Digital Museum of Childhood

Chapter 5: Pushing Forward

“Most of the important things in the world have been accomplished by people who have kept on trying when there seemed to be no hope at all.”

Dale Carnegie

Advocate Barry Goldstein developed The Safe Child Act. The salient points were:

  • The paramount concern of all custody decisions must be to provide safety for the children.
  • No parent can be penalized for a good faith complaint of domestic violence or child abuse.
  • If there are allegations of domestic violence or child abuse, courts shall not encourage parents to cooperate (as in “high conflict” cases.)
  • Any history of restraining orders, criminal history or other evidence of domestic violence shall be presented at an evidentiary hearing at the beginning of the case.
  • Lack of substantiation by child welfare or lack of prosecution by the district attorney are not to be treated as proof the abuse did not happen.  
  • Abuse allegations are investigated only by a qualified experts with substantial experience and training in domestic violence and child abuse. A graduate degree in mental health is not proof of expertise.
  • Allegations of child sexual abuse are investigated only be professionals with specialized training and at least five years of working with sexually abused children.
  • Allegations of domestic violence must include a risk assessment.
  • A full evidentiary hearing must be held.
  • Parents have a right to an expert of their choosing.
  • Only valid scientific research is admissible.
  • If the court finds there is domestic violence or child physical or sexual abuse using the preponderance of the evidence burden of proof, custody is awarded to the safer parent.
  • Accused abusive parents receive supervised visits, or no contact, until they complete a 52-week batterer treatment program, accept full responsibility for past abuse and convince the court that there is no risk of harm to the child with unsupervised visitation.
  • The use of flawed practices in prior decisions is considered a change of circumstances and the court shall reconsider decisions based on those previous practices, using proper practices.

In May 2015, Mary Kernic published the Final Report of the Impact of Legal Representation on Child Custody Decisions among Families with a History of Intimate Partner Violence Study sponsored by the National Institute of Justice. It cited studies showing:

  • 7 million children experience severe parental intimate partner violence per year.
  •  150,000 dissolutions occur every year involving child witnesses to the violence.
  • Children exposed to parental violence have multiple adverse outcomes.
  • Continuous conflict after divorce is a primary risk factor for emotional well-being.
  • Having an attorney helped protect children, especially a Legal Aid attorney.

Not surprisingly, the study found that having legal representation leads to greater protections for children.  The surprise was that legal aid attorneys appeared to keep children safer than private attorneys did.

Legal Aid AttorneyPrivate Attorney
2.5% of victims had a legal aid attorney59% of victims had a private attorney
The abuser was 85% more likely to be denied visitation when the victim had a legal aid attorney than when the victim had no attorney.The abuser was no more likely to be denied visitation when the victim had a private attorney than when the victim had no attorney.
The victim was 46% more likely to receive sole decision-making ability when the victim had a legal aid attorney than when the victim had no attorney.The victim was no more likely to receive sole decision-making ability when the victim had a private attorney than when the victim had no attorney.

One confounding factor was that rich abusers are protected in ways that poor abusers are not, due access to expensive attorneys, so cases with legal aid attorneys for poor litigants may have different dynamics. Most initially well-off victim mothers ended up impoverished after spending all their money on private attorneys, evaluators and other professionals, but generally had no idea that legal aid attorneys even existed.

person putting finger on scale

Back in California, we stepped directly into the case of convicted pedophile Nicholas Elizondo. He had gone to prison for molesting his six-year-old daughter in 1995. He was then given custody of his second daughter when she turned six, in Oklahoma in 2013. We were appalled and felt smugly safe in California. But then Nicholas and his little daughter moved to Bakersfield CA.  We managed to find a pro bono attorney for her mother Lisa Knight through Jones Day Law Firm, since the case was so blatantly egregious. It did no good. California Judge James Compton ordered the convicted child molester to retain custody.

The Women’s Coalition and Safe Kids International filed a complaint to United Nations Women showing the human rights violations of children being taken from safe mothers and given to abusers.

Nothing.

That month, an expose by Michael Volpe titled Making Divorce Pay: The Association of Family and Conciliation Courts takes back-scratching to a new level  highlighted the focus of the AFCC on parental alienation, created by the pro-pedophile Richard Gardner M.D., one of accused pedophile Woody Allen’s chief defenders. 

Michael Volpe

The article exposed the shocking histories of Sunny Kelley who spent over $1 million on, unknown to her, AFCC professionals ordered by AFCC judges, and lost her child to an alleged sexually abusive father.  Susan Skipp and Elisabeth Desmond also had AFCC court professionals on their cases.

He exposed AFCC literature recommending a plethora of court professionals who divert attention from abuse by trying to have everyone cooperate. He also exposed the Children’s Rights Council (CRC), co-founded in 1980 by Meyer Elkin who also founded the AFCC in Los Angeles in 1963, as the lead organization promoting equal parenting. CRC and AFCC have multiple cross over high ranking members (much like Dr. Joylen West was a subcontractor for the CIA MK ULTRA experiments and also on the False Memory Syndrome Foundation board.)

The article exposed Joshua Komisarjevsky who used a federal program for prisoners and parolees to try to gain access to his daughter, and later murdered 4 people, and Beltway Sniper John Allen Muhammad who used federal program, overseen by AFCC member Jessica Pearson, to try to gain access to his children.  Pearson is president of the Center for Policy Research, consultant to the US DHHS Office of Child Support Enforcement, putting her in a position to steer fatherhood grant funding to other AFCC members.

Volpe posed the dilemma succinctly. “Pseudo-science from an obscure psychiatrist is promoted by a group until it is accepted by family courts. The bad science allows any abuser to explain away their abusive actions and use it to his advantage in divorce proceedings.

This same group then calls all abusive situations ‘conflicts,’ thereby putting the blame on all parties including the abuse victim and bringing in numerous bureaucrats to resolve the ‘conflict.’ They promote a theory which asks both parties to work together in all situations except proven abuse, knowing full well that bureaucrats will never accept proof.” 

It made one’s head spin. It was meant to.

Also in 2015, war correspondent Keith Harmon Snow published The Worst Interests of the Child: The Trafficking of Children and Parents Through U. S. Family Courts. In his introduction, he called this practice “organized crime.”

Lundy Bancroft wrote in his review, ““Keith Harmon Snow’s meticulously documented investigation into sex-trafficking of children by American judges is not to be missed. This scandal is one of the most important censored stories in our country today. I might not believe what Mr. Snow has written if I had not independently investigated two dozen cases not discussed in his article and found ample evidence of the precise dynamics he lays out for us here. Anyone who says they care about child welfare needs to learn what is happening in family courts and take action until it is stopped. Once you start reading this exposé, you won’t be able to put it down.”

Assemblyman Brian Maienschein’s bill AB 217 passed. It required the juvenile court to let children aged 10 and older know they could address the court and participate in their dependency court hearings. Earlier legislation made sure the children received a notice of hearings, and the court made sure they were there if they wanted to be, unless the court determined it was not in their best interests.

Assemblyman Brian Maienschein

Although I suspected this law did not roll out exactly as expected, since juvenile court hearings were closed and nobody knew what was really going on, it seemed the concept of giving children a voice in court was a good one and maybe it would work in family court.

It was a steep learning curve.

We knew we needed powerful people to help, since we had been shown often how truly powerless we were.  We just didn’t know how to make that happen. But we were also a stubborn and persistent group.

Did the definition of insanity as doing the same thing over and over again while expecting different results, apply here?

On August 21, we spoke again at the Judicial Council. I said that little Madeline Fay Samaan and Alicia Mesiti’s blood was on my hands because I could not convince the Judicial Council to put child safety first.

On August 22, we went to National Plan to End Interpersonal Violence (NPEIV) Think Tank in San Diego.  Advocates Kathleen Russell, Diane Cranley, Rick Froyd, Joyce Baarck, and Maralee McLean were there. There was lots of talk but little action in our Action Team #5 on public policy, although both the Sexual Assault and Corporal Punishment Policy Statements were finished. 

State Senator Alan Solano from South Dakota thought state efforts were best.  Victor Veith and Joyce Thomas, presented, along with attorney Ron LeGrand who said he had taken our 4 binders of mothers movement material with him when he left the House Judiciary Committee to begin working at National Network to End Domestic Violence (NNEDV.)

It was disconcerting to know that after we made wonderful contacts, they often left their positions.

We were eternally grateful that George Washington University law professor Joan Meier picked up the Congressional Resolution idea.  She and Dawn Dalton from DV LEAP helped us place the Congressional Resolution with Texas Congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee, a Senior Member of the House Judiciary Committee who seemed eager at first.

Joan Meier, Eileen King, and Dawn Dalton said we needed to ask for co-sponsors and get supporters for the Resolution. We could do that. I started with my Congressman John Garamendi, asking him to be a cosponsor. His aide Andrew March was quite negative.

[W]e needed to ask for co-sponsors and get supporters for the Resolution. We could do that.

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.