“The future depends on what you do today.”
Mahatma Gandhi
A few days later, on October 1, 2010 Mothers of Lost Children again converged on Washington DC for a second demonstration. This time it was during Domestic Violence month, and we were demonstrating in front of the federal U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) at 950 Pennsylvania Ave NW to protest the cruel treatment of children placed with criminal violent, incestuous fathers.
Protective grandmother Helen and her husband Jim had spent their anniversary at the demonstration. Her daughter had finally been released from prison after New York attorney Toby Kleinman alerted the media to investigate. Federal attorney Richard Fine had also been freed.
Our bullhorn was great. Karen was blocked from going into the DOJ building with our packet, but their public relations people came out to meet us and took the packet after protective mother Donnette called them.
We then marched to the U.S. Senate building while Channel 9 filmed. The mothers in our white t-shirts met with 18 Senate offices, including Dianne Feinstein, Orrin Hatch, and Arlen Specter. We had good talking points. Advocates Rita Smith, Barry Goldstein and Joan Zorza met with Chairman Patrick Leahy and Tom Harkin’s staff.

We met at the Sewall Belmont House for photos.
The next day, we unfurled the big banner and stood vigil at the White House, then marched to 17th Street and joined the big One Nation march to the Lincoln Memorial with throngs of union and peace marchers. It felt like the 1960s. I loved it.
Two days later, we took packets of information about the family court crisis to 10 Senators and met with Barbara Boxer’s staff, Al Franken’s Chief Counsel and Jennifer Tarr from Susan Colllin’s office.
We did not have a solution, but felt it was critical to let Congress know the problem which we proposed to be civil rights violations of women and their children.
Back in California, fifty or sixty people, including some good men, showed up for a demonstration at the Marin Civic Center on October 12, organized by Center for Judicial Excellence. After speaking at the Marin Board of Supervisors to ask for an investigation into the cases in family court in which children were placed with their identified abusers, some of us drove across the Golden Gate Bridge to picket the Judicial Council for an hour, just for sport.
It just seemed right to be in the streets. Polite requests to protect children were not working. We wanted solutions but had none. We figured that civil rights demonstrations were essential.
A coalition of strong groups, California Partnership to End Domestic Violence (CPEDV), California Court Appointed Special Advocates (CalCASA,) Peace Over Violence, and Family Violence Prevention hosted a policy training event in Los Angeles on October 18 during Domestic Violence month. Congresswoman Judy Chu, who had once been a DV counselor attended.

The coalition explained we needed to:
- Influence the public through positive grassroots action, with visuals and statistics, like the group who took a pink RV mobile billboard cross country. Karen and I had done that with her white pickup truck and a big up sign with Judge Peter “Chainsaw McBrien’s cartoon picture on it.
- Influence the media through angry grassroots action. Robin Sax, an NBC News Legal Analyst who prosecuted child sex abuse crimes, suggested blogging constantly about the issues. Stories would get picked up and we could play one outlet against the other. We needed to get our sound bites down and use words like “atrocious” and “outrageous” to grab attention.
Then something amazing happened.
On October 27, 2010, the White House unveiled the Obama administration’s initiative Commitment to Combatting Violence Against Women, to reduce domestic violence, sexual assault and child abuse. It coordinated multiple government agencies, including the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), Housing and Urban Development (HUD), U.S Department of Justice (DOJ), Department of Treasury (Treasury), U.S. Department of Labor (Labor) and Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC).
Their fact sheet reiterated that one out of every 4 women experiences domestic violence in their lifetime and 20 million U.S. women have been raped, 15.5 million children were exposed to domestic violence, and the impact of trauma lasts for years.
- Children: The Defending Childhood Initiative was launched by the Attorney General, aimed at protecting children from the harmful consequences of witnessing violence.
- Civil protection orders: The Department of Justice would release new tools and guidance for communities to improve issuance and enforcement of protective orders.
- Forums on sexual assault: The White House Council on Women and Girls, headed by senior adviser Valerie Jarrett, and the Department of Justice would host regional forums across the country in the next six months, aimed at reducing sexual assault.
- Legal access: The Department of Justice would launch pilot projects in New Orleans and Baltimore to provide pro bono legal services to victims of domestic violence.
- Maternal, infant and early childhood home visits: Funded by a $1.5 billion health-care legislation set aside over the next five years, it would provide for home visitation services and early intervention in domestic violence and child abuse cases.
- Housing assistance: The Department of Housing and Urban Development would release rules to housing authorities and landlords to ensure that victims of abuse do not lose their housing because of crimes committed against them.
This was a wonderful outcome.
The President was immediately back in my good graces. Whether it was related to our efforts or not, we decided to take some of the credit for our collective advocacy, while giving the majority of kudos to our domestic violence allies. We basked in the victory and felt a big ray of hope. Children were being defended. The federal government was on our side of this issue in a big way.
But still nothing changed at ground zero, in California family courts. None of this directly affected family court judges and their appointees who operated in their own silo, trained to be suspicious of any abuse allegations in a divorce situation and dismissing concerns of protective mothers. In fact, the nooses around children’s necks tightened, as they were shipped off to their batterers’ homes in ever increasing numbers.
TANF Healthy Marriage and Responsible Fatherhood grants totaled $150 million annually, and although the program had added a few token domestic violence protections, these federal dollars went to men, not to women. Women were turned away due to their gender. Wasn’t that illegal? We wrote letters to Congress asking that question, to no avail.
How could that be? We were told by domestic violence advocates that father’s rights advocates had warned that if we had the audacity to touch the fatherhood funding, they would bury us and obliterate the Violence Against Women Act. They had staff within the federal government that could do that, so the threat was taken very seriously.
Father’s rights advocates had warned that if we had the audacity to touch the fatherhood funding, they would bury us and obliterate the Violence Against Women Act.
Checkmate.
Amazingly, I did get a response to my October letter asking Attorney General Eric Holder to investigate family courts in Sacramento, Marin and San Diego. The letter was from the Child Exploitation and Obscenity Section of the DOJ’s Criminal Division. They let us know, again, that child custody and child abuse issues are handled by state and local authorities, not the federal government.
We were aware of that nuance, but these were civil rights violations. Children’s lives and liberty were being trampled on.
They advised us to contact the state government to get better state rules or laws. They suggested parents continue to dialogue with judicial officials to modify their decisions and consult with their attorneys.
Their mildly hopeful comment was that if we believed federal crimes were being committed, we should report to the FBI. They even gave us the San Francisco FBI address, which was right across the street from the Judicial Council. We had already done that.
It was exactly the type of letter I, a bureaucrat flack catcher, used to write for my boss’ signature. It was strange to be on the receiving end. I did appreciate the fact that they put some time and effort into redirecting us.