Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 4:  The Wheels of Government Go Round and Round

“Let them eat cake”

Attributed to Marie Antoinette

On the international front, the next to last holdout, Somalia, finally ratified the 1985 United Nation Convention of the Child in 2015. 

children laughing in a field of flowers

That meant that U.S. children were the only children in the entire world who were not considered human beings with human rights.

angry children standing in a line

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights held a hearing in Washington on the lack of implementation of their recommendations in the United States based on the Jessica Gonzales case.

By now, I was beginning to feel deeply ashamed of my country

On March 25, lobbyist Melissa, attorneys Barbara Kaufman and Kim Robinson, and advocates Kathleen Russell, Steve Burdo and I met with Amanda Levy from Family Law Executive Committee (FLEXCOM) and staff member Catalina Sanchez about SB 594 (Wieckowski).

Judicial Council staff said that judges were rarely ordering 3118 investigations and mediators were not able to obtain criminal background information from law enforcement nor child welfare records in certain counties. Wouldn’t it be easy for the court to order law enforcement and child welfare services to provide their records for 3118 investigations?

I understood the financial disincentive, since courts had to pay for these investigations, and they were using cost containment as a reason to not order investigations. On the other hand, that was the only way to create a neutral investigation, and the statute clearly said the court could have parents repay the cost if they were financially able to do so. 

We explained that when parents with resources stipulated to private mental health evaluators who were then court-appointed under Evidence Code 730, the evaluators received immunity and could not be sued for poor performance even though the parents paid directly.  And if one parent had more money, that parent usually paid more and got the outcome they wanted. It was another Catch 22 for often bankrupted protective mothers. 

Judicial Council staff liked our idea of having a temporary restraining order when a child reports a crime to the Multi-Disciplinary Interview Team (MDIT) or law enforcement, until a criminal court adjudicated the case. This would not only protect the child but would prevent witness tampering.

Judicial Council staff liked our idea of having a temporary restraining order when a child reports a crime to the Multi-Disciplinary Interview Team (MDIT) or law enforcement, until a criminal court adjudicated the case.

Our Twenty-First Annual Child Sexual Abuse Awareness Conference was held on April 12, 2015, at the Veterans Memorial Center in Davis. Barry Goldstein was the keynote speaker. He talked about his book, The Quincy Solution; Best Practices that Dramatically Reduce Domestic Violence Crime and Child Abuse and Save $500 Billion.  

The key was to have a coordinated community response with strong law enforcement involvement with immediate consequences for breaking restraining orders.

Our guest speaker was California Senator Ricardo Lara who spoke openly as a sexual abuse survivor. He was terrific. He said that speaking out about his abuse was healing. We had always maintained it was worth a year of therapy.

Senator Ricardo Lara

Will Arnold from Senator Lois Wolk’s office was also great. Methodist Pastor David Isom was enthusiastic about Solano County’s Family Justice Center. Mashan from the Sheriff’s office talked about being a domestic violence victim.

The Multi-Disciplinary Interview Center staff, Jonathan Raven from the Distinct Attorney’s office, Jane Stevens, Tracy Favre from the Court Appointed Special Advocates (CASA) program and Celine Alvarez from the Yolo County domestic violence center Empower Yolo gave updates.  An impromptu protective mothers’ panel with one protective father was excellent.

Former Yolo and San Diego County Deputy District Attorney Jean Jordan, Executive Director of Administrative Services at Violence Against Women and Victims of Crime in Sacramento, spoke about the county’s lukewarm approach to a Family Justice Center and Domestic Violence Court. She said the efforts were floundering due to lack of leadership.

Advocates were clearly pushing a boulder up a hill to get state-of-the-art protocols implemented in Yolo County. Turf wars were part of it, but I suspected there was a strong undercurrent of batterers and molesters, not to mention ritual abusers, who were quietly blocking things behind the scenes.  The undertow pulled the tide backwards after each wave forward.

Singers Mattieu Jean-Pierre and his brother drove up to sing to us.

The next day, Barry Goldstein and I went to the Legislature to meet with staff from Senators Leno, Wieckowski, Wolk, Anderson and Jackson’s offices. The staff member from Joel Anderson’s office was writing his thesis on childhood obesity and had never heard of the Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) study. We told him all about it.

I explained to Barry that the Judicial Council had told us that they would only create a form to implement Family Code section 3118 if the Legislature told them to. When SB 594 (Wieckowski) was released to tell them to do just that, they objected vehemently. Judicial Council immediately sent a plaintive three-page letter of opposition to on April 16, 2015.

Barry Goldstein

They said a form “would cause a severe workload increase on courts, be difficult or impossible to implement, and would limit the information judicial officers receive in attempting to make decisions on child custody matters.”  The letter said a checklist for evaluators, investigators and mediators to follow to ensure they follow all the requirements of the Family Code was an attempt to create a one-size-fits-all solution.

A week later I sent our letter of support for the bill. 

Our team met with Judicial Council Representative Alan Hershfield and Senator Wieckowski’s staff.  Kim Robinson fired off a list of pertinent appellate cases, which was quite effective. Alan was gruff at first but backed off when we decided to just require the template for evaluators, not court mediators.

We were amazed at the objections made by Association of Family and Conciliation Court (AFCC) representative Diane Waznicki (Josie Cohen’s former husband’s attorney) and Diane Fetzer from Family Law Executive Committee (FLEXCOM) and their team.

On April 17, when we arrived at the Judicial Council to talk about SB 594, the guard talked into his phone, saying there were several “Red Shirts” coming. I loved that. But after the meetings, Senator Wieckowski decided to back down.  He changed the language to say that custody evaluators would simply be required to follow the law.

Attorney Barbara Kauffman testified about SB 594 (Wieckowski) to ensure evaluators obey the laws and rules of court.

On May 5, we went to the Senate Judiciary hearing in Room 112 to testify for the completely watered down SB 594. You could have heard a pin drop with Roberta Fitzpatrick’s testimony about the murder of her grandniece Alycia. 20 or 30 of us said “me too.”

Senator Moorelach, a CPA, kept asking, “Why don’t they have a checklist?” Exactly.

The Judicial Council went neutral. The Association of Family and Conciliation Courts (AFCC) and certified Family Law representatives sounded pathetically lame testifying against the bill. Senator Hannah Beth Jackson leaned over her podium at one point, fixed them with her piercing gaze, and asked if they really meant that custody evaluators should not have to obey minimum standards of the law.  Exactly. The neutered SB 594 passed 7-0.  Evaluators must obey the law. It was another Pyrrhic victory.  

We went to Hannah Beth Jackson’s reception and thanked her, then Kathleen and I talked about Joint Legislative Audit Committee (JLAC) findings. She wanted a copy.

Dave Greenwald of the Davis Vanguard Court Watch of Yolo County, who normally focused on criminal court, had attended a family court hearing with me and was duly shocked at the three-ring circus.  He said it was far, far worse than criminal court abuses. Yes, it was.

Dave Greenwald of the Davis Vanguard Court Watch of Yolo County

He invited Kathleen to be the keynote speaker at a Vanguard fundraiser in Davis on May 9 titled Family Court Crisis: Who Will Protect the Children?  Supervisor Jim Provenza and Senator Wieckowski’s staff Catalina Sanchez were there.

Kathleen gave an outstanding talk. “The most basic problem in California family courts is that there is a complete lack of oversight or accountability over a burgeoning cottage industry that has sprung up there, and those working in the system are making A LOT of money with virtually no one checking on whether they are following the laws or rules of court, and they are fighting to keep it that way.”

Yes, they certainly were.

It reminded me of the protective grandmother who described seeing her former son-in-law hand a Chicago judge an envelope stuffed with cash “for his campaign fund” just before their family law case began.  The attorneys told her that was not illegal.

The Eleventh Annual Battered Mothers Custody Conference Battered Women, Abused Children and Child Custody: An International Crisis, Hands Across the Water was held on May 15-17, 2015 in Secaucus, New Jersey. We saw old friends and met new ones. Conference coordinator Mo Hannah had a knack for creating a wonderful atmosphere that combined information and healing. The conferences were class acts.

Actress Kelly Rutherford, also a class act, took part in the conference that year.  Her children had been shipped off to Europe by a California family court because their father was too much of a criminal to be allowed in the United States.

Actress Kelly Rutherford

We presented a workshop about Mothers of Lost Children and again offered t-shirts for those who wanted to attend the upcoming march in October.

Mothers Against Court Custody Abuse MACCAbuse.com was formed by protective mother Doreen Ludwig, who wrote three exposes of the ruthless bureaucratic engine that stripped children from mothers and gave them to abusive fathers:

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.