Team panel presentation led by Cameron Handley was excellent. They showed just how well one small county could come together to tackle child sexual abuse. Appellate attorney Tony Tanke and Nina Salarno from Crime Victims United spoke.

Cameron Handley

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.